World Rugby has been accused of mixed messages after reportedly fining England for its counter to New Zealand’s haka three days after trumpeting it as “incredible” on its official YouTube channel.
Before their stunning 19-7 win in Yokohama last Saturday that ended the All Blacks’ eight-year reign as world champions, England lined up in a V formation to counter New Zealand’s traditional Maori challenge.
A clip posted by World Rugby captioned “England’s incredible response to intense New Zealand haka” has been viewed almost 4 million times, putting the governing body in an awkward spot after it reprimanded the semi-final winner and delivered a “four-figure sum”.
Continue reading below…
The Guardian is reporting that England have been fined ‘a four-figure sum’, however it is less than the fine handed down to France for similar tactics ahead of the 2011 final. On that occasion, the French were fined $4,300.
The Guardian‘s report was met with fury in some corners.
England fined a four figure sum for their V-shaped formation facing the Haka. World Rugby is a joke organisation that isn't fit for purpose.
— Neil Fissler (@neilfissler) October 29, 2019
'But it's important to New Zealand's culture'
Great, let them keep doing it.
But why should the opposition have to stand there getting cold when most fans would probably like to see challenge answered?
Opposition response gets talked about for generations not Haka itself.
— Sam Street (@samstreetwrites) October 29, 2019
Others took an opposite view. “I love the Haka. I loved England’s response, equally. All teams are told not to cross the halfway line when responding. England were fined for crossing the halfway line. Simple as that,” wrote Rugby World Magazine‘s Paul Williams.
England lined up in front of the traditional challenge in V formation and had to be told to retreat by officials when they moved too close to the All Blacks.
Mako Vunipola admitted that “we knew it would rile them up” while the captain, Owen Farrell, who could be seen smirking during the haka, said: “We wanted not to just stand there and let them come at us.”
England breached a “cultural ritual protocol”.
Sign up to our mailing list here and we’ll keep you up to the minute with weekly updates from the world of rugby.