Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

'That's a piledriver' - Yellow for ugly incident at ruck branded lenient

By Ian Cameron
Piledriver

A yellow card for Connacht’s Paul Boyle for what has been described by one ex-pro as a ‘piledriver’ has been labelled lenient by many on social media.

ADVERTISEMENT

Connacht bagged an impressive 36-14 victory over the injury-hit Scarlets at the Sportsground and despite arguably not affecting the result, many weren’t impressed by referee Marius van der Westhuizen’s decision regarding the incident in the 48th minute.

Connacht No.8 Boyle upended Tom Price at a ruck and the incident went to Marius Jonker’s TMO van for review. Van der Westhuizen instructed Jonker as follows: “A player is clearly lifted above horizontal. He’s very close to the ground. He does end up on his head, but because he’s so close to the ground I’m only thinking yellow card. Have you got any other facts to add to that?”

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

Jonker replied that: “I’ve got no other facts to add to that.”

When challenged by Scarlets skipper Jonathan Davies he was told: “It’s not a debate. He’s very low to the ground, so it’s not a high level of danger. It’s a yellow card.”

Former Wales back row turned pundit Gareth Delve told Scrum V: “That’s a piledriver on Tom Price. This could be red-card territory in my view.

“You are talking about a high-level of danger, he’s dropped him straight on top of his head.”

Co-pundit James Hook was equally unimpressed: “I know he wasn’t that far from the ground but you just watch here. He’s lifted him upside down, he’s dropped him on his head like The Undertaker, and regardless how far away from the ground he is, I think that’s dangerous and that’s a red in my opinion.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Many Welsh rugby accounts on Twitter were fuming and directed their anger at overall standard of refereeing in the league, a stick critics have repeatedly used against the URC and its previous iterations.

Welsh rugby journalist Iestyn Rhys Thomas observed: “That’s a red card for me, are we ever going to get the correct decisions in this league?”

Cardiff Rugby Life wrote: “Connacht with a try that wasn’t grounded and a yellow card for a clear red card offence. URC Referees Manager thinks his referees are performing at an 8/10 remember.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Another account wrote: “I know the URC is a joke, but the fact that isn’t a red is the ultimate.”

Related

ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

N
Nickers 2 hours ago
The changes Scott Robertson must make to address All Blacks’ bench woes

Hopefully Robertson and co aren't applying this type of thinking to their selections, although some of their moves this year have suggested that might be the case.


The first half of Foster's tenure, when he was surrounded by coaches who were not up to the task, was disastrous due to this type of reactionary chopping and changing. No clear plan of the direction of travel or what needs to be built to get there. Just constant tinkering. A player gets dropped one week, on the bench the next, back to starting the next, dropped for the next week again. Add in injuries and other variations of this selection pattern, combined with vastly different game plans from one week to the next and it's no wonder the team isn't clicking on attack and are making incredibly basic errors on both sides of the ball.


When Schmidt and Ryan got involved selections became far more consistent and the game plan far simpler and the dividends were instant, and they accepted bad performances as part of building towards the world cup. They were able to distinguish between bad plans and bad execution and by the time the finals rolled around they were playing their best rugby as a team.


Chopping and changing the team each week sends the signal that you don't really know what you are doing or why, and you are just reacting to what happened last week, selecting a team to replay the previous game rather than preparing for the next one and building for the future.

12 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ 'Turnaround Tyrel' epitomises the foggy state of the Bledisloe Cup 'Turnaround Tyrel' epitomises the foggy state of the Bledisloe Cup
Search