Northern | US

'Gutted' England star ruled out of tour as skipper admits area that 'let us down'


England's prop Ellis Genge (4th R) and England's hooker Jamie George (2nd R) react during the rugby Nations Championship match between South Africa and England at Ellis Park Stadium in Johannesburg on July 4, 2026. (Photo by PHILL MAGAKOE / AFP via Getty Images)
Comments
15 Comments

Jamie George admitted England were punished for their indiscipline as they crashed to a fifth straight Test defeat after being outclassed 45-21 by South Africa at Ellis Park.

ADVERTISEMENT

Tommy Freeman and Guy Pepper were shown yellow cards for illegal tackles that meant Steve Borthwick’s tourists were forced to play the final seven minutes of their Nations Championship opener with only 13 men.

Inevitably they then leaked tries to Malcolm Marx and BJ Dixon to complete a harrowing evening in Johannesburg.

VIDEO

England have now been hit with 10 yellow cards and one red in their six games in 2026 to continue the self-destructive theme that was raised by their post-Six Nations review as an area of concern.

Captain George said: “There are some clear things we need to make sure we get better at and as players we have to take a lot more responsibility with regards to our discipline, which let us down.

Fixture
Nations Championship
Argentina
38 - 47
Full-time
Scotland
All Stats and Data

“Outside of that, there were periods where we put the Springboks under a lot of pressure. Speaking to their guys they know they have been in a Test match.

“We are going to be a significantly better team off the back of this experience with a young team coming here and understanding how we put them under a lot of pressure and also understanding how we let that pressure get to us a little bit.

ADVERTISEMENT

“This is going to be a great learning experience for us but we are gutted because we genuinely believed we could come here and win.

“We are going to rally round, stay tight and we are all looking forward to getting to Liverpool and putting in a great performance against Fiji.”

Freeman was sent to the sin-bin for a dangerous tackle in the 71st minute and a minute later Pepper followed him into the stands for a late challenge.

In reality the game had already been lost after the world champions cranked up the power in the second half and Borthwick refused to blame either player.

ADVERTISEMENT

The head coach said: “If you look at the Tommy Freeman one you see a slight timing error, there wasn’t anything malicious or reckless there. He was trying to make a tackle and he was apologetic for the tackling height.

“The Guy Pepper one, South Africa put players under pressure because that is the way they play and they are very good.

“We want our execution and decision making to be at a very high level and these young players will learn from this experience of playing against the best in the world.”

Borthwick confirmed that full-back George Furbank will miss the rest of the July tour after he was withdrawn from the team to face South Africa because of appendicitis.

The England boss said: “He went into hospital on Friday evening with abdominal pain, he had surgery this morning on his appendix and he is still in hospital recovering.

“I spoke with him earlier, he is gutted and he will miss the next couple of weeks. He will be delayed in South Africa to fly back at a later date.”

Nations Championship

Watch Hemispheres collide as North faces South in the brand new Nations Championship. Live matches, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV here

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

15 Comments
M
Muchopompos 45 days ago

I don't think Van Portfleet is of a good enough standard to play international rugby, but he still gets picked. Curious.

f
fl 45 days ago

This wasn't a game between a good team and a bad team, it was a game between a team that was trying to win, and a team that wasn't.


For 60 minutes England proved they are a world class set of players with great tactics. For the first 10 and last 10 minutes they proved that wearing the shirt means nothing to them.


I don't know where we go from here.

u
unknown 45 days ago

It’s the indiscipline that let them down ? Really ? Just that ? How about the fact that we’re still trying to play a brand of rugby that went out years ago. I watched most of the games yesterday and every other team is trying to play a fast fluid game with players supporting the ball carrier so that they can progress line breaks creating exciting rugby. England ? Let’s slow it down in the forwards, then get the slowest scrum half in the history of world rugby to kick it away meaninglessly. Oh …. and don’t get your players to chase the kicks. We’re relying on individuals to create something but even when they do no-one has the foresight, or basic ability, to back it up. Borthwick must go and he can take his ‘coaching team’ with him.

P
PMcD 45 days ago

So, England do a full report after the 6 Nations, say the losses were down to discipline, giving away so many yellow cards and how they will learn from this and do better.


Looks like we aren’t listening, or need to improve our learning. Well beaten by a better team - no excuses, we weren’t good enough from the start.

G
GrahamVF 45 days ago

Hi P. I am more relieved than exuberant after yesterday, especially after the second half of the first half when it looked like we were going to do an Australia at Ellis Park again. I am always loathe to blame the two regular scapegoats, the ref and the coach, but having said that I sincerely believe that was not the best squad England could summons, not the best match day selections and certainly not the best tactical approach. I mean if you are going to kick Garry Owens all day why have your tallest available back at outside centre when he is clearly a specialist winger?

C
Conrad 45 days ago

“..he had surgery this morning on his appendix...”


“I spoke with him earlier, he is gutted…”


Slowly appreciating Steve's very arch sense of humour. He's misunderstood.

S
SB 45 days ago

Furbank out, how sad. Was looking forward to seeing how he’d do at 15.

G
GrahamVF 45 days ago

Bad luck to lose Stewart and Furbank on tour.

H
Hammer Head 45 days ago

I’m not sure Freeman’s was a timing error - he made no effort to go low.

T
Tom 45 days ago

Yeah was just a tired attempt

S
SB 45 days ago

Got there too quick I think.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close