Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Toulouse player ratings vs Exeter Chiefs | Investec Champions Cup

Antoine Dupont

Toulouse player ratings: Stade Toulousain kept their title defence rolling with a crushing — victory over a plucky Exeter Chiefs at Sandy Park.

ADVERTISEMENT

Spearheaded by Antoine Dupont, the Top 14 side overpowered their hosts in the physical exchanges and ran riot in open play.

Here is how the Toulouse players fared.

1. Rodrigue Neti – 7 
New Caledonia’s own put in a workmanlike performance with a solid showing in all departments. His ability to get underneath tightheads at scrum time has been USP over the years and was on full display this evening.

2. Julien Marchand – 8
Reclaiming his role as starter from Peato Mauvaka, he laid set the standard with Toulouse’s second try from a textbook maul. Bringing punch to the close-quarter carries, the hooker kept the Chief’s ruck pillars honest.

3. Dorian Aldegheri – 6.5
Mixed from start to finish, the veteran was visibly frustrated in the early scrum exchanges.

Set Plays

8
Scrums
4
86%
Scrum Win %
100%
11
Lineout
16
55%
Lineout Win %
94%
4
Restarts Received
10
75%
Restarts Received Win %
82%

4. Thibaud Flament – 8
Did you know he was once Loughborough University’s fifth-team flyhalf? Of course, you did! Everyone does! Whilst you might scoff at a 6’8″ and 118kg lock playing in the ten shirt, if any international secondrow was capable of doing so it is Flament. Pouncing for a nice first-half try will top his stat line, but the frequency with which he pulls the ball back as a distributor is remarkable.

5. Emmanuel Meafou – 7
Manhandling Chiefs, left, right, and centre, Toulon’s gargantuan lock was at times unplayable at Sandy Park. Bustling about for 51 minutes, by which time the job was firmly done,

ADVERTISEMENT

6. Francois Cros – 7.5
Tidy in every department, he led the charge on the rare occasions that the Chiefs were in the ascendancy. Playing the full eighty minutes with intensity in his first Champions Cup outing of the season, he didn’t miss a beat.

7. Jack Willis – 8.5
Back in his homeland for one night only, the former Wasp reminded Steve Borthwick of all the qualities at his disposal, none are at his level. Knowing exactly which breakdowns to target, putting on top-class footwork before contact and crunching ball carriers in the tackle, it was a do-it-all performance from the openside.

8. Alexandre Roumat – 8
Classy in every sense of the word, the do-it-all number eight ruled the skies as he directed a perfect line-out. Running with an upright style, the 6’6″ eighth man got his hands free for some timely offloads.

Defence

115
Tackles Made
74
29
Tackles Missed
13
80%
Tackle Completion %
85%
ADVERTISEMENT

9. Antoine Dupont – 8.5
Living up to the moniker of the best player in the world, as confirmed by RugbyPass. Dupont opened his account with a try in the 8th minute and continued on his merry way to yet another outrageously impressive showing. Departing in the 63rd minute as the top carrier with 11 to go with his 46 passes and 9 kicks.

10. Romain Ntamack – 7
Perhaps it was a desire to reclaim his best form, but the flyhalf looked like he was trying too hard in the first quarter of the fixture. Unfortunately for Exeter, these wobbles didn’t last for long. Once he settled into the contest, Ntamack distributed beautifully at the line. Defensively, he had an edge to his game as he targeted the ball, looking to hold up the Chiefs before his support arrived.

11. Matthis Lebel – 8.5
We employ you to focus on the magnificent winger who rarely gets the plaudits he deserves in this star-studded side. Whenever he makes a break, his ability to make the right move, whether it is looking for support or going it alone, is always bang on. When he does make a pass, he routinely runs the perfect support line to get a second and, at times, a third touch. This frequency of possession saw him beat 7 defenders in the first half alone as he raced away for 73 meters made.

12. Santiago Chocobares – 7
Confrontational and direct in his approach, the Argentine centre was once again Toulouse’s backline enforcer. Making hard yards into the guts of the Chief’s defensive line, his highlight reel doesn’t pop quite like those around him, but he gets through a mountain of work, as reflected by the stats.

13. Pierre-Louis Barassi – 9 
Carved open the Exeter defence in the 19th minute to set up Lebel for a classic team try. Twenty minutes later he would be closing out the first half under the sticks as he slipped between two Chiefs defenders. These scores underpinned a first-half performance that yielded 76 meters gained, 2 line breaks and 3 defenders beaten.

14. Juan Cruz Mallia – 6.5
Growing into the role of facilitator, the Puma was marked relatively well by the Chiefs, only for him to find an offload that would set a teammate free. Overall, he might consider this a quiet showing but his work rate off the ball was noticeable.

Attack

140
Passes
145
92
Ball Carries
119
175m
Post Contact Metres
236m
4
Line Breaks
12

15. Thomas Ramos – 8
Death by a thousand paper cuts is the tactic Ramos employs week-in, week-out. Setting the tone with a banana kick that led to a superb 50:22 before shredding the Chief’s defence with incisive carries, Ramos was impervious once again this evening.

Substitutes
16. Guillaume Cramont – N/A
Unfortunately, he had to depart less than ten minutes into his foray onto the pitch with a knock. Up to that point, he was eager to get involved and looked ferocious when clearing rucks.

17. David Ainu’u – 7
The USA international continues his rise as one of the very best looseheads in European Rugby. Impossible to shift when he gets over the ball at the breakdown, Ainu’u translates outrageous power into crucial interventions. At scrum time, his positioning is top-notch, whilst his impact on mauls is magnificent.

18. Joel Merkler – 7
Mirroring the above with Ainu’u, the Spanish international continues to round into a top-class operator. Still somehow only 23-years-old, the man mountain tighthead brings oomph to the close exchanges as an alternative to Emmanuel Meafou.

19. Joshua Brennan – 7
One of Irish Rugby’s ‘what ifs’, the now French international, brings a mongrel element to the Toulouse pack. Rag-dolling Chiefs all over the show, the 23-year-old’s potential is frightening.

20. Theo Ntamack – 7.5
Coming from a line of fine playmakers, it is unsurprising that the younger Ntamack is not simply a ruck hitter. Possessing top-notch pace, a world-class rugby intellect and exceptional physicality, he opened up the Chief’s defence. This pace saw him show a clean pair of heels en route to a try that took Toulouse over fifty points.

21. Mathis Castro-Ferreira – 6
Living up to his moniker as one of the brightest young talents in French Rugby, the former World U20 Championship winner looked right at home at this level.

22. Paul Graou – 7
Making the most of some valuable minutes in the Champions Cup, the backup nine looked good, albeit behind a pack that was rolling forward at a rate of knots. Claiming a loving support try as he took a pop-up offload from Kinghorn in the 77th minute was the highlight of his evening.

23. Blair Kinghorn – 8
Operating as a key distributor against a tiring Chiefs defence, the Scottish international had a field day in the wide channels when he replaced Mallia. Scored an easy run-in try and was denied what would’ve been a top-class finish for a second try with a marginal knock-on.

Top 100

Rugby’s best of the best, ranked by experts. Check out our list of the Top 100 Men's Rugby Players and let us know what you think! 



ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

6 Comments
R
RedWarrior 30 days ago

Its early in the season to be hitting 60 pointers every game. La Roche and Leinster can do that too. The difference is they dont concede as much as Toulouse.

Leinster may not win this year, but I'd bet Toulouse need to avoid them if they are going to win. Leinster are conceding 10 points less per game than last year. Their attack will be a lot better with Barrett in play.

J
JPM 30 days ago

Leinster didn’t seem so great vs Clermont…

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

J
JW 31 minutes ago
How law changes are speeding up the game - but the scrum lags behind

so what's the point?

A deep question!


First, the point would be you wouldn't have a share of those penalities if you didn't choose good scrummers right.


So having incentive to scrummaging well gives more space in the field through having less mobile players.


This balance is what we always strive to come back to being the focus of any law change right.


So to bring that back to some of the points in this article, if changing the current 'offense' structure of scrums, to say not penalizing a team that's doing their utmost to hold up the scrum (allowing play to continue even if they did finally succumb to collapsing or w/e for example), how are we going to stop that from creating a situation were a coach can prioritize the open play abilities of their tight five, sacrificing pure scrummaging, because they won't be overly punished by having a weak scrum?


But to get back on topic, yes, that balance is too skewed, the prevalence has been too much/frequent.


At the highest level, with the best referees and most capable props, it can play out appealingly well. As you go down the levels, the coaching of tactics seems to remain high, but the ability of the players to adapt and hold their scrum up against that guy boring, or the skill of the ref in determining what the cause was and which of those two to penalize, quickly degrades the quality of the contest and spectacle imo (thank good european rugby left that phase behind!)


Personally I have some very drastic changes in mind for the game that easily remedy this prpblem (as they do for all circumstances), but the scope of them is too great to bring into this context (some I have brought in were applicable), and without them I can only resolve to come up with lots of 'finicky' like those here. It is easy to understand why there is reluctance in their uptake.


I also think it is very folly of WR to try and create this 'perfect' picture of simple laws that can be used to cover all aspects of the game, like 'a game to be played on your feet' etc, and not accept it needs lots of little unique laws like these. I'd be really happy to create some arbitrary advantage for the scrum victors (similar angle to yours), like if you can make your scrum go forward, that resets the offside line from being the ball to the back foot etc, so as to create a way where your scrum wins a foot be "5 meters back" from the scrum becomes 7, or not being able to advance forward past the offisde line (attack gets a free run at you somehow, or devide the field into segments and require certain numbers to remain in the other sgements (like the 30m circle/fielders behind square requirements in cricket). If you're defending and you go forward then not just is your 9 still allowed to harras the opposition but the backline can move up from the 5m line to the scrum line or something.


Make it a real mini game, take your solutions and making them all circumstantial. Having differences between quick ball or ball held in longer, being able to go forward, or being pushed backwards, even to where the scrum stops and the ref puts his arm out in your favour. Think of like a quick tap scenario, but where theres no tap. If the defending team collapses the scrum in honest attempt (even allow the attacking side to collapse it after gong forward) the ball can be picked up (by say the eight) who can run forward without being allowed to be tackled until he's past the back of the scrum for example. It's like a little mini picture of where the defence is scrambling back onside after a quick tap was taken.


The purpose/intent (of any such gimmick) is that it's going to be so much harder to stop his momentum, and subsequent tempo, that it's a really good advantage for having such a powerful scrum. No change of play to a lineout or blowing of the whistle needed.

161 Go to comments
J
JW 2 hours ago
How law changes are speeding up the game - but the scrum lags behind

Very good, now we are getting somewhere (though you still didn't answer the question but as you're a South African I think we can all assume what the answer would be if you did lol)! Now let me ask you another question, and once you've answered that to yourself, you can ask yourself a followup question, to witch I'm intrigued to know the answer.


Well maybe more than a couple of questions, just to be clear. What exactly did this penalty stop you from doing the the first time that you want to try again? What was this offence that stopped you doing it? Then ask yourself how often would this occur in the game. Now, thinking about the regularity of it and compare it to how it was/would be used throughout the rest of the game (in cases other than the example you gave/didn't give for some unknown reason).


What sort of balance did you find?


Now, we don't want to complicate things further by bringing into the discussion points Bull raised like 'entirety' or 'replaced with a ruck', so instead I'll agree that if we use this article as a trigger to expanding our opinions/thoughts, why not allow a scrum to be reset if that is what they(you) want? Stopping the clock for it greatly removes the need to stop 5 minutes of scrum feeds happening. Fixing the law interpretations (not incorrectly rewarding the dominant team) and reducing the amount of offences that result in a penalty would greatly reduce the amount of repeat scrums in the first place. And now that refs a card happy, when a penalty offence is committed it's going to be far more likely it results in the loss of a player, then the loss of scrums completely and instead having a 15 on 13 advantage for the scrum dominant team to then run their opposition ragged. So why not take the scrum again (maybe you've already asked yourself that question by now)?


It will kind be like a Power Play in Hockey. Your outlook here is kind of going to depend on your understanding of what removing repeat scrums was put in place for, but I'm happy the need for it is gone in a new world order. As I've said on every discussion on this topic, scrums are great, it is just what they result in that hasn't been. Remove the real problem and scrum all you like. The All Blacks will love zapping that energy out of teams.

161 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ How law changes are speeding up the game - but the scrum lags behind How law changes are speeding up the game - but the scrum lags behind
Search