Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Blow for leaders Bath as Sam Underhill's season appears to be over

Bath's Sam Underhill at Northampton last Sunday (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)

Bath will have to make do without Sam Underhill for what remains of the Gallagher Premiership season after the England openside was handed a four-week ban.

ADVERTISEMENT

Underhill’s high tackle on Lyon fullback, Davit Niniashvili, in last Friday’s EPCR Challenge Cup final win, was deemed a mid-entry point offence.

Underhill accepted that he had committed an act of foul play, but did not accept that it warranted a red card. But the independent disciplinary committee upheld the complaint from Lyon, finding that Underhill had tackled Davit Niniashvili in a dangerous manner that warranted a red card.

Referee Hollie Davidson had, controversially, only handed Underhill a yellow card in the 26th minute of the match.

Because of Underhill’s admission of foul play and his remorse, the six-week ban for a mid-entry point offence was reduced by two weeks to four. However,  Underhill’s poor disciplinary record – he was sent off in the Round of 16 clash against Pau, ironically when Davidson was the referee – counted against the ban being cut any further.

As a result, Underhill will miss this weekend’s final match of the regular season at Saracens, which he was likely to be rested for anyway, as well as the home semi-final on Friday, June 6th, and if Bath make it to the Allianz Stadium, the Gallagher Premiership final eight days later.

EPCR have not listed the games included in the ban because it is not yet known whether Underhill will tour with England this summer. If Bath crash out of the semi-finals, it could jeopardise his chances of making the trip to Argentina and the USA.

ADVERTISEMENT

An EPCR statement said: “The date when Underhill can return to play will be determined once his future playing schedule is confirmed.”

Underhill can appeal the decision.

While losing a player of Underhill’s calibre is a blow – he was Bath’s most dominant tackler against Lyon in another Lion-hearted performance, Bath are blessed with riches in the back row.

Guy Pepper is a brilliant option, at either six or seven, while Miles Reid can play anywhere across the back row. Ted Hill and Josh Bayliss are both top-drawer players, but are sixes rather than sevens, while Alfie Barbeary and Arthur Green are out-and-out No.8s, so Ethan Staddon, a specialist openside, could have a big part to play in covering the position.

Staddon has impressed in the Premiership Rugby Cup and Challenge Cup-winning campaigns, but has had few opportunities in the Premiership. His only league start of the season came in the defeat to Bristol in Cardiff earlier this month.

ADVERTISEMENT

Related

ADVERTISEMENT
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

16 Comments
J
JJ 41 days ago

‘‘Underhill … did not accept that it warranted a red card.

Because of … his remorse, the six-week ban for a mid-entry point offence was reduced by two weeks to four.’’


What remorse???

P
PM 40 days ago

I think you’ll find it was because he pleaded guilty to the offence, so they reduced it from 6 weeks to 4 weeks.


As I said, there were two similar incidents in the Saints vs UBB Final, one which wasn’t even picked up (on Tom Lockett), so where are the citings for those? They level of inconsistency in the citing process is damaging its credibility.

A
AliciaBelstead 41 days ago

Great article today………………. Cash43.Com

P
PM 41 days ago

No issues with this being upgraded to red but where are the citing for the shoulder to the face that was missed and the other yellow card for Bordeaux, as they were no different to Underhill and were not even cited.


Where is the consistency in disciplinary proceedings across the two European Finals?

f
fl 41 days ago

so, if Bath make the prem final, he’ll be available for 2 of england’s summer games; if Bath don’t make the final he’ll only be available for 1 summer test?


That all makes sense - but if Bath don’t make the final, and as a result he isn’t selected by England, he’ll then also miss the opening 2 matches of the next prem season?

J
JJ 41 days ago

He will get selected for england, with Borthwick knowing he then can’t play and will use it to serve his ban.

P
PM 41 days ago

It’s worse than that, England have to select him in the squad and then not play him for it to count, which is doubtful because of the ban, so he will likely miss the Premiership Playoff & Final and the start of next season.


Given the talent they will be building for the RWC next season (B Curry & Pollock), I suspect this will signal the end of his England career and I wouldn’t be surprised to see him being offered a lucrative contract with a French team to see out his final years.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

LONG READ
LONG READ Six selection questions for Joe Schmidt as Lions loom large Six selection questions for Joe Schmidt as Lions loom large
Search