Northern | US

Three overseas players that must be brought home for the Wallabies


(Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)
Comments
70 Comments

Although Super Rugby Pacific has only just ticked over the halfway mark of the regular season, Rugby Australia and Joe Schmidt will already be deep in Wallabies planning.

ADVERTISEMENT

In a little over two months, Australia will welcome Ireland, France, and Italy to its shores for the first-ever iteration of the Nations Championship, but the Wallabies have already copped a setback.

Losing Will Skelton to an Achilles tendon rupture was a hammer blow to the nucleus of the side that would’ve faced Ireland on July 4, and that brings the focus back to the depth and strength of the Wallabies.

VIDEO

This loss means there will be a hole in the Wallabies for someone to fill, and a Skelton-sized hole is a big issue for a side that is trying to find its way back to the top of rugby.

It has also prompted some pondering on the depth and strength of Australian rugby as a whole, particularly in key positions.

Losing Skelton comes only a couple of weeks after learning the news that experienced Western Force lock and 17-cap Wallaby Darcy Swain is departing for French club Clermont at season’s end.

This comes a year after the Queensland Reds lost their stalwart, Ryan Smith, to the Ospreys in Wales.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Wallabies can’t keep building up promising locks and then start losing them when they are about to hit the form of their careers.

Elsewhere, the centres are a problem position for the Wallabies. There is not enough high-level or experienced depth at no.12 or no.13, and Len Ikitau cannot be split into two.

Joseph Aukuso-Suaalii now has a decent cap count at the Test level, but many are still unconvinced of his merits in the centres.

There is a pool of older centres who are coming through, such as Isaac Henry at the Queensland Reds and David Feliuai at the Brumbies, who are now entering their prime and are solid units.

ADVERTISEMENT

Then, of course, there’s the much-anticipated arrival of Angus Crichton in 2027 at the Waratahs.

However, there are still not enough power-centres floating around Super Rugby to truly push for that Wallabies spot.

Finally, there are the mistakes that have led to the problems of Aussie rugby for a decade, which are on the verge of being continued.

Young playmakers are being thrust into compromised positions that they are not ready for.

What Australian rugby needs, what the Wallabies needs, are experienced operators to be brought back to Aussie shores, to consolidate IP and game nous to push the Wallabies forward.

Why must they return to Aussie shores, you may ask?

Well, it was revealed this week, in the Sydney Morning Herald by Jonathan Drennan, that the ‘Giteau Law’, which many, including players, believe to be scrapped, is in fact very much in operation as it’s always been.

Schmidt and eventually Kiss will only be able to select any three players from anywhere in the world, provided they hold 30 Test caps or have played Super Rugby for five years or more.

Any betting individual would put big money on Skelton (La Rochelle, France), Taniela Tupou (Racing 92,France), and Tom Hooper (Exeter Chiefs, England) to be those three players at any given time, should they be fit, and the game being played in an international window.

Should Kiss or even Schmidt require more, they would have to request an exception, just like every other coach.

The Wallabies can’t rely on exceptions for success, and they can’t rely on overseas talent while the administration works to have a ‘domestic-first’ policy with an opaque and ambiguous selection policy on OS based players.

Therefore, RA and the Wallabies must work to bring the right talent back to Aussie shores.

They need experienced campaigners, proven players who understand the rigours of Test match rugby and who can be a dominant force for their provincial clubs in Super Rugby Pacific.

Here are the three capped players RA should go after and bring home in 2026 and beyond.

Related

Izack Rodda, lock, 29yo, 33 Test caps

The loss of Skelton is monumental; his experience, raw size, and game nous make a visible difference to the way the Wallabies play and the confidence they have in themselves.

Swain leaving for Clermont is also a blow, not because he is as influential as Skelton, but because he is an elite lineout operator and has that same game nous.

He does the things that most don’t see, he games the opposition, psychs out other lineout callers, hassles halfbacks, and ruins the opposition’s clean ruck ball.

Too little respect is paid to how much of a pest he truly is to other sides, and this is a skill he and Skelton share, which Australian rugby will lose, again.

This is not only destabilising for the Force, but with Swain not currently in the inner circles of the Wallabies, his chance of being selected for higher honours from his new home, Clermont, will be close to nil.

This is where Rodda enters the equation. The towering lock had a horrendous run of injuries during his time at the Force, and eventually RA’s patience ran out, unable to offer him a decent deal to keep him in Perth.

Now, the 202cm and 123kg lock has already played more than twice as many games for his French club Provence in the second division ProD2 comp as he had for the Force.

To quell the fears some have about his robustness, he has almost played more games this 2025/26 season than he did for three years at the Force between the years 2022-2024.

Rodda is the profile of a player in the tight forwards you need available at all times: experienced, big, rugged, and strong at all parts of the game.

Visually, Rodda is an imposing figure, and he is a direct complement to other experienced heads like Lukhan Salakaia-Loto, Matt Philip, and Nick Frost, and can be a great mentor to the likes of Jeremy Williams, Josh Canham, and Lachie Shaw.

At 29 years old, Rodda, like many tight-five forwards, has his best years ahead of him. The Force and the Reds would greatly benefit from having him rejoin their ranks.

RA must capitalise on his time in the ProD2 and bring him home once again, much like the NZRU and Dave Rennie are contemplating with 34-year-old All Black, Brodie Retallick.

Related

Izaia Perese, centres/wing, 28yo, 6 Test Caps

At 179cm and 96kgs, Perese is almost a like-for-like with Japan-bound, Reds veteran, Hunter Paisami.

Perese is powerful, experienced, and at 28-years-old, he is entering his prime as a centre.

While Pasaimi is a defensive powerhouse who can, and has folded anyone he has come up against, Perese is more of an attacking weapon.

When Perese has the ball in hand, he is explosive, robust, and unpredictable. He also has great acceleration and top-end speed, making him a great person to put in the no.23 jersey on gameday.

The Force or the Waratahs would hugely benefit from bringing him into the fold. The Force lack punch and the Tahs lack centres and will do so even more once Joey Walton departs at the end of the season to France.

Yes, the Tahs will have Crichton, but they will need options, and the Wallabies can’t put all their eggs in the Angus basket.

Perese would be exactly the type of centre that Suaalii and Crichton could learn from.

The Reds and Brumbies have plenty of robust budding talent as well as some older heads, as mentioned above.

Perese is the profile of player RA and the Super Rugby clubs need in their ranks.

Head-to-Head

Last 5 Meetings

Wins
2
Draws
0
Wins
3
Average Points scored
26
39
First try wins
60%
Home team wins
80%

Noah Lolesio, flyhalf, 26yo, 30 Test caps

Currently, the crop of Super Rugby Pacific flyhalves in Australia is mostly aged between 22-27 years old.

Carter Gordon 24yo, Tom Lynagh 23yo, Harry McLaughlin-Phillips 22yo, and Jack Bowen 22yo.

Then there are the older players, Tane Edmed 25yo, Declan Meredith 26yo, Lawson Creighton 27yo, Ben Donaldson 27yo, and Jack Debreczeni 32 yo.

Of these players, only four have Test experience: Donaldson 19 caps, Gordon 9, Lynagh 7, and Edmed 9.

There is a gulf of experience if compared to Lolesio’s 30 caps.

Lolesio is the type of player RA and Super Rugby sides would benefit from bringing back into the fold.

His ability to game drive, to kick goals, and to read games is one of the best Australia can call upon, and he is a player Schmidt endorsed when fit.

Lolesio, like Perese and Rodda, is entering his prime as a player in a position where nous is more important than brawn. Lolesio is only going to get better.

The flyhalf of a team can’t just be flown in and flown out like James O’Connor was last year; they need to be a stable member of your side’s leadership and decision-making core.

Bringing Lolesio back to Aussie rugby is the only prudent thing to do.

It ensures he is getting the support he needs from RA and Wallaby staff, and it means he will be playing a higher level of rugby.

To be clear, Lolesio isn’t only playing rugby in Japanese Div 2 for Aichi Shuttles, he is carving up.

Last week he scored a hattrick of tries and has been their main game driver since he returned from injury. The fact that he had to have neck surgery after making a line break appears to be a distant memory for the pivot, who is playing with poise and finesse.

For Lolesio to come back, it would mean RA would have to pony up a solid figure, north of $600k a season, but for a Wallaby flyhalf with 30 caps, it is an amount definitely worth spending.

The Waratahs is the only home which makes sense for Lolesio.

He could once again link up with Debreczeni and would be with a bulk of the Wallabies backline, as well as be able to guide new recruit Crichton in his maiden Super Rugby season, heading into a World Cup.

Watch Super Rugby Pacific live and free on RugbyPassTV in the USA! 

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

70 Comments
A
Alex 45 days ago

Adam Coleman has been brilliant for Bordeaux too

S
SB 44 days ago

Yes, eligible only in July 2027 though.

J
JD 45 days ago

Oz are crying out for a Reece Hodge type - still under contract at Bayonne but injured for around 18 months now.


Adam Coleman is playing like a man possessed for Bordeaux but he is of course with Tonga now.


Petaia 100% would be ideal for the backline.


Lachlan Swinton is leaving Bordeaux this summer. Class player who will be a real asset for Oz again if he heads home.

J
John 44 days ago

Coleman is now Tongan at Test level and Hodge is still making his way back from injury I believe.


Petaia’s form is questionable.


Swinton is a great shout and the best new pick I’ve seen in these comments.

r
rs 45 days ago

Would’ve thought Petaia would be a useful one. They need a 100kg+ centre at 12, and he’s playing on the outside backs in France, which is no good to the wallabies needs.

J
John 44 days ago

He is not playing great at Perpingnan and is headed to Japan. So I am unsure if he should be top of the list.

T
Two Cents 45 days ago

So they lied to us again. How exactly are Phil and Dan any better than the Castle and the Hamster?


RA seems to be operating under the misconception that the Wallabies jersey is the carrot in itself and not simply a means by which a player can secure a higher asking price.


The prestige that had been won by the teams of Jones, Dwyer and McQueen has long since tarnished and although there was a marginal buffing under both Deans and then Cheika it's now completely corroded and won't shine again.


At least not until significant structural changes are made and one of those changes, in fact it should be the first change and it should be made immediately, is to abolish our eligibility rules entirely. Scrap them because we don't need them anymore.


They're literally an anchor dragging Australian rugby down. So get rid of them. Selection should be a rigorous process based entirely on merit not arbitrarily decided by where you play and who pays your salary.


It is a fruitless debate to discuss amongst ourselves who we think deserves to be called up because we all already know who is going to be in the team and none of the people you suggest are on that list.


Hooper and Lenny and Ball are exceptions because they're still technically under contract to RA and even though Hooper has now extended his sabbatical to 27 and Lenny and Ball may do the same, they're still ostensibly part of the system. And they “left” with RA’s blessing.


However, players like JOC, Lolo, Staniforth the youngest, Banks, Ramm, Rodda, Kemeny, Perese, etc, were essentially cast out by RA which led to them ending up where they're now playing. So I don't see RA essentially walking back that decision by then selecting those players they rejected.


Especially since they deceived us all by saying they had scrapped the restrictions when they hadn't and actually never had any intention of doing so. It was a lie designed to trick more players into sticking with Australian rugby.


And it has partially worked. But now that the cat is out of the bag and we are still a year out from the World Cup, there's probably many players starting to reconsider, especially those light on game time, when they see the huge amounts being offered to code hoppers and being earned off shore.


Since the prospects for Australia at the World Cup are next to nil at progressing beyond the quarters in the best foreseeable scenario, how is even the potential of a call up enough of an incentive, especially when RA has a track record of sticking doggedly with incumbents even when they're not delivering?


Once again we have the genuine opportunity to test combinations but instead RA is going to be chasing an impossible glory by forcing the selection of the team they're convinced has the least likelihood of losing badly rather than choosing the side that has the best possible chance of winning?


We already know what is going to happen in July. Aside from injuries and non availability, Ireland will defeat us comfortably and depleted Italian and French sides will test us but we will just win. 2 out of 3 [sic] ain't bad.


Then we will be tested by Japan but probably win both games and we will lose at least one test to Argentina, possibly both. 2/4 or 3/4 and they'll say it was what they expected.


Then of course we have the tests against the Boks and Kiwis and we will likely lose all those games but make a competitive showing in at least 2. Again, building for the future.


Finally, the return leg of the championship in November to round out the year and England and Scotland will flog us and Wales will possibly beat us again at last.


So from 14 tests, we will come away with a possible 5 wins. Embarrassing just doesn't even cover it anymore. The self deception that this year is somehow our year despite having no basis for such optimism allows RA to get away with it's continuing profligacy and incompetence.


The only way we can get meaningful change is by voting with our feet. If people stop buying tickets to see live games, RA will have to make the hard decisions they have been avoiding for more than a decade now.

J
John 44 days ago

My point is that if we sign these people in Super, then we don’t have to use the 3 OS picks. Bypasses the need for that particular debate.

Q
Qualify 45 days ago

Haha, c'mon. Noah? Again? He couldn’t cut it after 30 odd tests. Let’s move on, please. An injury free Carter Gordon is the future.

P
PM 45 days ago

I think bringing him back is a step backwards.

T
Two Cents 45 days ago

Hasn't worked so far. But good luck with that.

C
Cameron 45 days ago

Please stop sending people to the Force and Tahs, careers go there to die. As you said yourself in the article, Rodda went there for three years and played less games in total than in a partial French season. Lolesio must return to the Brumbies.


The others we don’t really need at Test level, or even at club level (even the Force now have reasonable depth, in fact I just saw Taj Annan playing club footy in Newcastle on the weekend because he was surplus to requirements) and if we did we could pick them from overseas.

S
SB 45 days ago

Tom Banks would be another good one. However with the Wallabies being able to select anyone from anywhere, it shouldn’t really matter.

P
PP 44 days ago

Tom Banks, Alex Newsome, Izaia Perese & Irae Simone are all performing at a high level with their respective overseas clubs. They have become much better all-round players since leaving SR.

J
JD 45 days ago

Banks just extended at Montpelier.

J
Jez Nez 45 days ago

Hate this three player selection rule.


Wallabies don’t have the depth to be able to ignore many of our best.


Doesn’t work for Super either, the whole aim of limiting Wallaby selection is to keep players here. Newsflash, it isn’t keeping enough players here and RA can’t afford the salaries that would keep them here.


There is a good chance we don’t have a team in the top four by end of Super’s regular season.

J
JW 44 days ago

The idea definitely works, it is when you’re on the edge of collapse you have to ask yourself “is this idea the best?”.

J
JW 45 days ago

Sorry why are we only picking three John?


I’d probably look at it from the other direction, and bring back a bigger group more the likes of Samu and Philip. Players like Pelegrini, Coleman, Alaalatoa, the Arnold brothers? Perhaps even the likes of Tom Banks has learnt enough tips and tricks offshore to cover 10!


But yeah, go the SR depth route, those selections (of yours) I feel (and possibly mine too) like you would need to offer Wallaby retainers (and so avoiding those could give you more hang for you buck). Bell is only away on sabbatical? Wasn’t Cale leaving as well?


On the flip didn’t I hear Ramm was coming back? Agree with the outlook though, but to be quite honest I wonder if Cooper would add more value than Lolesio is where I’m coming from.

T
Two Cents 45 days ago

The issue seems to be that RA still has the Giteau Law in place so 3 OS players is all that Joe and Les can pick.


They lied that they’d abolished it and opened selection up. But it wasn't true. They never had any intention of selecting more than 3 non-Australian based players.


So the 3 OS picks will be who we already know: Hooper, Lenny and Bell. That's it.

M
MitchO 45 days ago

Coleman and Sio played for their heritage island teams so don’t qualify

N
NHinSH 45 days ago

Being a Saints man I'd hate it but Kemeny should be up there as well

J
John 45 days ago

So you would be willing to lose him to a Super Rugby side? that is very big of you !

R
Rugby3 45 days ago

Izaak Rodda would be a huge gain for the Wallabies.

J
JW 44 days ago

You don’t want to go too far on the depth side though right?

Tahs have Samu/Gamble

Reds McRight/Brial

Brumbies Valetini/?

Perth Tizzano/CDC


Obviously 8’s can be universal too but generally not desiring those player types (some have been used at 8 I think), so assuming 8s are a seperate group you can assure quality in, maybe theres one starting berth at the Brumbies that would be good for a quality player like kemeny? When they Have Reimer on the bench though I might just not know how good their starters are yet!

B
Ben Casey 45 days ago

Tom Staniforth for me is Number 1(don’t believe he was capped in France A or anything yet?), then Ikitau, than Taniela depending upon form/injury, than Marky Mark. Tom Hooper is world class, but we have a plethora of backrowers, so unless he focused more on his second row work, I think Wallabies as a team have greater needs. Marky, Max and JSA headline our back three, but plenty to back them up. For me, centre, Lock (especially) and front row are our depth issues. One of the flyhalves will just have to stand up.

J
John 44 days ago

What Super Rugby team are you putting Staniforth in?

S
SB 45 days ago

Correct, he did train the whole time with the French team during the 6N. I expect him to get his France debut in July if Australia do not want him.

J
John 45 days ago

To be clear, you are saying this as bring Staniforth to Super?

N
NH 45 days ago

Other names I’d throw in are reece hodge, petaia and any front row stocks tbh. Noah and Rodda good shouts, not so sure about perese given you mention hunter who has better handling and we can get attacking threat from suaalii if thats the way you want to go. When I think of what wallabies are missing its probably: size and experience in the backline - so the likes of noah, hodge, and any big back like petaia come into conversations. In the forwards, we will always need tight 5 depth and so anyone in that space comes to mind like Rodda, and others like a uelese, sio etc but unsure how they’re playing. And then obviously ikitau and hooper as they are class. Oh and Bell!?!?!

J
JD 45 days ago

Hodge has been injured for well over a year and a half. His career is over.

J
John 45 days ago

Where would you put Petaia in Super and Hodge? What position are you playing Hodge?

B
Ben Casey 45 days ago

I don’t believe Reece Hodge has made it back on to the paddock yet? I am behind on my Aussies Abroad articles, but hadn’t been cited for some time as of 3 weeks ago. As a Reds man I am a big fan of Petaia, but his form for Perpignan hasn’t been outstanding, and he is off to Japan.

A
Ardy 45 days ago

I find it ironic that some in the media are saying that Darcy Swain is a loss, when they demonised him as a ‘thug’, and some posters suggested he should never play the game again. I think this ‘hate spate’ has lost us a decent lock with a good future, same as losing Skelton, because the media/posters thought him close to useless.

As a rugby nation, we are lacking the ability to understand what makes a decent lock.

They only think of ‘Nobody’ John Eales as the model, and not the freak he was.

S
SB 44 days ago

Swain is a quality player. That incident was ages ago and Quinn Tupaea is back playing well now. So time to move on.


I think Swain should’ve played way more last year for the Wallabies. Particularly when Frost was exhausted.

J
John 45 days ago

I agree with this.

u
unknown 45 days ago

Ikatua , Lolisio and Tom Hooper are the only three we need .

Loto is in VG form we don’t need Skeleton or Rhoda .

Daugunu is also in VG form .

J
John 45 days ago

To be clear, the point of the article is summarised in these three short paragraphs about why bringing them back to Super is a better way to get them included rather than using them as a Overseas Pick:


“The Wallabies can’t rely on exceptions for success, and they can’t rely on overseas talent while the administration works to have a ‘domestic-first’ policy with an opaque and ambiguous selection policy on OS based players.


Therefore, RA and the Wallabies must work to bring the right talent back to Aussie shores.


They need experienced campaigners, proven players who understand the rigours of Test match rugby and who can be a dominant force for their provincial clubs in Super Rugby Pacific.”

T
Tah Man Too 45 days ago

They should have treated Swain better last year. He was called up for the end of season tour just to hold the tackle bags. I'm sure that made up his mind to bugger off and go get a better pay check overseas, and good luck to him. I hope they treat Amatosero better, we need to develop a better depth level, by actually playing fringe starters against some of the less competitive teams. I'd love to see him in the squad this year and getting a jersey or 2 against Japan.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close