Northern Edition

Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

LONG READ From an uncertain position, Barrett and McKenzie are the All Blacks' key playmakers

From an uncertain position, Barrett and McKenzie are the All Blacks' key playmakers
1 month ago

It’s apparent two men in particular are determined to make a dramatic impact in Super Rugby Pacific and the competition’s narrative may well be shaped entirely around them.

This is going to be the year of Beauden Barrett and Damian McKenzie, as both men have been seemingly rejuvenated and energised by the news their former All Black colleague, Richie Mo’unga will not be coming back to New Zealand from Japan until 2026 at the earliest.

There’s no animosity between the trio; no personal gripes or hidden tensions beyond the usual friction that arises when three highly driven athletes are all striving for the same thing within the same team.

All Blacks coach Scott Robertson has made little secret of his desire to see Richie Mo’unga return to New Zealand (Photo by Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

But last year was tough for Barrett and McKenzie. Most of it was spent in the shadow of Mo’unga, despite the fact the former Crusaders 10 was playing for Toshiba Brave Lupus and supposedly no longer competing for a place in the All Blacks team.

Mo’unga had signed a three-year deal with Toshiba at the end of 2022 and had made it clear at the time of doing so, he felt he’d done all he had wanted in Test rugby. He knew he’d bring up his 50th appearance at the World Cup, which would be the second he’d played at, and that was going to be his lot.

He did all this knowing, or at least strongly suspecting, his long-time Crusaders mentor Scott Robertson was going to take over as All Blacks coach.

Razor coming along and saying he’d love to have me back home, it’s just given me another opportunity to think about where I’m at with my footy.

He was sure he was done, but by July last year, he was reconsidering. Robertson had checked in with Mo’unga in March, with the coach selling his vision of how he wanted the All Blacks to play on his watch.

Robertson making a play, or planting a seed at least, to try to persuade the 29-year-old to come home early and extend his Test career, was entirely reasonable. All Blacks coaches have always kept in touch with overseas-based players they’d be keen to see return.

A problem arose, however, when New Zealand Rugby’s general manager of professional rugby, Chris Lendrum, made the situation public by telling the Rugby Direct podcast: “We would love Richie home as soon as we can. There are contracts. We respect those. He’s employed by Toshiba currently, but we’ll be involved in conversations to see what’s possible.”

Once the story was out – NZR wanted to extract Mo’unga from his Toshiba contract early – it became impossible to ignore.

Beauden Barrett
Beauden Barrett had an impressive 2024 for the All Blacks (Photo Timothy Rogers/Getty Images)

When Mo’unga was home in Christchurch ahead of the All Blacks series against England, he spoke to local media and explained he was indeed thinking about an earlier than expected return.

“I signed for three years with Toshiba and my intentions were, ‘Yep, I’m going do the three years’,” he said.

“[But] obviously with Razor coming along and saying he’d love to have me back home, it’s just given me another opportunity to think about where I’m at with my footy.”

The big problem with this playing out so publicly, was it left Barrett and McKenzie feeling like they were in interim roles – place-holders in the 10 jersey until the deal was done to get Mo’unga home.

From being uncertain they were wanted, McKenzie and Barrett are now the two playmakers shaping up as integral to Robertson’s All Blacks.

It didn’t help in the week before the All Blacks played the Wallabies in Sydney, Robertson told media he had gone surfing with former NRL legend Andrew Johns. No-one asked Robertson what they had talked about, but he volunteered the answer anyway: “He knows all the pivots, you know ‘When are you getting Richie back?’, geez, it’s gone global. It was entertaining.”

It was an extraordinary scenario where the All Blacks had two incredible talents in McKenzie and Barrett feeling uncertain about their longer-term futures.

Barrett is contracted through to 2027 but he has the right, given his long service, to leave whenever he wants and McKenzie is only locked in until the end of this year. It was rumoured, not without strong cause, both would leave New Zealand at the end of this year if it was confirmed Mo’unga was coming home for good in July.

But it has been reported Mo’unga is staying put, and will see out all three years of his Toshiba contract, meaning the earliest he would be available for the All Blacks is July 2026 – and even then there is no guarantee he will want to come home.

From being uncertain they were wanted, McKenzie and Barrett are now the two playmakers shaping up as integral to Robertson’s All Blacks. These are his guys – the two Robertson has to trust and build his team around. The shadow of Mo’unga has lifted and Barrett and McKenzie appear to know that. They have an opportunity to spearhead their respective teams into a repeat of last year’s final and lay down irrefutable cases they are in possession of the game management skills the All Blacks need.

Damian McKenzie All Blacks
Damian McKenzie started last year as Scott Robertson’s first-choice fly-half (Photo by Bob Bradford – CameraSport via Getty Images)

Barrett, having missed Super Rugby last year to play for Toyota Verblitz, has been unusually vocal in pre-season, suggesting he has been invigorated by the news out of Japan. He spoke to reporters in Auckland last week, making it clear he is committed to helping the champion Blues grow their game and retain the title.

The Blues ended a 21-year drought in 2024, winning their fourth Super Rugby championship with a gameplan that was direct, narrow and powerful.

“It’s been a fairly blunt strategy that’s worked, but there’s no doubt we’ll look to adapt a little bit,” Barrett said. “We can’t assume that will work again. We’ll have to improvise and not be complacent.”

It was the fact he was willing to delve into matters he would normally have steered well clear of, that suggested he is going to embrace his new position as elder statesman and All Blacks chief playmaker.

If we don’t have momentum, how do we get momentum back? It was the part of my game which definitely needed to show the most improvement.

He offered the media opinions about New Zealand’s eligibility policy – saying it should be held where it is – and suggested Japan should be brought into Super Rugby in some capacity. He also, at the launch of Super Rugby in Sydney, talked up the Australian threat.

“Obviously with the Rebels not being part of the competition, each team’s strengthened by players spreading out,” he said.

“The change we saw with the Wallabies under Joe Schmidt, I think you’ll also certainly see a step up at Super level with the movement, his trajectory with where they’re going.”

This is un-Barrett like, to be so forthcoming on topics he would usually suggest are outside of his lane.

McKenzie, too, has been open about what he didn’t get right last year when he was entrusted with the All Blacks 10 jersey for the first eight Tests of the year.

“There’s a lot of stuff in Test rugby that’s a lot different to Super Rugby,” he said. “It’s recognising the flow of the game, really.

“If we don’t have momentum, how do we get momentum back? Whether it’s through kicking, running, going more to our set-piece… making sure we’re putting the ball in front of the forwards, making their job easier.

“It was the part of my game which definitely needed to show the most improvement.”

What’s amplified the importance of Barrett and McKenzie in this year’s Super Rugby, is not only the knowledge Mo’unga is staying put, but Harry Plummer, who was so steady and influential for the Blues last year and won his first cap as a result, is off to France in the coming months.

Fergus Burke, who was the heir apparent to Mo’unga at the Crusaders, has already left for Saracens and Brett Cameron, who was seen as one of the other leading lights to emerge, is set to miss most of the campaign with injury.

New Zealand is decidedly low on quality 10s and Barrett and McKenzie know it.

Comments

35 Comments
J
JW 36 days ago

The big problem with this playing out so publicly, was it left Barrett and McKenzie feeling like they were in interim roles – place-holders in the 10 jersey until the deal was done to get Mo’unga home.

The whole reason this situation exists is because Mo’unga wasn’t good enough to earn a sabbatical. Both Beauden and Dmac are that status, the only ones dismayed by events were Rugby Pass authors who got everything wrong all season.

S
Spew_81 36 days ago

I think that the NZRU would’ve offered him a one year sabbatical. If they didn’t it would’ve been weird as he was the starter since 2022 and played well at RWC 2023. Also, as was his Super Rugby coach, (who got the best out of him, was going to be the All Blacks coach.


I think part of the reason that Mo’unga left was that he was a bit bitter that he got handed the ‘too hard basket’ in 2019 and in 2022. Foster basically dropped Mo’unga when he went on maternity leave and replaced him with B Barrett; who the then dropped and Mo’unga stepped up and won the second test in South Africa.


Also, maybe he doesn’t think the All Blacks are good enough to win in 2027; or that they won’t be good enough to be favorites, so he may as well make an extra 3 million?


To think Barfoot and Thompson wasted about a million on Roger Tuivasa-Sheck. They would’ve done better to put that money in Mo’unga, move him to the Blues. Put B Barrett at 15, then drop Perofeta to make room for M'o’unga at the Blues. When Barfoot sold his house I though he had seen sense and was trying just that, wishful thinking :)

S
SC 36 days ago

Neither Barrett nor McKenzie have the tactical kicking game nor the game management skills to consistently dominate territory and possession in test matches against top 5 nations.


They both will make highlight reel plays followed by brain farts. And they are ten year test veterans now in their 30s, not 22 year old test rookies. Neither Barrett nor McKenzie is going to improve or change.

I
IS 34 days ago

Dmac has the best kicking game in the world he has the best kick retain dtat out of any other player meaning he retains more of his kicks than anyone else meaning his tactical kicking game is better so what you talking about

J
JW 36 days ago

You have to pick the best you’ve got though, you can’t magical sign Dan Carter back up and expect him to succeed.


DMac has been the best tactical kicker for three years running and could make do at International level if that’s what the coach wanted.


Neither Mo’unga or Barrett were anything more than passable at game management, other than if you factor in their running ability. Which I would personally do, I’d give them huge bonus points for being able to break up a tight game like they did in the RWC Final. Would they have won that easily with a much better tactical kicker like McKenzie though?

S
Spew_81 36 days ago

I think, in part, it goes back to Hansen and Foster. They clearly had a preference for game breaking players, not technically proficient grafters.


Too many of the loose forwards became big midfielders e.g. A Ioane (as high as A Ioane’s potential was, Tom Robinson was a better option for a tight test). B Barrett and McKenzie, while wildly talented, are not test - knock out game - 10s.


This led to young players and their coaches getting a distorted view as to what types of skills they needed to develop. This will take time to rectify.


But it’s not to say that Robertson has it all correct either. Continuing with a solid, but not explosive 12 and a 13 that doesn’t break the line or pass isn’t doing the backline any good. The Nonu/Smith combination is what they should use as the default setting; power and skill combined. What’s the point of having an electric back three if they don’t get the ball? J Barrett has all the skills a 13 needs. If he was moved to 13, paired with an explosive 12 it would make a difference.

d
d 37 days ago

Both of these players are more natural fullbacks than #10, and I’m not sure either has the wide-angle vision to be another Carter. Still, neither does Mo’Unga. Where all our players are lacking is in tactical kicking skills, and that is because (although NZ Rugby can’t see it) Super Rugby is a mile from test rugby, which is why our players struggled to adjust for last year’s tours. The huge question is: does Razor have enough nous to correct those weaknesses?

I
IS 34 days ago

What you on about Sr is closer to test rugby than any other comp in the world also dmac is the best tactical kicker in the world stats prove that before making comments maybe you should look at stats and watch the games

J
JW 36 days ago

Struggle? What tests were you watching?


Razor did introduce a weird aspect where things quickly feel apart to the poin.t they could finish well. People are demanding that SR be the best for of rugby available, it’s slow progress but you think these two are aligned?


Funny because Razors Crusaders were considered the most conservative and physically dominant team for a long time. Brumbies before that.

T
Tom 37 days ago

SR needs the SA teams back. The SA teams bring a different dimension to the tournament and will better prepare the Kiwi and Aussie players for tests against NH and the Boks.

I
Icefarrow 37 days ago

NZR has never once claimed Super Rugby is anywhere close to the level of test footy, and our players’ failure to adapt was due to Robertson’s change in coaching, not the domestic scene.

H
Head high tackle 37 days ago

Razor is a bit too loose to be a test coach. I think he fails to put a short term group together. Coaching the same guys for 8 mths a year is very different to 2 weeks here and there. Mounga has never claimed he wants to break his contract so this is all down to Razor’s ego. If I was BB or DM Id be looking at Japan as soon as possible.

f
fl 37 days ago

doesn’t he have the ABs pretty much continuously from July to November?

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
Search