Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Who's In Charge Here? A New Zealander Praises Wayne Barnes

barnes

In what is thought to be a world first, New Zealander Jamie Wall offers praise to English referee Wayne Barnes for the way he controlled the All Blacks’ first test against Wales.

ADVERTISEMENT

Let’s get one thing out of the way: I don’t actually have so much of a problem with Wayne Barnes overturning the forward pass that cost TJ Perenara’s a try in Saturday’s test match between the All Blacks and Wales. In fact, I can honestly say I don’t have much of a problem with Wayne Barnes at all… it was nine years ago, people.

Did he get the call wrong? Almost certainly. World Rugby’s definition of a forward pass is somewhat confusing for the average fan, but it’s something a guy who is paid to understand rugby’s confusing rules should understand. So Barnes isn’t completely lacking culpability here.

But let’s give the man some credit, by overriding the TMO he actually took responsibility for a call. It’s a rare event in the realm of rugby refereeing these days, an occupation which severely lacks accountability and promotes confusion on a game-by-game basis.

Barnes isn’t the first ref to pull rank this season. Nigel Owens, everyone’s favourite wise-cracking Welshman, awarded a try to English prop Dan Cole against France in the Six Nations despite the TMO getting in his ear and suggesting that he check the replay for obstruction. A clearly annoyed Owens took one look at it and re-awarded the try.

The difference between the two cases is that while Owens was pestered by the voice in his earpiece, Barnes deliberately sought out the advice from the man upstairs, then ignored it. But then, in every other game, the TMO’s decision is final. So this really does beg the question, who is actually in charge of a game of rugby these days?

Owens and Barnes now do whatever they like, while other refs still seem beholden to the TMO. So a test match reffed by them essentially has a different set of rules than the others.

ADVERTISEMENT

The confusing state of affairs isn’t helped by the referees’ worldwide governing body having no clear definition of it either. Throw in the ability of assistant referees to get in and actually be able to tell the ref to dish out cards and it suddenly gets murkier.

It’s fair enough to make time-keeping a duty for someone else, but surely the guy out on the field should have the final say on matters involving everything else, whether that decision is right or wrong.

So that’s why Barnes isn’t just off the hook for a bad call, he should be given a pat on the back for his handling of the issue. Perhaps now other refs can follow his lead and take charge of the matters that used to be in their own hands anyway, and not even that long ago.

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

J
JW 1 hour ago
All Black star Richie Mo'unga stuck in stalemate in Japan

Richie is a great passer too, don't get me wrong. But if I'm picking Mo'unga's direct attack were he threatened the desences in 23' by having the ball in both hands, or Dmac's 24' backline where theyre super deep and he has to run sideways doing skip passes, I choose the 23 backline.


As a first five, Dmac has no threat on the carry, he's too small to bust through, that's why you don't see him try it like Mo'unga does. Dmac can still try to carry (when he should just give it to someone else) as his bailout option when under pressure, but thankfully with the forward dominance it's not so much an occurrence/issue.


Somehow Spew, but we haven't seen that because of the Dmac issue I outlined. It's generally the 10 that doubles around. I don't trust Jordies instincts at doing it either, even in his role of laying it back I don't think he's the one. So while I agree it's a powerful attacking play I don't think it's an option for the All Blacks either. Rieko just hasn't been able to catch the ball, it's pretty much his only problem. You can't see that changing though. I'd imagine they just can that play as something theyre not capable of too rather than change people in and out.


I perhaps go for something more simple, like runners from deep coming into the line at different angles. No so much about width like they were last year, just simple inside or out passes to Clarke/Jordan/Telea straitening the line. We want to see something different happen this year because if its the same I think we'll all be calling for heads again.

13 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING Louis Rees-Zammit breaks silence on immediate future in on-air interview Louis Rees-Zammit breaks silence on immediate future
Search