Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

South Africa player ratings | 2024 Autumn Nations Series

By Philip Bendon at Principality Stadium, Cardiff
Franco Mostert

South African player ratings: South Africa completed an unbeaten tour of the United Kingdom with a 45 – 12 victory over Wales at the Millennium Stadium in Cardiff.

ADVERTISEMENT

Starting hot, the Springboks scored two tries inside the opening ten minutes through their secondrows Franco Mostert and Eben Etzebth.

Dominating their hosts physically from the off, the World Champions rarely looked challenged through the opening half.

In the second half, Wales launched a spirited attack on their visitors, ending the match with a try for James Botham to go with Rio Dyer’s late try in the first half.

Overall, the Boks were simply in a different league physically to their hosts and battered their way to victory.

Here is how the South African players fared in Cardiff.

1. Thomas du Toit – 7
Struggled initially to get to grips with Archie Griffin at scrum time but grew into the contest as time progressed. Once comfortable, du Toit and his front-row buddies walked over to their Welsh counterparts. In open play, the Bath star was his usual brilliant self and, if anything, looked a bit fresher playing in the loosehead role.

2. Johan Grobbelaar – 8
Arguably one of the most important breakthrough players for the Boks in 2024, given the age profile of the two players ahead of him in the pecking order. The Bulls Hooker was tireless as he played a key role in ensuring the Boks lightening quick ruck speed (63% 0-3sec) during his time on the park.

ADVERTISEMENT

3. Wilco Louw – 8
Simply obliterated Nicky Smith at scrum time, albeit it wasn’t entirely the Welsh loosehead’s fault. When he departed in the 46th minute, Louw had overseen a near-perfect day at set piece time to go with his 2 carries, 6 tackles and 2 defenders beaten. All in all, it was a good day for 144kg Vodacom Bull.

4. Eben Etzebeth – 7
Stuck in the middle of everything positive the Boks achieved, Etzebeth roamed the wider channels as a kick reception option and a support runner. Unfortunately for the Sharks man, he hobbled off 29 minutes into the match, albeit he wreaked havoc during that period.

5. Franco Mostert – 8.5
Haring down the right touchline like rampaging wildebeest for the opening try of the match, Mostert was busy from the off. Being named the player of the match following a 15 carry, 6 line-outs won, and 13 tackle performance was just reward for the often underrated lock.

6. Siya Kolisi – 7.5
Doing the hard yard for his side, Kolisi was in seek-and-destroy mode. On the rare occasion that the Boks had to defend, he was at the front and centre of their rush defence. Even when he didn’t make the tackle, his pace off the line forced Wales to rush the pass and ultimately stunted their momentum.

ADVERTISEMENT

7. Elrigh Louw – 6.5
Similar to the man he replaced this week in Pieter-Steph Du Toit, Louw’s work rate was phenomenal during his 41 minutes on the park. Carrying the ball 8 times, winning 2 line-outs and scoring a try was a solid return for the rangy backrow.

8. Jasper Wiese – 8
Pinballing through Welsh defenders as his team’s top carrier. Perhaps the most apt way to sum up Wiese’s performance is to compare him to a Toyota Land Cruiser chomping through an overland park in second gear. Concluding his day in the 60th minute, having made 19 carries for 69 meters and 3 defenders beaten.

9. Jaden Hendrikse – 6
Forming a mind meld with his brother, the older Hendrikse was solid overall but, in truth, was handed an armchair ride by a pack that was always on the front foot. This dominance ensured he was rarely hassled, but he did, by and large, take the correct options, which kept his side rolling.

10. Jordan Hendrikse – 7
Clean, professional and with just enough sprinkling of stardust to remind everyone that he could be a game-breaker with more experience. Benefitting from his pack’s dominance, Hendrikse was never tested in terms of needing to clear his lines or put his team in the right positions. Playing what was in front of him, Hendrikse facilitated some great play for those around him and got some nice width on his passing game.

11. Kurt-Lee Arendse – 8.5
Fizzing with enthusiasm every time the ball came close to his area, the Bulls winger was untouchable today. Mirroring Kolbe’s quick step for his score against England, Arendse put on some ‘routine’ footwork to leave the Welsh cover defence clutching at ghosts for his first try. Every time he subsequently received the ball, the Welsh defence was on high alert, and for good reason, his ability to occupy defenders before setting a teammate free was exceptional. A primary example of this was Fassi’s try in the 54th minute, where Arendse realistically could’ve gone the whole way himself but opened the lane for his fullback.

12. Damian de Allende – 7
Showing his subtle skills once again today, de Allende had some nice soft touches which facilitated those around him. Mixing in his usual physicality with these soft skills, de Allende had one of his now weekly big bursts through the Welsh defence which brought him within a meter of a try to start the second half.

13. Jesse Kriel – 8
Firmly in the honeymoon period of his late career renaissance, Kriel is playing the best rugby of his career. Hitting perfect lines off his centre partner, Kriel found himself in the open prairie on a handful of occasions. In this scenario, many players would look to force their hand, but the veteran always stayed calm and took the right option. This was never more evident than in the build-up to Mostert’s try, where Kolbe was in a position to make key yards following a sublime break.

14. Cheslin Kolbe – 8
For a player who is renowned for moments of individual brilliance, Kolbe’s ability to set up those around him for success was on full show today. Hitting perfect lines, making yards in contact and then getting the ball away with either an offload or a perfectly placed ball for quick recycling, Kolbe did it all today. Such is his presence that the Welsh defenders honey-potted around him, thus opening acres of space for those around him. Confirming this eye test was the stat that shows Kolbe beat 7 defenders and had 6 offloads.

15. Aphelele Fassi – 8
Beating more defenders than any other player in the first half (4), the Sharks fullback returned every Welsh kick with interest. Scanning the pitch, Fassi continually took the right option, whether it was to find support or hit space. Rounding out his day with 15 carries for 94 meters with 5 defenders beaten and 5 offloads shows just how effective he was.

Substitutes
16. Malcolm Marx – 7.5
Professional Rugby’s ultimate impact hooker. Marx might lack that slight edge in terms of the pace that he enjoyed during his younger years, but his power remains elite. Driving through contact, Marx was rarely stopped on the first contact.

17. Gerhard Steenekamp – 8
Bringing some extra oomph from the bench, Steenekamp took advantage of tiring Welsh defenders for a perfectly taken try in the 62nd minute. At set piece time, he upped the ante by obliterating the Welsh scrum.

18. Vincent Koch – 6.5
Picking up where Louw left off at scrum time, the wily tighthead drove straight through Keiron Assiratti. Around the park, Koch fronted up and made tackles when he needed to but was found to be doing most of his work around the breakdown.

19. Marco van Staden – 6.5
Slotted in as the Boks’ battering ram when he replaced Jasper Wiese in the 60th minute. This role allowed Hanekom to play a roaming game that suited his skill set. This snapshot sums up what van Staden brings to the Boks as a player who does the hard yard to allow those around him to shine.

20. RG Snyman – 8
Entered the contest and immediately pulled off a now routine offload, which set up what looked set to be a try for Siya Kolisi. Unfortunately for the Boks, Jaden Hendrikse had a slight knock-on in the build-up, which chalked off the try.

21. Cameron Hanekom – 7.5
Did exactly what a highly touted debutant should do and slotted in seamlessly. Getting on the ball for a few nice carries, Hanekom’s footwork before contact ensured he was always in a position to either set up a quick ruck clear-out or find an offload. At line-out time, his jumping speed was notable as he became a good option at the back.

22. Cobus Reinach – 7
Added some needed zip into the Bok attack in the 60th minute and immediately got his pack going forward. This tempo made the Welsh defence untenable, with Steenekamp being the beneficiary with an old-school Springbok try. Adding another try assist to his stat line with a Sonny-Bill Williams-style offload, Reinach proved that even at 34-years-old he is still an electric operator.

23. Handre Pollard – 7
Slotting in at inside centre for the final half an hour, Pollard looked super comfortable as a second distributor in what could be his perfect role going forward. Taking the pressure off Hendrikse whilst showing the Welsh a different picture from midfield scrums, Pollard took on the defensive line and really opened up the width of the Bok attack.

Watch the highly acclaimed five-part documentary Chasing the Sun 2, chronicling the journey of the Springboks as they strive to successfully defend the Rugby World Cup, free on RugbyPass TV (*unavailable in Africa)

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

9 Comments
J
JK 16 days ago

Too many boks held up in when touching down - Siya and Fassi should've scored


At least the line-out is getting better. A good tour but a soft finish in H2 in this game I think

S
SF 16 days ago

As Naas would say... A win is a win.

It was not perfect and at times frustrating. All 3 tests were not the best by the Boks and they still found ways to win.

Rassie would have noted the sloppyness at times and silly mistakes. The 9's made amateur handling mistakes when clearing the rucks in all 3 tests.

Once the "stupid" mistakes are eliminated, this Bok team will be very very hard to beat.

B
Bull Shark 16 days ago

Giving 52 players caps in a calendar year over 13 matches. When the majority of the players don’t play with each other (I.e. domestically etc) and you’re bound to see less than polished performances.


In the past, the boks would lose games in the name of building. Now they win games with less than perfect performances. Even Score 7 tries playing poorly.


I’m happy with that.

J
JW 16 days ago

Weres Hellhound, can anyone else see his posts?


Love the detailed review of everyone, SB have the best diehard fans going around.

T
The One 17 days ago

I'd rate the brothers Hendricks a point or two lower. Jaden has really not delivered on his early promise and Jordan's kicking at posts was quite erratic. Amongst other things.


I was really surprised that DuhDuh was replaced and not Jordan. DuhDuh had a great game and just underlined his class in a backline that was not firing on all cylinders.


Damian Willemse was missed. Hopefully he'll be back to full fitness and have an injury free 2025 (and '26 and '27 and so on until he decides to retire to spend time with his grandchildren).


RG was great. What an athlete.


Very happy that Hanekom made his debut at last. He gave a good account of himself and will hopefully grow into his role on the international stage.


All things considered, this was another frustrating Bok performance. Even though it was a comfortable win, it wasn't a commanding win. This Welsh team should've been put away by a far larger margin.


But I have faith in Dr Rassie. He knows more than I do. Bring on 2027 😁

B
Bull Shark 17 days ago

Siya’s rating is a joke. He was everywhere and didn’t put a foot out of line. Played 80. Compared to Eben who only played 30 minutes?


Thomas du Toit’s rating also baffling.


But regardless, a pretty dominant showing all around.

J
JW 16 days ago

"Stuck in the middle of everything positive the Boks achieved" thats a great effort for someone only on the field for a third of the game!

H
Hellhound 16 days ago

There is this thing going around against Siya Kolisi where they don't want him to be known as the best national captain ever, so they strike him down in ratings permanently whenever they can. They want McCaw and reckons he is the best captain ever. I disagree.


Just like they refuse to see SA as the best team and some have even said that should the Boks win a third WC in a row, they will still not be the best team ever. Even if they win every game between now and the WC. That is some serious hate coming SA's way.


Everyone forget how the McCaw AB's intimidated refs, was always on the wrong side, played on the ground etc. Things they would never have gotten away with today. They may have a better win ratio, but SA build depth, not caring about rank inbetween WC's until this year.


They weren't as bad inbetween as people claim, because non e of their losses was big ones and they almost never faced the strongest Bok team outside of the WC, allowing countries like France and Ireland to rise to the top unopposed.


Rassie is still at it, building more depth, getting more young stars into the fold. By the time he leaves (I hope never) he will leave a very strong Bok side for the next 15- 20 years. Not everyone will play for 20 years, but each year Rassie acknowledge the young stars and get them involved and ready for international rugby.


Not everyone will make it to the WC, but those 51/52 players will compete for those spots for the WC. They will deliver their best. The future of the Boks is in very safe hands. The only thing that bothers me is Rassie's health. If he can overcome it, rugby looks dark for the rest of the rugby world. He is already the greatest coach in WR history. By the time he retires, he will be the biggest legend any sport has ever seen

H
Hellhound 17 days ago

Well the game went as expected. Huge blow out.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

J
JW 33 minutes ago
'Razor's conservatism is in danger of halting New Zealand's progress'

Razor is compensating, and not just for the Foster era.


Thanks again for doing the ground work on some revealing data Nick.


This article misses some key points points that are essential to this debate though;


Razor is under far more pressure than Rassie to win

Rassie is a bolder selector than Razor, and far more likely to embrace risk under pressure than his counterpart from New Zealand.

It doesn't realise the difficulties of a country like South Africa, with no rugby season to speak of at the moment, to get full use out of overseas internationals

Neither world player of the year Pieter-Steph du Toit nor all-world second row Eben Etzebeth were automatic selections despite the undue influence they exert on games in which they play.

The last is that one coach is 7 years into his era, where the other is in his first, and is starting with a far worse blank slate than where upon South Africa's canvas could be layered onto after 2017.

The spread at the bottom end is nothing short of spectacular. Seventeen more South Africans than New Zealanders started between one and five games in 2024.

That said, I think the balance needs to be at least somewhere in the middle. I don't know how much that is going to be down to Razor's courage, and New Zealands appetite however.


Sadly I think it is going to continue and the problem is going to be masked by much better results next year, even forgotten with an undefeated season. Because even this article appears to misconstruing the..

known quantities

as being TJP and Sam Cane. In the context of what would need to change for the numbers above to be similar, it's players like Jordie Barrett, Beauden Barrett, Rieko Ioane, Sevu Reece, Ethan Blackadder, Codie Taylor, where the reality needs to be meet face on.


On Jordie Barrett at Lienster, I really hope he can be taught how to tackle with a hard shoulder like Henshaw and Ringrose have. You can see in these highlights he doesn't have the physical presence of those two, or even the ones behind him in NZ like ALB and AJ Lam. I can't really seem him making leaps in other facets if he's already making headlines now.

9 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING South Africa win title at home, New Zealand triumph as Cape Town champions South Africa win title at home, New Zealand triumph as CPT champions
Search