The end of a high-octane 10 weeks of New Zealand Rugby has been celebrated by the selection of an official team of the season by Super Rugby.
However, the team has once again not gone down well with fans, as Super Rugby’s selection is based on surface-level stats that fail to capture other areas of importance, such as speed, vision, tempo, decision-making, strategy, and system fit.
The official team had no place for current All Black halfback Aaron Smith, who is widely regarded as being in the form of his life at the Highlanders, with Hurricanes halfback TJ Perenara picked instead.
Aaron Smith’s quick tempo and lightening fast recycles at the right times led to the creation of many Highlanders’ tries, albeit the final pass was usually delivered by someone else out wide. His decision-making around when to link with his backs or play flat forward runners was often a key component of directing the Highlanders’ game.
The halfback’s running game also had a resurgence with shades of his earlier self, resulting in many breaks and good support lines. Fans asked whether Super Rugby ‘had watched any of the games’ as Aaron Smith was ‘clearly heads and shoulders’ above every other halfback, with one fan claiming he was ‘literally the player of the season.’
How do you not pick Aaron Smith?! Y'all obviously didn't watch any Highlanders games. https://t.co/njChVLSHit
— Christopher Reive (@ChrisReive) August 18, 2020
How can the even debate against @Te_Nug? Best 9 in the comp
— BathBytes (@BathBytes) August 18, 2020
Aaron Smith is NZ's best rugby player right now. End of.
— Gary Dooley (@NaturalGaz) August 18, 2020
No Jordie Barrett either
— Alex (@Alex_Gainey_) August 18, 2020
Crusaders obviously the team of the tournament. But Jordie Barrett was the best player.
— Gumby (@GumbaliciousDef) August 18, 2020
Absolute fact; Aaron Smith had been head and shoulders above any halfback in this competition
— It's always a good day for science (@fdude85) August 18, 2020
Jordie Barrett >> Jordan
— Njau (@_martinjoroge_) August 18, 2020
— Cory (@808Cory) August 18, 2020
– Smith at halfback was dynamite
– Jordie transformed the Canes (Jordan can go on the wing in place of Reece)
— J Mac (@jimimac_alf) August 18, 2020
Will Jordan over Jordie…???? pic.twitter.com/0a8hQX5Ec4
— Joseph (@joenotaverage) August 18, 2020
The Hurricanes started 0-2 without Barrett but when he returned they went on a 5-0 run before losing their last game in the final round to the Highlanders in Dunedin. In all of the Hurricanes wins, Jordie played an important part as the primary goal kicker and key playmaker out wide.
In the head-t0-head battle between the two fullbacks in Christchurch, it was Jordie Barrett who was immense under the high ball diffusing a number of Crusaders box kicks and bombs, whilst kicking the key goals to keep his side in the game.
Against his brother when the Blues visited Wellington, Jordie Barrett nailed a clutch conversion to put the Hurricanes ahead 29-27 over the Blues with just three minutes remaining.
Will Jordan was one of the competition’s top running threats, finishing first in tries scored and second in defenders beaten and line breaks, but it is blurred by the fact that some of that was done playing on the right wing, particularly against the Highlanders in Dunedin with a scorching two-try performance while against the Blues Jordan was used as a late game substitute.
The two fullbacks won’t get a chance to face off in the North vs South game either with both picked for the South Island due to Jordie Barrett’s provincial debut with Canterbury, despite growing up in the Taranaki and his brother Beauden playing for the North.
Sign up to our mailing list for a weekly digest from the wide world of rugby.Sign Up Now