Northern | US

This feels like a formidable All Blacks squad but the benchmark is perfection

New Zealand huddle at full time during the Nations Championship match between New Zealand All Blacks and France at One New Zealand Stadium, on July 04, 2026 in Christchurch, New Zealand. (Photo by Joe Allison/Nations Championship via Getty Images)
Comments
13 Comments

The nature of the new – and I have to say exciting – Nations Championship is that the show quickly moves on.

ADVERTISEMENT

For a tournament starting from scratch, it’s already generated quite a following. I don’t just base that on the reaction to it here in New Zealand, but the stuff I listen to from overseas.

It almost feels a bit like we’re in the midst of world cup fever, which is no mean feat given FIFA’s got their flagship event on at the moment.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

The attention of All Black fans now turns towards Italy, but I’d hate the coaching staff to overlook what happened against France.

First, credit to New Zealand for their 34-32 win in Christchurch. It was an entertaining game, in which both teams performed creditably.

The All Blacks’ explosiveness and athleticism enabled them to overcome the French and I’d be disappointed if that obscured the disparity in skill.

I thought France taught New Zealand a lesson in using the ball to beat the man and committing defenders.

ADVERTISEMENT

I’m not knocking the All Blacks for having great athletes at their disposal. It’s a nice thing to possess.

But there are times when I think that dumbs down our rugby and we revert to giving the ball to the fast kid or the big kid and hoping they can conjure something out of nothing.

Time and again in Christchurch, I saw the All Blacks ship the ball sideways. It wasn’t draw and pass or anything of the sort, just the shifting of the ball for shifting’s sake.

France, meanwhile, played more direct and used more subtlety in their passing, exposing the All Blacks’ defence on regular occasions. I have to say I found that very pleasing on the eye and it made me recall the skill Ireland showed during their series win on these shores back in 2022.

ADVERTISEMENT

I hope the All Blacks and their coaches take something from what France showed us and look to integrate it into their own repertoire.

Again, I definitely don’t want to diminish the outstanding ability of Will Jordan or minimise Damien McKenzie or Ruben Love’s ability to see chinks in a defensive line and exploit them.

It’s just that what happens when a hole doesn’t open up or you aren’t confronted by a front rower that you can easily run around?

I’m not convinced we genuinely know how to manufacture space or put people through gaps in the way Ireland so memorably did here and France managed last Saturday.

It’s not a criticism of anyone or necessarily even a glaring failing in the All Blacks. But the benchmark with this team is perfection and, to me, this is an obvious area in which they can improve.

This feels like a formidable All Blacks squad. There’s brilliance, there’s grafters and there’s depth.

Going and winning in South Africa later this season seems like a tough assignment, but I continue to be heartened by what I see and hear from the coaching staff.

They’re realists and they won’t get carried away by anything that happens in these opening Nations Championship encounters.

I’d like to think that includes taking heed of how France opened them up defensively. Athleticism is an asset, but it’s not a guarantee of success. Every All Black team possesses plenty, but not all of them are given opportunities when they can demonstrate it.

For as good as France was with the ball on Saturday, they weren’t so impressive without it.

Not every team is going to be so generous.

Nations Championship

Watch Hemispheres collide as North faces South in the brand new Nations Championship. Live matches, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV here

Stream Nations Championship 2026 LIVE

Hemispheres collide in the new Nations Championship. Stream live, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV.

Watch on RPTV
Starts 4th July 2026 - USA only.
ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

13 Comments
N
Nickers 2 days ago

Talk about a dim comparisons.


Ireland’s entire attacking system relies on fast ruck ball to play against a defence that is going backwards and narrowing around the ruck. They then move the ball to where the space is and pick the best runner - sound familiar?


Ironically this is exactly how France were able to score most their tries and put us under huge pressure on Saturday. They had as much lightning fast ball as we did, our defence could not get set and was retreating and narrowing all night. No line speed = space.


The quality of analysis in these articles is extremely poor sometimes.

J
Jordon 2 days ago

Having a 12 playing at centre and Love defending on the left edge, and for one of the tries ardie was out there, did not help. Did the hurricanes ever have Love defending out there??

B
Blackmania 2 days ago

I don’t think that’s correct.

Just look at the first three French tries out of the four. They were all scored after fewer than five rucks. It was France’s quick ball and their ability to execute skilful plays at pace in tight spaces that allowed them to capitalize on New Zealand’s turnovers. They scored those tries within 30 seconds of winning possession and using very few rucks.

The French are exceptional at turning opposition turnovers into attacking opportunities so quickly. They are unquestionably the best team in the world at this aspect of the game.

The last try was more conventional, built through phase play inside the 22 with more than ten rucks.

Comparing Ireland’s style of play to France’s is quite surprising. The difference between the two teams has been obvious over the last two Six Nations tournaments and, more recently, in the European Cup.

L
LondonAllBlack 2 days ago

It does feel formidable, but we really need to shut the door when it comes to our defence!

B
Blackmania 2 days ago

I much agree with that analysis.

The All Blacks relied on their speed at the breakdown to recycle the ball quickly and shift it wide, but without really doing enough to manipulate the defence through the middle first. France, on the other hand, were much more subtle with their short passing in front of the defensive line, like on Penaud’s first try. It was a pre-planned training-ground move, and the players executed it perfectly in the match, reading the situation brilliantly.

French players aren’t the most physically imposing, yet they consistently trouble opponents thanks to their incredibly sharp passing game right on the gain line, and also with their clever kicking game to exploit space behind the defence.

The All Blacks can’t just think, “We’ll win every ruck in under three seconds, move the ball wide, and our athleticism will do the rest.” That was only just enough against what was essentially a French B team. Against France’s first-choice side, it wouldn’t have been enough.

That said, it’s great to see New Zealand rediscovering their willingness to play with tempo and ambition. We’ve missed seeing that. But they’ll still need to sharpen a few aspects of their game if they genuinely want to challenge South Africa in a few weeks.

L
LondonAllBlack 2 days ago

14h of rugby! That’s not feasible. Sorry. I have a family of four lol 😆

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close