Mercer and Mitchell omissions are baffling – Andy Goode
The omission of Zach Mercer and Alex Mitchell from England’s latest World Cup training squad is baffling and hints even more at a cautious approach from Steve Borthwick.
Bazball may be coming in for a bit of criticism for the first time at the moment in English cricket but it has reinvigorated the national team and reconnected fans with it and it’s hard to see Borthball having a similar effect in rugby.
Only Italy and Wales scored fewer tries than England in this year’s Six Nations, despite them having more territory than any other team, and as many as eight of the 13 tries they did score started with a scrum or a lineout.
That isn’t exactly getting bums off seats and now two of the most exciting, attacking players who could have improved things have been jettisoned from the squad at a relatively early stage in the preparations for the World Cup.
The decision to cut Mercer is particularly hard to understand after he was named Top 14 player of the year in 2021/22 as Montpellier won the title and then beat more defenders than any other player in the league this season in a team that struggled at times.
You have to wonder what he’s thinking as well after agreeing to return to the Premiership and probably take a sizeable pay cut in order to be eligible for his country again only to be cast aside without being given an opportunity to show what he can do in an international.
Number eight has been something of a problem position for England too and, although Billy Vunipola may return if he proves his fitness, the incumbent Alex Dombrandt had a poor Six Nations and it feels like he’s had a fair crack of the whip.
Tom Willis finished the season strongly with Bordeaux but it’s a major shock not to see Mercer’s name in the latest squad, especially after Sam Simmonds ruled himself out of contention a couple of weeks ago.
There was more competition for Mitchell at scrum half and Borthwick has gone with the experience of Danny Care, together with the Leicester pair of Ben Youngs and Jack van Poortvliet who he knows inside out.
Care has been one of the best players in the Premiership in recent years but he is 36 and Mitchell, a decade his junior, was the spark that ignited a Saints attack which scored more tries than any other team in the Premiership this season.
It feels like a closer call between the pair of them than it would’ve been for me at number eight but it does seem as if Borthwick has gone for the more conservative option again and Mitchell will feel he hasn’t been given a proper chance to shine either.
The Northampton man has won all five of his caps from the bench, including scoring a try on debut a couple of years ago, and his four appearances in this year’s Six Nations amounted to just 71 minutes of playing time in total.
Elsewhere, it’s great to see Theo Dan included, albeit probably only because of Luke Cowan-Dickie’s injury-enforced absence, after his exciting form with ball in hand for Saracens towards the end of the campaign.
There are a few other interesting calls with the likes of Adam Radwan, Ted Hill and others who have the potential to inject a bit of youth, energy and pace missing out but Mercer and Mitchell are by far the most notable omissions.
It’s no surprise that Owen Farrell has been confirmed as captain, with Ellis Genge and Courtney Lawes named as vice captains, but I think there was a golden opportunity to reconnect with fans after the departure of Eddie Jones and it isn’t being taken so far.
Of course, winning will soon get supporters back on side but showing personality and playing with a certain style and freedom will go a long way towards encouraging people to get excited about the England rugby team again as well.
There may have been a few recent batting calamities that come with the territory but that is what we have seen with the England cricket team under Brendan McCullum and Ben Stokes and it’d be great to see something similar, even if not as radical, from Borthwick and Farrell.
We know from his successful tenure at Leicester that Borthwick favours a conservative, pragmatic approach but England aren’t going to win a World Cup unless they develop their attack significantly.
The men in white had the slowest average ruck speed in the 2023 Six Nations of 3.77 seconds, they made the fewest linebreaks and kicked more in play than anyone else.
Mercer and Mitchell are two of the first English players you think of when it comes to injecting pace and beating a man and the fact they’ve been left out already perhaps doesn’t bode well for people expecting those statistics and the style of play to change at the World Cup.
England’s preparations for the tournament will be long and rigorous, they will be more well-drilled than in the Six Nations but they need to find a few sparks to go with that. We’ve been crying out for Mercer’s return from France and Mitchell has long deserved the chance to start a Test and show what he can do.
There’s no doubt in my mind that both have the potential to light the blue touch paper on the world stage but it looks like they might be doing it for their clubs in the Premiership Rugby Cup come September instead.
Comments on RugbyPass
Juicy stuff well covered I’d go as far as to say that the referee was a key component in keeping it a tasty spectacle
1 Go to commentsCotter has added that steel that has been missing. Let's see if it will carry until the Finals… Come on the Blues ….
2 Go to commentsAndy Goode just loves to be controversial. Its boring. Let’s all stop reading.
6 Go to commentsYou have got to consider that if the situation was flipped and the French were held to a salary cap with no English equivalent, the English would laugh in their faces and tell them to get over it. As for Leinster (as a fan), the central contract system is a dream but is guilty of cutting out the other 3 provinces. At the end of the day, it comes across outside of the English border that the Premiership is drowning and trying to take everyone else with it rather than adapt. The English lose, the English want new rules. We've seen this repeat (and once it even led to the current Champions Cup) You make many good and informed points, but if the flip was on the other flop, it wouldn't be Rugby’s problem I suspect - it would be a French one.
13 Go to commentsSeems to have been a bright start but it tailed off. To win the big matches you have to get used to putting your foot on the throttle and your opponent’s necks in an 80 minutes performance which is what the All Blacks were renowned for. An example in the Women’s game is England v Ireland in the 6N match played at Twickenham in April. Watch on YouTube.
1 Go to commentsBobby has been a first grade bonehead since high school. Like a true Cape Tonian, his own reflection is more important than anything else.
1 Go to commentsNo comment on the textbook red card for Ramm that was just ignored? Amazing that
4 Go to commentsThese rule changes have been implemented with good intentions, but much like every other rule change focus on isolated symptoms instead of the root cause. If you cannot croc roll, and cannot risk any head contact with a front on clear out, it is not clear how you are supposed to lawfully clear someone out who is attempting a jackal. This will backfire massively and lead to substantially more kicking. Teams will simply not want to take the ball into contact. Or it will lead to even more dangerous methods to clear players out who are over the ball. I much prefer having the set piece on a 30 second shot clock over no scrum on a short arm infringement. Resets are not a problem in themselves, but 90 second water and tactics breaks before every scrum are a big problem. Trainers constantly coming on to the field to help players pull their socks up and delaying the game are a problem. DuPont law was a blight on the game and should have been changed the day after it was first implemented.
79 Go to commentsAh yes, the opinion of Andy Goode… Andy Goode, the man who knows what some of the Irish players said to Eben Etzebeth after the QF, better than what Eben himself knows. And, judging by this piece, the Grandmaster of clichés.
6 Go to commentsI think this is a fair view. As a South African I am concerned about the depowering of the scrum but let’s be honest, until the SA vs FRA quarter many people didn’t even know you could take a scrum from a free kick. As you say it’s going to come down to interpretation… until then we don’t really know how this is going to impact the game. That would lead to my own objection. Do the unknowns of changing a law outweigh the cons of said law. With such an obscure law that most people had never heard of, one that had never really had an impact on the game in the first place is it worth changing to invite so much uncertainty. Better the devil you know then the devil you don’t as it were…
6 Go to comments162 comments so far and counting. i didn't realize that rugby fans are on the way to join the football brothers. what is the point to share personal opinion only to get all this shi*? it seems IRB bosses are doing the great job by killing the spirit of the game both on and outside the pitch. too sad, indeed. btw, was there anything on eben’s point of view from the boys in green, who he mentioned?
164 Go to commentsJob done guys. Great win in a game where things can quickly go wrong.
1 Go to commentsAlex Sanderson fantastic coach and person .So pleased he has signed another contract great days ahead for Sale under his leadership.
1 Go to commentsAndy Goode cant kick to 12
164 Go to commentsDoxed himself. Great work Johnny. You are well suited to the Saders
1 Go to comments_Best game players _
2 Go to commentsWho's Jarrad Hohepa?
1 Go to commentsSo let me get this straight. Say you have the dominant scrum. You are 99% sure you can go for a scrum pushover try on the line to win the game. The opposition knows it too. They give away a silly tap kick instead. You are now not allowed to scrum. This is ridiculous! *%@ing the game up as usual! The fact that the attacking teams are not allowed to scrum from a held up over the line is just as ridiculous. Really world rugby? Careful people might start a rebel league called True Rugby or Real Rugby.
79 Go to comments12 subs during a game? How has that been allowed to happen NB? I hate when the game goes in this monopolistic direction closing up shop, it just becomes non sport. Btw have you seen anything of how Liam Coltman was tracking for Lyon? He has just signed to return to Otago though we have a couple of young hookers developing here. He was a popular gentle natured character down here and I’m glad to see him back but maybe he will be a mentor primarily?
13 Go to commentsGreat breakdown and the global politics always confuses me a little. The southern hemisphere seems to be left out a bit but I wouldn’t even know where to start with fixing it. Club challenge could be a step in the right direction
13 Go to comments