Northern | US

Heated debate over who should be Australia's No9 for World Cup


Nic White celebrates his try against the All Blacks last Saturday (Photo by Getty Images)
Comments
Comment

Over the past decade, the 103-cap veteran Will Genia has had more or less complete control over the Wallabies No9 shirt but has had to settle for the bench over the past month. 

ADVERTISEMENT

Michael Cheika opted to start Nic White at scrum-half against the Springboks and the All Blacks, and he is set to start there again this Saturday at Eden Park in the second Bledisloe Cup test. 

With the World Cup just over a month away, many would have thought that Cheika chose to play White to test how he plays as he knows exactly what he is getting from Genia. 

White only recently moved back to Australia after a four-year stint with Montpellier and Exeter Chiefs, and Cheika would have wanted to scout his other scrum-half options ahead of the world showcase in Japan. 

However, the performances by the former Exeter man, particularly against the All Blacks last weekend, have suddenly made the 29-year-old the Wallabies’ first choice scrum-half according to many fans on social media. 

Such a rise was probably not expected by the Australian public, particularly as it was touch-and-go a few months ago as to whether White would even be returning to Australia. 

But a scintillating performance last weekend in Perth against the All Blacks, in which Steve Hansen’s side conceded their record number of points in a 47-26 loss, makes it hard to ignore White now. 

ADVERTISEMENT

He bossed the game the whole time he was on, causing havoc around the fringes of the ruck, and helped starve the All Blacks of possession. He finished a brilliant team try to cap off his performance as well. 

https://www.instagram.com/p/B1AeiA8AIoB/

Since then, there has been a clear rift amongst fans, from both Australia and abroad, as to who should be the first choice scrum-half come the World Cup. 

White has won over a lot of people, including former Ireland international Tommy Bowe, which was inevitable after his display against the All Blacks. 

White seems to be the popular choice, but there are still those that think Genia is the best option. Perhaps after such a long time, and after so much he has given to the Wallabies, it will take more than a couple of good performances to dislodge the Rebels scrum-half. This is what has been said: 

ADVERTISEMENT

https://twitter.com/AndrewBrogan/status/1161220319098494977?s=20

https://twitter.com/theow45/status/1161220701426241536?s=20

https://twitter.com/thaidaynightfb/status/1159272392557858816?s=20

In modern rugby, scrum-halves are substituted almost every game, meaning both White and Genia will be integral to the Wallabies’ chances of success in Japan in September. 

Although it is unknown who Cheika will favour, it is a good position to have such quality players vying for the same place. 

WATCH: Australia captain Michael Hooper speaks ahead of Bledisloe Two in Auckland

Video Spacer

Stream Nations Championship 2026 LIVE

Hemispheres collide in the new Nations Championship. Stream live, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV.

Watch on RPTV
Starts 4th July 2026 - USA only.
ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

P
Phantom 1 hour ago
Nations Championship: 'The data shows the north has finally caught up with the south'

Fact: the gap between the North and the South has narrowed considerably - that I get. However, determining that only selecting only Home grown players or playing in the home country is is the optimal strategy is a bit of a toss up and highly reliant on the economies of the home union. I do understand that England and to a lesser degree Ireland selects home based only. The top 14 is a massive threat to their domestic product. France would probably not be affected (the money is at home). Fiji, Argentina, Samoa, Italy and you could even argue Scotland have only benefitted from this. Their players either go overseas to learn at higher levels (Fiji, Samoa, Argentina) or players coming into their leagues to strengthen the home product and their National teams (Scotland, Italy, Japan).

South Africa used to limit its selection to the home based players, but the reality of a weak currency vs what players could earn oversees meant that you lost access to your best players at some stage of their careers, with very few exceptions. Kolbe left SA as he was considered too small for International Rugby (yes coaches/selectors view), but ironically in France he forced selectors to notice his endeavors and select him. He is only reaching 50 caps now despite being north of 30 - granted rotation and the odd injury also played a role, but for the most part it is having debuted or becoming a regular so late.



...

18 Go to comments
Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Copied to clipboard

Share Article close