Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Springbok starters respond to disrespect jibes ahead of Wallabies

By Josh Raisey
Marco van Staden of South Africa during the South Africa men's national rugby team training session at Stade Omnisports des Fauvettes on September 19, 2023 in Domont, France. (Photo by Steve Haag/Gallo Images/Getty Images)

Rassie Erasmus’ decision to make ten changes to his starting South Africa side to play Australia on Saturday is not a decision that has been universally well-received.

ADVERTISEMENT

The relatively experienced XV that beat the Wallabies 33-7 in Brisbane in round one of the Rugby Championship has largely been replaced by an XV possessing four players with a solitary cap and a further four with under ten for the round two rematch in Perth.

In response to the team naming, there have been accusations of disrespect in some quarters.

It is easy to see why Erasmus has made this decision- the Springboks are not only in the midst of a long international campaign, but the head coach always has one eye on 2027 and blooding in the next generation.

But for two of the more senior starters in the Bok’s starting line-up, flanker Marco van Staden and centre Lukhanyo Am, this drop in experience has in no way brought a drop in motivation.

Fixture
Rugby Championship
Australia
12 - 30
Full-time
South Africa
All Stats and Data

“I wouldn’t say it’s a disruption,” the Bulls flanker said regarding the changes that have been made to the squad.

“I don’t think this team needs any more motivation than we currently have for this match.

“All of us want to use this opportunity, and we took a lot of confidence from training this week. The intensity was really up there, and we want to take that energy into the game.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Though there are five players in the pack alone with under ten caps, four of them play alongside van Staden for the United Rugby Championship runners-up the Bulls.

This unity from playing week-in, week-out together in Pretoria has given the pack “confidence”, he believes.

“Many of us have played together quite often at the Bulls, which certainly gives us confidence,” he added. “We’ve been working together well at training (in the Bok camp too), so we are excited about this opportunity.”

Am also stressed that though the starters may not have many caps to their names, the players have plenty of experience at franchise level.

ADVERTISEMENT

“We are experienced at franchise level,” he said. “Although some of the players don’t have many Test caps. We have quality leaders in this group, and the fact that some of them have only played a few Tests doesn’t mean they are less experienced leaders.”

Related

The Women's Rugby World Cup 2025 is coming to England. Register now here to be the first to hear about tickets.

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

14 Comments
S
STBUR 34 days ago

Media created offense. I doubt any Aus player or coach is fretting over this.


But I agree, WR should act immediately. Rotation is against the spirit of the game.

H
Hellhound 35 days ago

It may not be what most of us wanted, but Rassie did it again. Surprised us all. The Wallabies will come out hard this weekend. Now with such a changed team, they will think they can do it. I hope Rassie made the changes due to a plan he have rather than being overconfident. Still, this team have 14 world cup winners, so it's not disrespect. A very good team actually, and young by comparison to the other team. The Boks should still win, but I hope the Wallabies make a fight of it. There was no physicality from them last week. I hope they front up hard. I always want the Boks to win, but I like close matches much better.

B
BlouBul 35 days ago

Please don't go back to the 1 point win!

J
JK 35 days ago

want more respect? play better

B
Bull Shark 35 days ago

Would like to know who feels disrespected. I want names.

D
DP 35 days ago

There’s a good chance World Rugby is going to put a stop to this rotation circus, it’s completely against the spirit of the game.

B
BlouBul 35 days ago

Since when!

N
Ninjin 35 days ago

Winning seems also to be against the spirit of the game. World Rugby must act!

G
GrahamVF 35 days ago

Aren’t you the one who is going on about player welfare? What do you think rotations is aimed at? I’ll let you into a secret - it’s to prevent built up fatigue which is the leading cause of injuries.

C
CC 35 days ago

Hulls weet nie, wat ons weet nie

F
Flankly 35 days ago

Suggestions of disrespect are stupid. Modern teams need to rotate, and naturally they rotate the less experienced players into the games in which they are big favorites. Right now SA odds are about 1/3 to win TRC, whereas Australia's are 100/1. Those odds are to harsh on Australia and to flattering to SA, in my view. Nonetheless it would be professionally negligent for Rassie not to bring in some of the brilliant youngsters to get some game time.


And of course the coaches and senior players are not going to say that this is a substantially weakened team.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

B
Bull Shark 44 minutes ago
Why Rassie Erasmus should cull some Boks veterans for 2027

I think cull is the wrong word.


I think Rassie and the senior players will be pretty open and honest with each other about their prospects for another World Cup campaign. And, ironically, I don’t think Rassie is thinking as far ahead as 2027 in terms of who is going to go.


There are likely going to be injuries too where players one would assume will be at 2027 won’t feature. Think Marx and Am and 2023.


I think the priority is really having as many players as possible in contention for a spot on the 33 by the time squad selection comes around.


I made this point a while ago, but having double World Cup winners in the setup over the next 3 years is going to be golden for the boks. It’s like having a coach in each position.


Razor was criticized for having too many coaches in his team. Rassie has more than 15 player coaches at his disposal.


I think Siya is being teed up to play the same role Duane did at the 2023 RWC. Invitation to the coaching box this coming weekend included.


I think many of the old guard are playing a role in the team that certainly does not guarantee them a 2027 place but doesn’t hurt their chances at being selected - but they will have to be the no.1 or no. 2 best in that position to be selected at that time. There won’t be any dead weight - whether old or young.


In my mind the strategy would be quite simple. Take everyone who will be over 32 by 2027 and pencil their names in right now in slot number three for their relative position. We know what they can do and they know what they need to do to be in contention for 2027.


Then ask yourself who do we have to take position no.1 and no. 2. Tried and tested or not. Find them and trial them over the next 3 years. Their job is to keep the old guys out. And the old guys job is to help them do just that.


That’s what Rassie has to do and has started well trying 48 players and 11 debutants in year one as the article mentioned (and winning).


I reckon there’ll be another 5-10 new players tried by the end of this year, particularly in November.


2024 ✅

1 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Inside the mind of Franco Smith: The 'school head boy' who scaled the URC's Everest Inside the mind of Franco Smith: The 'school head boy' who scaled the URC's Everest
Search