Close Notice
Show scores

'I dont get this' - The forward selection dilemma that is vexing England fans

By Josh Raisey

Trending on RugbyPass

More News More News

Eddie Jones has made two changes to his starting XV to face Wales on Saturday from the one that beat Italy in round two, with Jamie George replacing Luke Cowan-Dickie and Mark Wilson replacing Courtney Lawes.


Of these two changes, one is not enforced, as Lawes would probably have started had he not succumbed to an injury.

But Jones’ decision to revert back to George is an interesting twist in the ongoing battle between the two hookers.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

The Australian fielded a strong XV against Italy in the hope that the team would find some rhythm and allow some potentially rusty Saracens players to work their way back up to speed after a long absence.
Cowan-Dickie’s presence in that side represented a potential shift in the power struggle between the No2s. George, like many of his Saracens teammates, may have needed the game time against Italy, but Jones had an alternative who has been England’s premier hooker on a domestic level over the past year.
Cowan-Dickie’s selection looked to be far more significant than simply addressing a potential blip in form by the Saracen.

After dominating English and European rugby with Exeter and being nominated for European player of the year (not that that has swayed England selectors in the past), he was earning only his fourth start in 28 Tests. Regardless of Geroge’s form in recent weeks, or even the past year, many felt the Exeter man deserved his starting berth.

To some, this looked like a sign of things to come, so his immediate return to the bench has been questioned. His performance against Italy was not worthy of being dropped, and his form over the past 18 months has been faultless, which helps to explain why there is such surprise that he is a ‘Finisher’ once again.

The Chiefs No2 may be more dangerous in the final half hour than George would be, and while that is a point that is consistently hammered home by the England coach, most would want the better player playing the larger portion.


Jones’ decision to stick with largely the same team has been met with rancour this Six Nations, but it is easy to understand why he has done so. The hooker debate has more layers to it, however, and goes back further than this Six Nations alone.

Mailing List

Sign up to our mailing list for a weekly digest from the wide world of rugby.

Sign Up Now

'I dont get this' - The forward selection dilemma that is vexing England fans