Northern | US

Why 39-year-old flanker Deon Fourie was picked over Bongi Mbonambi

Bongi Mbonambi in training - PA
Comments
24 Comments

The Springboks called upon Stormers flanker Deon Fourie for the second Test in Cape Town, with the 39-year-old set to make his first appearance for South Africa since the 2023 Rugby World Cup.

ADVERTISEMENT

Despite playing for the Stormers against the All Blacks as a flanker, Fourie has been picked as hooker cover in the No.16 jersey for the second Test, a role he filled as an emergency stopgap option during the 2023 Rugby World Cup after they lost Malcolm Marx to injury.

The decision to call on a part-time hooker has raised questions about the whereabouts of Bongi Mbonambi, South Africa’s 80-Test hooker who is four years younger than Fourie.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

Erasmus explained that he has been keeping tabs on Mbonambi but the hooker is not medically cleared to play. He has been sidelined with back and knee problems since missing the back half of the 2025/2026 season with the Sharks.

“At this stage we just feel for this specific game we need a guy like Deon there, but obviously in the long run, you know, Bongi (Mbonambi) is really close to returning again,” he said.

“Bongi has to play some proper matches now and get it under his belt before we can again look at him.

“Bongi had a knee and then it’s a lower back thing. So, he keeps us up to date and he WhatsApps every now and then to say how he’s doing, but obviously the Sharks medical team must clear him first.

ADVERTISEMENT

Despite keeping direct contact with the Sharks hooker, Erasmus revealed “he doesn’t know” the extent of the injuries as the timelines keep changing.

“I’m not 100 per cent sure which of the two injuries is keeping him out right now, but as I say, we can’t pull him in here and let him play a first match again, a Test match, so we we’ll have to get him in and see him playing maybe a few Currie Cup games and then maybe we can consider him again,” he said.

“I haven’t spoken to JP (Pietersen). I’ve only spoken to Bongi, and I honestly don’t know. About three weeks ago I thought he was a week away, but since then I can’t tell you. JP would know that.”

Erasmus was very happy to see Fourie back in the Springboks who offers value not just on the pitch but in preparations too.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I know him very well, and I coached him for many years. He played flanker for us and then moved into hooker and, as I said yesterday to the guys, the guy is a gymnast, the guy’s a wrestler, and I guess very few people, some at 35, 36 and others at 39 still make it.

“It’s unbelievable, and we feel it’s something not just in his game. It’s also him as a person and how he helps us make decisions and plans and so on. On and off the field, he is very valuable.”

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

24 Comments
H
Hammer Head 43 days ago

These two teams have had each others number consistently. They are number 1 and 2 respectively.


Not number 1 or garbage.

B
B 44 days ago

There had been a few signs over the last while that the evergreen Bongi was past his best. Some bad injuries and the ticking down of his current contract.


But replacing him with a…39 year old?

A
Ayre123 None 44 days ago

Someone should tell Ben Smith that Bong was proclaimed a damaged good since last year😢

u
unknown 45 days ago

One loss and panicans come out of every hole like rats off a sinking ship. It’s an effing game, NO ONE can win them all. 22 times in the 22 with one try? Don’t expect a repeat.

f
fl 44 days ago

The scoreline is what matters though. Great teams will find a way to win, and SA didn’t.


There are things that SA can fix this week, but there are also things that NZ can fix. The game on saturday won’t be a repeat of last week, but that doesn’t mean SA will necesarily turn things around.


You are right that its just one game though. At this point the series could go either way, and if SA win the next 3 games then they’ll have proven all their doubters wrong.

p
proooooovince 45 days ago

I see the All Black fans are nice and salty in these comments.


Not my style really, but if I was going to stick the knife in I would’ve waited at least one more game just to be sure Ellis Park was real trend and not a blip.


And whatever happens this series, don’t worry, the Boks will be strong for that quarter final in next year’s WC.

B
BluesBust 44 days ago

Always add salt for flavor.

Are you talking about loosing this series already and building for the 1/4 final?Cmon we are only one game in, so defeatist.

B
B 45 days ago

Rassie has made a calculated decision that fits within his game strategy and its up to Dave Rennie, his staff and players to counter it in Cape Town…


Go the AB's…A repeat of last weeks staunch attitude wins…Kapa O Pango…

M
MM 44 days ago

Thats a sensible comments chap unlike the earlier prats

B
BluesBust 45 days ago

All we have heard for years out of SA is they have 3 teams to smash any other team in the world. Now the excuse we were rusty, but we get told practice at SA training is harder than playing a test. Hmmm

f
fl 44 days ago

The reaction to the game by SA-haters is silly, but given the arrogance of SA fans, you can hardly blame us for getting excited for their downfall.


And to be clear - if they win on saturday, that won’t make their absurd claims of depth any more true.

R
Red and White Dynamight 45 days ago

what happened to this ‘depth’ that theyve been shoving down everyone’s throats for the past 2-3+ years ? 40yr olds, pack is 30+ pffffft, theyre panicking

H
Hammer Head 43 days ago

Well it didn’t disappear after one loss, did it? Nor did the proverbial “they” shove it down everyone’s throats any more or less than virtually any pundit, local or abroad, looking for clicks.


The SBs have made quite a number of people famous, haven't they?


In the 6 Nations, of which I am a great fan, the competing teams regularly drop games against each other. On any given weekend, it’s not uncommon for teams like France to lose to teams like Scotland.


But the earth keeps spinning.


Between the no.1 and no.2 team, one should expect games to go one way or the other. Surely?


But when clowns like this ou jump on the bandwagon - emboldened by one win/loss - my gosh it’s both pathetic and hilarious at the same time.


Mostly pathetic.


Keep it up chum. Looks good on you and every other sourpuss lecturing Saffers on decorum.


You’re about as common as they come.

f
fl 44 days ago

be careful - I’ve been warning about the SB’s age profile for years now, and everytime I think they’re on their last legs they keep on going.


I think I’ve overstated the SB’s issues in the past because I assumed they would be impacted by age in the same way that other teams are. But most teams face the dual risk of (1) older players losing fitness, and (2) losing players to lucrative contracts overseas. The SB’s only face the former problem, which means they have less need to bring through young players than other teams do. England, for example, have to give caps to a load of 22 year olds so that those players will be on 50+ caps by the time they are 30. SA know they can retain a higher percentage of players, so don’t need to cap new players until they are in their mid- or sometimes late-twenties, and still get them to the same number of caps by the end of their careers. Obviously SA players tend to drop off after they hit 30, but England, and other teams that cap players young, also face the risk of players simply never fulfilling their potential. If SA cap a 28 year old, they know he’ll start to decline pretty soon, but they also know he can reliably perform at a particular standard. The long and the short of it is that SA are able to maintain a very experienced squad, that appears to be very deep, while capping very few new or young players.


All that said - things don’t look great for them. Picking Deon Fourie is a desperate move, and I just don’t think the backline is very good.

B
Bruiser 45 days ago

Next 5 world cups apparently

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close