Northern | US

Wales Player Ratings vs England

Alyn Wyn Jones
Comments
Comment

With the official World Number One spot up for grabs, this was always going to be more than a warm-up match for both Wales and England.

ADVERTISEMENT

Wales fielded a full strength side to face an experimental Eddie Jones’ England team – but this was in Twickenham, where Wales have won just three times in 24 years.

Sadly for Wales, it was they who looked like the experimental side as Eddie’s England outplayed them across the park.

Here’s our Wales player ratings.

15. Liam Williams

Combined nicely with Josh Adams at times. As a unit the English back three dominated their Welsh counterparts, but the Saracen was menacing with ball in hand as ever.

7

14. George North

The best of Wales’ back three in attack, with 60 metres and 5 defenders beaten in the stats department. Deserved his try.

7.5

ADVERTISEMENT

13. Jonathan Davies

Carried for an average of 4.4 metres per carry off nine runs, with four offloads. Had his hands full with Jonathan Joseph and his two missed tackles in defence will irk him.

6.5

12. Hadleigh Parkes

Refused to give up and did what he could with the scraps on offer, although Piers Francis stood up well to him on defence. A decisive carry near the English line in the second half led to Wyn Jones’ try.

6

11. Josh Adams

Looked bright at times, absent at others – but was ultimately outshone by England’s back three of Watson, Daly and Cokanasiga. Cleaned up the odd mess in defence.

5.5

10. Gareth Anscombe

ADVERTISEMENT

Hobbled off in the 33rd minute after an innocuous-looking bump that will leave the Welsh worried. Was seen later on crutches in the stand.

6

9. Gareth Davies

Did well to take his try, stepping Elliot Daly on his way under the post. Looks in outstanding physical condition after the Swiss trip.

Wales Player Ratings
Gareth Davies

8

1. Nicky Smith

Being blown out of the road by Joe Cokanasiga at close range will have hurt the prop’s pride. Struggled for parity at scrum time.

5.5

2. Ken Owens

Bullish as ever but was part of a Welsh frontrow that was a distant second to their aggressive English counterparts. Made a few trademark carries. Luke Cowan-Dickie’s try off the lineout will hurt.

5.5

3. Tomas Francis

The Exeter tighthead looked to dominate Genge early in the scrums but didn’t get much change out of Englishman. Does his best in the loose.

4.5

4. Adam Beard

The 6’9 lock did his job at lineout time – looking secure on his own ball and managing to poach a lineout off England. It remains to be seen if the accomplished set-piece operator can add more to his game, especially given Jake Ball’s superior loose game.

6

5. Alun Wyn Jones (C)

The Welsh cap record-breaker didn’t play his best game in a red jersey. Hard to fault and never took a backward step.

6

6. Aaron Wainwright

The former Cardiff City midfielder will not have furthered the argument for his inclusion in the Rugby World Cup. English debutant Lewis Ludlam hogged the limelight and the deck. Carried manfully but rarely won the collision. Smartly tied in Ludlam on the scrum preceding Davies’ excellent solo try.

6

7. Justin Tipuric

A quiet game by his standards. Wasn’t the menace on the deck that he needed to be and struggled to turn over ball in the face of the work of Ludlam and Vunipola at the breakdown.

5.5

8. Ross Moriarty

Outshone by a rampant Billy Vunipola, literally getting flattened by his opposite number on occasion. The Dragons’ No.8 needs to find the form that forced him into the side four years ago if he is to fill Taulupe Faletau’s boots.

5.5

Replacements:

16. Elliot Dee

Another Welshman that looked uncharacteristically flat. Not a huge improvement on Owens whom he replaced.

6

17. Wyn Jones

Scored a well-deserved try from close range in the 55th minute. Scrum improved as the game went on.

6.5

18. Dillon Lewis

Gave away two penalties after coming on midway through the second half. Not a good look when you’re coming off the bench.

4

19. Jake Ball

Carried well at times, reminding the Welsh rugby public and Gatland why he was at one stage a first choice for Wales.

6

20. Aaron Shingler

Came on early and having coming back from a massive injury lay-off needed a big game. This wasn’t the game to make that case.

6

21. Aled Davies

Gave away a penalty for a high shot on George Ford in the 60th minute. Slow at times when he needed to be fast.

6

22. Dan Biggar

He missed a few too many tackles after coming on for Anscombe and couldn’t quite control the game in his customary fashion.

5.5

23. Owen Watkin

Run through by Manu Tuilagi in the 75th minute. Must do better.

4

Get the RugbyPass App 📱

Follow the biggest matches with live scores, line-ups, news and analysis, all in the RugbyPass App.

Download Here
On Apple IOS, Android, and Tablet.
ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

P
Phantom 1 hour ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

Fact: the gap between the North and the South has narrowed considerably - that I get. However, determining that only selecting only Home grown players or playing in the home country is is the optimal strategy is a bit of a toss up and highly reliant on the economies of the home union. I do understand that England and to a lesser degree Ireland selects home based only. The top 14 is a massive threat to their domestic product. France would probably not be affected (the money is at home). Fiji, Argentina, Samoa, Italy and you could even argue Scotland have only benefitted from this. Their players either go overseas to learn at higher levels (Fiji, Samoa, Argentina) or players coming into their leagues to strengthen the home product and their National teams (Scotland, Italy, Japan).

South Africa used to limit its selection to the home based players, but the reality of a weak currency vs what players could earn oversees meant that you lost access to your best players at some stage of their careers, with very few exceptions. Kolbe left SA as he was considered too small for International Rugby (yes coaches/selectors view), but ironically in France he forced selectors to notice his endeavors and select him. He is only reaching 50 caps now despite being north of 30 - granted rotation and the odd injury also played a role, but for the most part it is having debuted or becoming a regular so late.



...

18 Go to comments
Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close