Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
NZ NZ

Beattie: 'Genge obliterated Ireland's scrum. He bossed Tadhg Furlong'

Ellis Genge and Shaun Edwards (Photo By Brendan Moran/Sportsfile via Getty Images -Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)

To the neutral, ‘Le Crunch’ has always been the jewel in the Six Nations crown. A mighty collision of English power and French flair, Anglo efficiency and Gallic elan.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here in France, the anticipation for ‘Super Saturday’ is ratcheting up to levels I have never witnessed. The people are in thrall to rugby beyond anything seen in over a decade. The game is all anyone talks about when I drop my kids off at school, head to the supermarket, or chat to the postman as he pops round with the morning mail. The place has gone into a frenzy.

Little wonder when a Grand Slam – France’s first since 2010 – is on the line in Paris this Saturday night, and all that stands between Les Bleus and their cherished prize is an inconsistent England. What chance have Eddie Jones’ men, with their callow playmakers and fluctuating form, got in the bearpit of Le Stade?

Video Spacer

Freddie Burns and Ollie Lawrence join the podcast! | RugbyPass Offload | Episode 24

With Max unavailable this week, Freddie Burns steps into the breach to join Ryan and special guest Ollie Lawrence. Freddie gives us his take on Leicester’s strong start to the season and what makes him the ultimate stand-in superstar. Ollie talks us through his relationship with Eddie Jones and how his career could easily have taken a different turn. We get the guys’ best MLR impressions and Freddie asks the question every rugby player poses when watching football.

Video Spacer

Freddie Burns and Ollie Lawrence join the podcast! | RugbyPass Offload | Episode 24

With Max unavailable this week, Freddie Burns steps into the breach to join Ryan and special guest Ollie Lawrence. Freddie gives us his take on Leicester’s strong start to the season and what makes him the ultimate stand-in superstar. Ollie talks us through his relationship with Eddie Jones and how his career could easily have taken a different turn. We get the guys’ best MLR impressions and Freddie asks the question every rugby player poses when watching football.

Actually, not a terribly slim one. Combine the tremendous heart and wit of their 14-man heroics against Ireland with Wales’ canny strategy against France on Friday, and England have their blueprint for the role of party poopers.

Jones described England’s performance as a ‘foundation game’ for the World Cup. It is odd to talk of foundations six years into his reign, but that’s what the display was on the most simplistic level.

My highest Six Nations finish with Scotland was third, when Dean Ryan was part of our coaching staff. Dean used to say to us, ‘an Englishman is hitting you with a big stick, what are you going to do about it?’. He talked about winning Test matches in the most basic terms. That was through kick-chase, set-piece, tackles and collisions. England almost pulled off the unthinkable by bossing those areas.

They were galvanised by Charlie Ewels’ red card – and there is no doubt the lock’s high, late, head-to-head hit merited a sending off. We have not seen much of Ewels as an international starter, and he got his attempt to impose himself physically on another second-row badly wrong. The only thought anyone should have had in that moment was for the stricken James Ryan. It is not Ryan’s first head injury, and we can only hope it will not affect his career or, more importantly, his long-term health. The frequent grumbling on Twitter is that red cards destroy games, something needs to change, and paying punters deserve better. Where is the concern for the player’s wellbeing?

ADVERTISEMENT

For all that people moan about cards destroying the spectacle, what an audacious show of character those England players served up. When you lose a second-row, your line-out is heavily reshuffled, your scrum is hugely impacted, and you have to problem-solve on the hoof, which England failed badly to manage earlier this championship. Yet they dominated Ireland in those facets. Never mind the sheer exhaustion of spending almost an entire game a man down. To organise themselves under massive pressure and extreme fatigue on the biggest of stages was remarkable.

Every scrum victory was amplified, every disrupted maul celebrated by roars and spilled pints from a Twickenham crowd not traditionally renowned for febrility or raucous intent. Propelled by that backing, England were really close to pulling off one of the biggest results in the Six Nations era.

Player-camming three English forwards would tell the story of the game, and England’s refusal to let one action, one card, dictate the narrative. Ellis Genge, Maro Itoje and Jamie George were the visceral embodiment of English stubbornness.

Related

Genge obliterated Ireland’s scrum. He bossed Tadhg Furlong. There are a few moments you get as a rugby player where you completely own your opposite man and shift momentum in a match. Genge stepped forward with his chest pumped and had Furlong’s reverse lights flashing over and over, which almost never happens to the hulking ‘Mayor of Wexford’. Genge often has his character unfairly questioned, but here was the rugby player and the character combined in an awesome blend.

ADVERTISEMENT

Itoje was not so much a thorn in Ireland’s side as an entire rose bush. He wrecked their disallowed Caelan Doris try, and infiltrated their mauls with timing, power and presence. The volume and quality of work he got through was imperious.

George, like Genge, was key to the scrum efforts, but his collisions, industry and excitement set him apart. You could see how much he enjoyed that performance, latter describing it as one of his “proudest moments in an England shirt”.

You have to go to dark places when you are a man down, you have to dig deep and bring something out of yourself. It was one of those days for the English pack, with that trident at the forefront.

England must take the obstinance and determination and apply it to the game plan deployed by Wales, who have come closest to derailing the French juggernaut. Where they failed to capitalise on red-zone possession, England have the technical quality to succeed.

Eddie Jones Fabien Galthie
Head coach of England Eddie Jones looks on head coach of France Fabien Galthie (Photo by Jean Catuffe/Getty Images)

Neither team played especially well in Cardiff because there was so much non-rugby. Nobody was playing multi-phase stuff. It isn’t the entertaining game we want to see – it is a chess battle. It’s about how you can keep the ball away from your third, make no errors, be pragmatic, and then win cheap field position.

That’s what Wales did under Warren Gatland for years. Now France are doing it, and everyone is saying it’s so weird, so un-French, but it’s what almost every other team have done for a decade – France are just doing it better. It’s about building momentum and pressure. If you can’t build pressure, stick it up in the air, and if the opposition do get the ball back, it’s poor-quality ball.

That game broke the French TV audience record for a Test match. It was watched by an average of 6.9m people, with a peak figure of 8m for the final 10 minutes – the combined population of  Ireland and Wales. Imagine every single person in those two countries tuning in to a rugby match. That gives you an indication of how adored and admired this team is now.

The prize for France is that first slam in a dozen years, a monumental opportunity for them. But in some ways, it’s almost as big a game for England and their coach.

Related

What I find bizarre about the whole Jones complex is his constant focus on the World Cup. When you’re involved in any rugby environment, your immediate goal is to win the next game, not the global showpiece once every four years. England were fifth in last year’s Six Nations, and the best they can do this season is third. They should be first or second every year with the depth and resources at Jones’ disposal. It must infuriate fans to hear him talk of 2023 time and again, when there are tournaments in front of your nose you want your team to win.

Jonny Sexton, who spent two years with Racing 92 and knows a thing or two about Parisian glory, said England have a great chance this weekend, because “England are England, one of the most dominant teams in world rugby”. They certainly have a squad capable of winning every game in this competition, but a distant third? Jones will know that is not good enough.

Fabien Galthie
Fickou and Fabien Galthie are close and the France head coach is a big influence (Photo by ANNE-CHRISTINE POUJOULAT/ Getty Images)

Victory on Saturday, though, could change the complexion of an otherwise stuttering campaign. Jones will have one day fewer to prepare his team, and travel to consider, making a win even more impressive.

England might well have to beat France on their own turf next autumn if they are to lift the Webb Ellis Cup. The Six Nations title is gone for another year, but should they spoil a French party of this size and grandeur, thrive in the teeming cacophony of Stade de France, it could be a defining triumph for the players, Jones, and their quest for 2023 riches.

ADVERTISEMENT

Join free

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

5 Comments
J
J 853 days ago

The English pack did outmuscle the Irish, especially Itoje, who was his usual disruptive influence. However, your analysis of the scrum is inaccurate. It did play a significant role in helping the English stay in the game and exert pressure. However, it was not due to Genge dominating an opponent. Instead, it was the result of shrewd tactics by the English pack to wheel the scrum and the collective failure of the officials to govern effectively. The France game will still be incredible, and looking forward to a super game.

n
niall 853 days ago

Nigel Owens tweeted at least 3 of the penalties should’ve been reversed. Record loss for England and no tries again. All spin. You lost get over it, try and play rugby.

s
steve 853 days ago

I thought Ireland won that game? All I read and hear is how great this England player was. How brave England was.

l
lot 853 days ago

oh man, the hyperbole for a losing team is too embarrasing. they celebrated a scrum win more than a try and never looked like scoring a single try. The scrum, mann be unbiased for just a minute. we could all see, England scrummed illegally. your stars were playing all the tricks in the book, boring in, pulling out and running around. Poor ref, had to make up for the red card to maintain entertainment!!

P
Poe 854 days ago

Unless of course you go with the Analysis of a great big conning of the ref and scrum time. You tube it. Classic ref howler. Rassi was right.

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

B
B.J. Spratt 3 hours ago
All Blacks vs England takeaways: Richie Who? Time for Cortez

You Poms and Paddies are really nice guys. New Zealand V Ireland - 37 Tests - N.Z. 31 Wins - Ireland 5 Wins - 1 draw. New Zealand V England - 45 Tests - N.Z. 35 Wins -England 8 Wins - 2 draws. Combined - You have beaten the All Blacks 13 Times in 82 attempts over 119 years. The Stats over 100 years + would say, especially England with 6 Times the player pool than New Zealand, you have “a limitation of context” regarding developing your coaches to teach your players how to WIN. So how can England with a 6 times the player numbers have a 17% winning strike rate against New Zealand? and be 8 -0 in Test Series over 100 years. The answer is simple. Your perception of the game. How do you fix it? You need to play in New Zealand for a couple of seasons in your teens, 18 -20 or send coaches over here. Martin Johnstone played 2 seasons here under the mentorship of Colin Meads. When he came here he had rugby shorts with pockets and a handkerchief in one pocket. He played for NZ Under 21 against Wallaby John Eales. He became the toughest player in the game and the best ever English Captain and Captained the Lions twice. Legend! Maybe if he hadn’t come to New Zealand, he may still had those rugby shorts with pockets. Recently Rogan O’Gara spent time at the Crusaders. What a great coach. “Our “mindset is different” and that’s how we have beaten you for 100 years + How the hell he isn’t Coaching Ireland, France, England, Wales, or Scotland I will never know? England has 131,000 Senior rugby Players. Ireland has 21,000 Senior Players. New Zealand has 27,000 Senior Players.

42 Go to comments
TRENDING
TRENDING What Rassie Erasmus said on refereeing in Springboks loss to Ireland What Rassie Erasmus said on refereeing in Springboks loss to Ireland
Search