Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

The one thing that didn’t surprise Eben Etzebeth about Scotland

By Grant Constable reporting from Edinburgh
A general view as tempers flare between players of Scotland and South Africa during the Autumn Nations Series 2024 match between Scotland and South Africa at the Scottish Gas Murrayfield on November 10, 2024 in Edinburgh, Scotland. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)

While the final scoreline gives the impression of a fairly comfortable outing for South Africa in their opening Autumn Nations Series match, it was anything but as Scotland gave as good as they got at Scottish Gas Murrayfield.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Springboks’ 7-1 bench aimed to effectively blast the Scots off the park in the second half, but it wasn’t quite that straightforward as the home outfit stood up to the giant units that are now holders of both the Rugby World Cup and the Rugby Championship.

A 32-15 victory will look impressive in the history books, but this was a contest that felt a lot closer. And there was plenty of feeling.

“I think I said in the press conference before the game yesterday that we know they are a quality side,” commented stand-in Springbok captain Eben Etzebeth, who himself felt the full force of Scotland’s physical effort.

“Always, when you prepare for Scotland, we prepare like we are going to play New Zealand or Ireland, because they’re one of the top teams in the world.

“To beat them at Murrayfield with 17 points, yeah, maybe the scoreboard does flatter us a little bit, but we still got a good performance in.

ADVERTISEMENT

“We always know it’s not going to go our way. It’s going to be a bit of a grind. They’re a quality side, and they definitely stood up to us in the general play with their physicality and brought the game to us as well, so it was a good battle. It was a good Test match.

“Compliments to them. I think they were great today. We probably weren’t at our best, but we showed quality in the end to make the scoreboard like that.”

Defence

146
Tackles Made
125
17
Tackles Missed
26
90%
Tackle Completion %
83%

South Africa kept Scotland try-less for the second time in succession, a fact that coach Rassie Erasmus noted was even more impressive considering they have the likes of Finn Russell in their ranks.

The Springboks now move back to number one in the world rankings, with Ireland dropping to third and New Zealand up to second.

ADVERTISEMENT

Facing England next, Etzebeth knows full well that they need to keep getting better.

“We obviously set our standards for ourselves. We drive within the team, the players and the management. We want to keep on, keep on performing.

“And we know every now and then there’s going to be a performance that we’re not probably that proud of, and like I said, at the end of the day it was a good performance because we beat them by that margin.

“But there’s just some aspects of the game that we probably won’t be happy with and that we’ll work on and I’m sure the coaches will point it out to us, and there will be some harsh words, but also some good words. And then I think that you need that in a professional team environment.

“We always strive to be better, and that’s why I say there will be some harsh words as well.”

Watch the highly acclaimed five-part documentary Chasing the Sun 2, chronicling the journey of the Springboks as they strive to successfully defend the Rugby World Cup, free on RugbyPass TV (*unavailable in Africa)

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

2 Comments
N
NR 20 days ago

It looked like the Boks didnt show up. Just going through the motions and drills. Almost robotic. The score line is definitely not a true reflection of the game. Scotland were unlucky. Im sure the Boks will be much improved against "Plastic Energy" England.

B
Bull Shark 20 days ago

I think the boks were made to work hard for the win. Which says a lot about Scotland who weren't unlucky insofar as they couldn't score tries against the Boks formidable defence. Scotland were very good around the breakdowns. All credit to them, they definitely deserve to be higher up in the rankings.


I said from the outset that Scotland would be the toughest match on this tour. And they delivered.


England, not to be too dismissive of them, are less of a threat than Scotland imo. But they are wounded and angry and can produce a win. But they're not playing to any clear plan on defense or attack - due to their coaches not having a clue.


The Boks formation is leaving them vulnerable at the breakdowns. The backline, in particular, need to clear out more and more rucks as we play across the width of the field with this 12221 (or whatever they're calling it) formation.


So I think it was quite carefully planned out that two packs of forwards (i.e. the 7/1) were played against Scotland to get match fitness and our preferred backline in Manie, DDA, Kriel, KLA, Cheslin and Fassi were rested for England.


I think England are going to have their hands full on Saturday.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

J
JW 22 minutes ago
All Blacks report card: Are Razor's troops heading in the right direction?

First, thinking automatic success comes with succession. I think a heavily hand made succession can work but they need to be a whole lot more ruthless with their processes.


Then, as pointed out in a recent article, by the same author as this one I think, they went with what Razor would these days call the "quarter back" style 10 rather than a facilitator. This, along with a second playmaker, removed all desire to select alround players who have the skill to keep the ball alive and enable those wonderful team try's we used to see. We became 'strike' team with specific focal points, and a reliance on those players.


Two defend those players, and the idea itself I suppose, the two you name in particular were heavily affected by their concussions and the idea they can break a neck playing like they way they were. Neither were anything like that specifically due to injurys imo, this, combined with the same mentality that causes the team not to want to replace a future coach (Foster) with someone better, means they stuck with their man. There is also a heavy amount of fiscal perspective in things like investment in a player that dictated a lack of desire to move sooner (the delay in selecting someone like Mo'unga and using Scott as a 6 in conjunction with Ardie at 7).


Ah, yes, I see that you see. Yeah it was definitely another one of these pretty ideas like succession of coachs wasn't, naming the new 7 as captain, after McCaw. Combined with the look of your next paragraph, I'm going to suggest that again it is one of these 'AB philosophies' that are to blame of sticking with your investments till ruin or bust. I can't remember what injury Read had but there was also a conscious choice to play him tighter and we were robbed by his wide running and passing game by a loss of pace. But both of them were indicative of a lack of investment (by necessity no doubt) in securing talent behind them Lachlan was better than Cane for multiple years before he finally decided to go, guys you knew would deliver to a certain standard like Elliot Dixon, Squire, Robinson, Tuafua, even Messam, were constantly overlooked to play certain All Blacks into the ground and have them needing to be excluded from the start of SR seasons as a result. It's so indicative of now with players like Kirifi stonewalled to give Cane a farewell but more glaring grinding blood our of Ardie for one more performance. Not to mention passing up on players like Sotutu.


I see you have great names as well, fully agree, especially about how that Foster teams run ended. While I don't think you understand the dynamics of what selecting from overseas is likely involve, I'm on board, because I don't really care too much about SR. I'd prefer it if NZR had to do what you suggest and invest in the grass roots and NPC and everyone can turn up to a NPC game without paying a cent because the people involved are there for the love of the game.


Realistically though, and thinking with that All Black mindset of perfection, nothing should change until these problems weve highlighted with the setup, and this current coaches failings, have been fixed. Make the change to opening up when you don't need to open it up, that is the 7 point play to make.

308 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Can Will Jordan avoid the All Blacks curse of turning 27? Can Will Jordan avoid the All Blacks curse of turning 27?
Search