Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

One name features heavily as England fans call for Borthwick sack

Steve Borthwick, Head Coach of England, speaks with Jamie George and Maro Itoje of England prior to the Guinness Six Nations 2026 match between Italy and England at Stadio Olimpico on March 07, 2026 in Rome, Italy. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)

It seemed unimaginable just a matter of weeks ago when England won their 12th match on the bounce against Wales in round one of the Guinness Six Nations, but Steve Borthwick appears to be holding onto his job by his fingernails following their first-ever loss to Italy on Saturday.

ADVERTISEMENT

On the back of lacklustre defeats to Scotland and Ireland, the England boss rung the changes for the trip to Rome, hoping to breathe life into a side that were only ranked third in the world last month. But the errors that plagued England in rounds two and three appeared again, as Borthwick’s side look to be in total freefall.

There was plenty of pressure on the England chief heading into the match, and the calls for his sacking have reached fever pitch now with fans, pundits and former players calling for his exit.

VIDEO

Former England fly-half Andy Goode posted on X: “Borthwick out simples.”

Over on Virgin Media Sports, former Ireland fly-half Ian Madigan said that ‘it doesn’t look like they [England players] are playing for the coach.

Match Summary

3
Penalty Goals
2
2
Tries
2
2
Conversions
1
0
Drop Goals
0
94
Carries
118
9
Line Breaks
6
16
Turnovers Lost
15
9
Turnovers Won
9

RugbyPass transfer guru Neil Fissler wrote: “Dear Steve, Please leave now! Yours in Rugby Fizzy,” and openly pondered: “I wonder if Phil Dowson [Northampton Saints head coach] still has an international release clause in his new contract?”

One account demanded Borthwick be ousted and questioned why England didn’t compete at the final lineout, with Italy set to kick the ball out for full-time.

“No matter what Borthwick out! So just so i can understand England didn’t compete for a lineout that Italy could kick out to win the game. The dumbest team I have ever come across.”

ADVERTISEMENT

While a moment like this will inevitably see the reemergence of calls for Shaun Edwards to take over, it is unlikely that England will be able to lure the French assistant coach away from his role with 18 months to go until the World Cup. Similarly, Andy Farrell will be hard to prise away from Ireland.

One name that has been bandied about since the final whistle is Scott Robertson, who has been without a full-time job since parting ways with the All Blacks at the end of the year. A snag in that plan, however, is a clause in the Kiwi’s exit barring him from coaching another nation for a year.

Whatever happens, it seems unlikely that a decision will be made swiftly by the RFU, who will likely conduct a review. For Borthwick, his side have the daunting challenge of facing title-chasing France in Paris next week. Even a win at the Stade de France may not be enough to keep him in a job.

Related

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

21 Comments
H
Hammer Head 25 mins ago

There’s something very clearly up with the players. If Borthwicke has lost the change room, then you don’t have much of a choice.


But what terrible, terrible timing to be looking for a new coach. Let alone appointing one with 18 months to the WC.


Not great. And a few of those English players need to have a good look at themselves and their own performances. Good players don’t look that bad, almost, overnight.

P
PMcD 37 mins ago

We are 18 months from a RWC and need an experienced coach that has been there before and knows how to win the big tournaments, with the best win percentage we have seen in recent years - enter stage left John Mitchell and work your magic with this squad for RWC 2027.

H
Hammer Head 24 mins ago

Terrible timing. He’s just signed with the red roses. And any decent coaches are tied up to 2028.


England is staring down the barrel of a caretaker situation to 2027.


Unless they go after someone like Jamie Joseph?

u
unknown 51 mins ago

For me you either take the best from the Prem (Van Graan, Dowson or possibly Lam) or you get Edwards or Farrell. Robertson has no familiarity with the English game and has just been dispensed by the ABs. However Borthwick cannot continue

H
Hammer Head 18 mins ago

I was surprised that Borthwicke survived 2024, to be honest. And I said it then and I’ll say it again:


England should have the best coaches in the world in the top job.


I’m not sure who they can appoint in a caretaker role, but they should seriously consider recruiting for 2028 when many good international coaches, generally, become available.


How about Jamie Joseph, who just got overlooked by NZ again?

u
unknown 1 hr ago

The RFU will successfully make a b*locks of this .. whatever happens! Maybe they should call the WRU for some advice.

Joking aside, Borthwick has to go .. and the sooner the better.

His replacement needs to understand English rugby AND have experience of international coaching. That rules out homegrown contenders like Dowson and Baxter. Scott Robertson and Jamie Joseph don’t know the English Premiership.

Surely now is the time for the RFU to open its chequebook and bring in the dream team that is Andy Farrell and Sean Edwards.

J
John Breslin 33 mins ago

Why would Farrell even return the phone calls of the RFU? They burned him post 2015 and so very publicly. Lancaster too.


Two gifted coaches cast aside to be hoovered up by the Irish system. Fools

T
Tom 1 hr ago

Dowson probably the best candidate from the Prem but I'm not sure it's fair or a good idea to throw another inexperienced coach into the grinder right now. England need a proper test coach to pull them out of this mess. The RFU should do everything they can to secure Farrell post-WC and do what they can to build a foundation for him until then.

S
STypeman 1 hr ago

Borthwick should offer to Resign and admit he has taken the team as far as he can go. The Team are disjointed have no real leadership and 15 months out from World Cup does not know his First 15. Get Shaun Edwards in as Head Coach and Clive Woodward as Chief Executive

T
Tom 1 hr ago

Edwards won't ever work for the RFU, he hates them.

B
Bob Salad II 1 hr ago

Here we go again; another week of misery spent pouring over podcasts and analysis reports trying to find new ways to describe how crap England are under Borthwick.


My immediate take, for what it’s worth:


Shape and systems thinking has polluted Borthwick’s players minds. Everything is process and zonal: if A, then B, if B, then C, but if D is unlikely, then repeat A, but only when in Zone 2, not 3 etc. etc. No wonder players look so clueless; they’re terrified of doing anything spontaneous. It’s spreadsheet rugby designed and implemented on the basis of winning fractions and percentages.


I honestly don’t see the benefit of retaining Borthwick anymore and I think it’s starting to become clear neither do the players.

T
Tom 1 hr ago

Ye this is it. There's no flow to England. It's all analysis paralysis.


My only concern is are we going to be scraping the barrel to get a new coach at this stage of the WC cycle? Perhaps better to install a caretaker and look long term after the WC - possibly Farrell?

S
SB 1 hr ago

Scott Robertson, Jamie Joseph, Ronan O’Gara, Michael Cheika and Ewen McKenzie.

H
Hammer Head 0 mins ago

O’Gara… hmmm…

u
unknown 1 hr ago

Borthers is that you?

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close
ADVERTISEMENT