Pacific Islands profit share idea proves popular on social media
The Pacific Rugby Players Welfare organisation’s idea of a profit share system with tier one nations has received almost universal backing on social media.
PRPW director Dan Leo has shared a letter sent to the unions of England, Ireland, Wales, Scotland and France in which he suggested a “revitalised profit-share model” whereby a 10 per cent share of the profit generated by tier one nations hosting tier two nations is shared.
Currently, the home side keeps 100 per cent of the profits, but it is said on the PRPW website that “just 10 per cent of the profits from a sell-out England match at Twickenham could help a Pacific Islands nation run their international set-up for three years”.
Leo also wrote of the pressures that the Pacific Islands nations are under such as “player drain, the lack of any viable professional pathway, the reliance on government funding, and issues of depression/suicide resulting from players having to leave home”.
The former Samoan international said that these issues would be alleviated with more funding, as well as strengthening the teams and increasing competition in the international game.
READ| Pacific Rugby Players Welfare has called on some of the game's Richest unions, to agree a profit-sharing deal to boost the Pacific Island nation’s international programmeshttps://t.co/1kMbR89GbL
— PacificRugbyWelfare (@pacificwelfare) August 21, 2019
Amidst all the gloom surrounding state of Pacific rugby of late, this is a positive solution and perhaps light at the end of the tunnel for the sustainability of the sport in our region
Come on rugby family, we need everyone to get behind this! #Profit_Share @SixNationsRugby https://t.co/519O7VKVAU
— Daniel Leo (@danleo82) August 21, 2019
It's about time that some good news is potentially on the horizon towards better funding the Pacific Islands Test-playing countries https://t.co/Ahh5MuLHm5
— RugbyPass (@RugbyPass) August 21, 2019
Leo’s idea has been widely supported by many people on Twitter, who equally feel that the wealthier nations should be doing more to help those that are struggling. Of course, it is hard to know the intricacies of such a proposal, but in theory, this is something that fans from all over the world seem to support.
Only this past autumn, Fiji faced Scotland and France, historically beating the French, and Tonga faced Wales. The Scotland versus Fiji game at Murrayfield was a sell-out and any share of that has been shown to be hugely beneficial to tier two nations.
The player drain and financial troubles of the Pacific Islands nations has been an issue for many years, and the vast majority of the rugby world would want to see those teams helped to play to their potential.
That is why an idea like this is proving to be so popular already for many. This is what has been said:
It would be incredibly selfish of the 6N teams not to agree to this. Never do it for NZ, but definitely for the pacific island teams. https://t.co/7m361clqhH
— Dave Owen (@hobbittfeet) August 21, 2019
This is such a good idea – and it’s only 10% they are asking for. Even if more Tier 1 countries (hate that term!) play in the Pacific Islands, sell out crowds wouldn’t bring in this kind of money. If Unions are serious about expanding the sport, this is a golden opportunity! https://t.co/BcHH0hhiRG
— Nicks Johnston (@nicksjj) August 21, 2019
This is a fantastic initiative & I would urge the Unions of Eng, Wal, Scot and Fra to agree to what PRW are proposing.
Pacific Islands need support, & simply cannot generate necessary revenue. This would be huge help – provided guarantees of proper financial management in place. https://t.co/2mUCv72q1w
— Rugby and the Law (@rugbyandthelaw) August 21, 2019
Nice! https://t.co/coGU3303bQ
— Nkululeko Eutai Mnikathi (@Nkuli_MniCarthy) August 21, 2019
https://twitter.com/OlaLola81/status/1164176774491725824?s=20
It shouldn't be necessary to ask. The greedy unions should recognise that they benefit from the PI nations being strong https://t.co/88Gw3XkjEm
— Wrighty (@neilwrightlegal) August 21, 2019
Open letter to the rugby unions of England, Ireland, Wales, Scotland, & France. Ref the Pacific rugby players welfare, CMON DO THE RIGHT THING.
— John Jephcott (@JJ43_Wasps) August 21, 2019
Really hope they do something about this. The Home Nations could share 10% of the wealth https://t.co/l4dGSpcl5n
— Rob Rich (@robrich247) August 21, 2019
https://twitter.com/TheStroBro/status/1164202129751343104?s=20
The RFU donated £75,000 to Samoa after the Test at Twickenham in 2017 as the players shared their match fees, and this is one of the goodwill donations that Leo wrote of in his letter. He said they made a “huge difference for the receiving unions” and it is understandable why an official and a more consistent system like that should be set up.
Already this year, tier two nations have been able to fend off the threat of the proposed Nations League which they felt would be hugely detrimental to the Pacific Islands teams and now this proposal is about taking a positive step.
In order for the game to grow, those nations that may be struggling financially cannot be ignored and this could be a step in the right direction.
WATCH: Nadolo, the RugbyPass documentary exploring the life and times of Fijian great Nemani Nadolo
Comments on RugbyPass
Goodness. When are the All Blacks and New Zealand commentators going to stop complaining about how they could have won and just try to win next time 😂. In South Africa if you lose you get up and try again. Get over it.
75 Go to commentsHonestly, it doesn’t matter a whole lot. RSA has a ton of experienced talent in its leadership group. I am more interested in who is the new 8 man/8 men and the younger props. The captain may change but the system does not
1 Go to comments“See you in the final” can mean whatever you want it to mean. To me it means that 12 Irish rugby players are a bunch of poeses. See y’all in Pretoria.
124 Go to commentsBen, you are one of the most arrogant and self opionated rugby critics I have ever come across (next to Keohane). I hoped that after SA beating the best ranked teams in the world on their way to the WC (something not done before) that you might have the grace to admit that this is a special team that deserved the accolades coming their way. You have no humility and as has been been already pointed out, merely a troll to attract audience numbers. Count me out in the future.
75 Go to comments‘War of independence’. Such a grand name for a few skirmishes. Where were all the great battles of this ‘war’ ? Smith got goosebumps as he was being emotionally manipulated, another mushroom.
1 Go to commentsFor all those disputing the veracity of Etzebeth’s very public recollections of the Irish players’ comments, I have one question: should we be holding our collective breath in anticipation of a barrage of strenuous denials from the Irish squad? Then again, perhaps not…
124 Go to comments> If the game of rugby is to grow globally, then the rugby Sth Africa play needs to be exterminated. Their performances at World Cup ‘19 & ‘23 were the antithesis to what the game should be. If the World Cup final is the grand spectacle of the game, please no more having to endure the drudgery and insipid ‘style ‘ of play harking back to pre WWII days, where the soulless rugby of the Bok reflected the mindset of a nation. > Gotta agree with Ben Smith, “ the Springboks took the trophy by default, with what might be the most unimpressive escape of all time “.
75 Go to commentsI think Rassie should bring in some new guys and give them a go in these irrelevant games. It’s a chance to blood some guys that might otherwise not get a chance and see if they’re up to it. As for the who’s number 1 dispute? Don’t care. As long as the trophies are brought home, that argument isn’t important. Champions don’t fuss about the could’ve, would’ve, should’ve. They just do, and that for me makes SA and NZ the top dogs. Followed by Ireland and occasionally England.
225 Go to commentsThis is like the “catches win matches" saying in cricket. If ABs were pragmatic and kicked for goal instead of hunting tries, I reckon they win that game with ease. Instead, nearly 6 months later; we have World Rugby's official mouthpiece celebrating their Almost Won the Rugby World Cup trophy. Fine Victory Gentleman! Well-earned!!
75 Go to comments“…the All Blacks nearly won…” is the only phrase you need to concern yourself with relative to this “journalistic” piece. Enjoy your Almost Won the World Cup victory…
75 Go to commentsAw common. Stop winging. There were no errors by officials. It is all recorded. Whose fault was the Cane red card? Or the Savea knock? Maybe the selectors who insisted on making a very average player their captain should be blamed. Something had to give way.
75 Go to commentsThe latest ‘Ireland are arrogant’ attack from one of the two most arrogant rugby nations on earth.
124 Go to commentsWaawaawaaaaaaaa
23 Go to commentsHow does this guy still have a job?
75 Go to commentsSorry bok you can't beat facts, we heard you all crowing how great you thought you were..lol ! We all watched the game, cheatsabeth cheating cost abs a try, only a penalty considering it was cynical and a professional foul, doesn't matter who wrote this because thats how it happened, but you go enjoy your gifting of the cup,
75 Go to commentsCan we talk about the context of how this particular journalist continues to make a living and gets published? Controversy for clicks. Shame on all of us for engaging with these irrelevant opinions.
75 Go to commentsAn astounding article !
75 Go to commentsFrance didn’t lose against New Zeland in 2011, but against Joubert…
75 Go to commentsHahahaha knew the “journalist” just by seeing the headline. Not wasting my time reading it as I know it's just another toxic manifestation of the boks living rent free in this babies head.
75 Go to commentsWhen you read those facts, you can say safely that the game was handed to the Springboks by the ruling mistakes made by the Referee and TMO. Perhaps that is why South Africans were/are so “noisey” about the win….this behaviour perhaps concealing that they realise luck played a big part in the result. Certainly not a good look for the IRB going forward…pretty shoddy sadly.
75 Go to comments