1
'There is confusion': Ian Foster on the problem areas in Super Rugby for the All Blacks
Now former All Blacks coach Ian Foster has weighed in on the state of Super Rugby Pacific and its ability to prepare New Zealand players for the international level.
ADVERTISEMENT
The All Blacks were able to make it to another Rugby World Cup final despite challenging results against South Africa, Argentina, France and Ireland over the years leading into the event.
The international game has become more competitive than ever placing more emphasis on Super Rugby to produce international-quality players.
Foster said all is not lost with Super Rugby but that it requires a “massive” amount of attention to restore its status.
“I think it can be,” Foster said on The Platform NZ when asked if Super Rugby prepares players for international rugby.
“The Super Rugby competition needs a massive amount of attention.
“It’s critical to the All Blacks, that we have strong rugby clubs. I think we have.”
The coach explained that the critical area in need of change is player development, which has been identified as an ongoing issue in New Zealand’s governance review.
The issue is who is best placed to deliver that between Super Rugby clubs and provincial unions, who have invested heavily in player development with funding from NZR.
ADVERTISEMENT
Foster identified the U20 level and below as an area that “hasn’t been nailed” for some time with a state of confusion taking hold.
The results at the World U20 Championships for New Zealand haven’t been great for some years, with the last championship title coming in 2017.
“The only way to keep developing those clubs is to fine tune our development systems from underneath that,” he said.
“There is confusion in that area about how we develop our next players.
ADVERTISEMENT
“We are still stringing that out at U20 age group, where we haven’t nailed that for a decent amount of time.
“That’s our development programme. It’s not all about the U20 team as such, but the programme underneath that gets players to that point.
“That’s critical that we find a way through in that area.”
The other area that Foster highlighted as an issue is the diversity of playing styles since teams from South Africa, Japan and Argentina have disbanded or gone elsewhere.
He revealed that it took the All Blacks a couple of years to get used to playing different styles after the 2020 and 2021 seasons which saw a lot of internal rugby in New Zealand.
The All Blacks were shocked by Argentina in 2020 and 2022 whilst ended up losing to South Africa at least once every year from 2021. When they played Japan in late 2022 there was only seven points between the two sides.
Super Rugby Pacific added new teams in the Fijian Drua and Moana Pasifika but the absence of a wide variety of styles is being felt.
“We’ve got to make sure that Super Rugby is a viable competition and that our players are playing teams with a diverse way of playing,” he said.
“Certainly we narrowed down during Covid, we ended up playing ourselves.
“I think it took a bit to recover from that in 2022 and 2023 at international level and start to get used to playing different styles of rugby again.
“The more we do that the better.”
The Crusaders have been leading the way in player development for years. The model for pathway success from schoolboys, to academy, to provincial, then super, perhaps higher, is in place. Each super rugby franchise needs to step up.
As for covid “narrowing down” well, this was a global issue. And doesn’t account for the poor start in the first 5 tests under Foster (4 v Wallabies & 1 v Pumas). The results were 2 wins, 2 losses & a draw (but for a late penalty hitting the upright would’ve also been a loss).
I detect a hint of rewriting history seeping into these “Foster” articles. Cut it out!!
Super rugby is in really dire conditions because it is bound to the fate of Australian rugby. If the Wallabies go down to record defeats agains the BI Lions then I fear the sport in Australia might never recover. They really need to get their house in order and fast.
The problem is Rassie and the Boks.
It can’t be that bad. They were the best team in the knockout stages and only lost due to inept TMO and officiating.
No Ian, NZ and Aus just need to create that diversity themselves.