Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

Biggest call of Borthwick’s reign to date: 5 England talking points

By PA
Fin Smith - PA

England warmed up for Saturday’s clash with New Zealand by claiming a ninth consecutive win after dispatching Fiji 38-18.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here the PA news agency looks at five lessons learned from the second of this month’s four matches at Allianz Stadium.

On a roll
Rewind 12 months and England were on a seven-Test losing run against tier one opposition. Now they occupy the giddy heights of being expected to topple New Zealand in the headline event of the autumn in what would be their first triumph over the All Blacks at Twickenham since 2012.

Fiji are dangerous opponents who sprung an almighty upset when the nations met two years ago so England will be satisfied at having negotiated a banana-skin fixture with an ultimately emphatic victory.

Here comes the cavalry
One again it was the bench that proved the difference with Fiji trailing just 21-18 when head coach Steve Borthwick unleashed his bomb squad of five forwards in the 54th minute. Maro Itoje and Henry Arundell were part of a staggered second wave who helped propel England clear with the three final-quarter try-scorers – Jamie George, Arundell and Itoje – all replacements. It has become a key weapon that has meant the late collapses that haunted 2024 are a distant memory.

Arundell makes an impact
Arundell celebrated the end of his two-year England exile by scoring the key try – and in a instant showed why he is a valuable weapon building towards he 2027 World Cup.

Unavailable for selection due to playing club rugby in France, it took just two minutes for the 23-year-old wing to display his raw pace by beating two defenders in a race for Marcus Smith’s kick. Dangerous every time he touched the ball, it was a high-octane cameo from the super-sub who shone the brightest of England’s bench.

Borthwick’s selection headache
England’s growing depth means Borthwick faces some tough decisions across the 23 for the visit of New Zealand and for the first time this autumn he will reveal his strongest starting XV. Expect Tom Curry to figure in the back row and for George Ford to return at fly-half, but even these calls are not certainties with the wings, full-back and midfield providing the biggest selection puzzles.

ADVERTISEMENT

Much depends on whether Borthwick wants to continue loading his bench with experienced heavyweights to gain the edge in the closing stages when the match will be won or lost. Thursday is shaping up to be the most fascinating team announcement of Borthwick’s reign.

Ben Earl
Ben Earl – PA

Fiji on the rise
Borthwick and captain Ellis Genge were effusive in their praise of Fiji – and these were no mere platitudes. The Islanders ultimately lost to the extra firepower England could bring to bear, but until that point they showed a thrilling ability to strike from anywhere on the field, a strong set-piece, solid kicking game and tactical cohesion.

Their ranking of ninth is due to never playing top tier opposition in Fiji and fails to reflect the threat they pose. Borthwick is backing them to be World Cup semi-finalists in 2027 and they are a side that all the big guns will want to avoid.

ADVERTISEMENT

Related

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

23 Comments
A
AA 28 days ago

Mark, Agreed. England were ok but no proper control at 10 . Fin is learning and will become even better. Ford would have just been an obstacle to run over hence not even on the bench . Marcus has played v much stiffer opp than ford or Fin recently so comparison a little unfair. . Remember AB,S last year when wee george came on and failed to put a decent tackle in on the scorer , missed simple kicks and we lost .

If ford in the team next week , we will lose . Borthwick has to be praised for putting together a terrific squad , but his predeliction to keep picking ford will be Englands undoing. You sense that the team is a jigsaw piece away from being a terrific team . Stop messing about with the back line, making stupid comments about no 8,s on the wing and select a settled team . Injuries accepted .

f
fl 27 days ago

“Marcus has played v much stiffer opp than ford or Fin”

Marcus always loses when he plays 10 against low quality opposition too.

M
Mark 28 days ago

For large parts of the game England were very average, the pack lacks some proper thumpers on the carry, and the backline with Borthwicks constant tinkering at flyhalf and in the centres doesn’t have any cutting edge.

P
PMcD 28 days ago

Mark, I understand your thought process but Borthwick has moved away from the game you suggest, so you won’t see it.


His 3 x 7 strategy will not have big thumpers and they will lose that contest, hence why he wants the ball 50 yards upfield with kick chase, or in the outside channel so the 3x7’s can get there before the opposition.


It’s a totally different style of rugby, which you then have to maintain for the full 80 mins, hence the 5x7’s to sustain it in the overall 23.


I still don’t think it will beat SA or FRA (consistently) but just hope the return of Elliott Daly means Fin Smith is kept at 10 and Daly plays at 15 vs NZ.

P
PMcD 28 days ago

I think Borthwick has decided how front five, back row and forwards bench, so you will see a combination of:


Genge/LcD/Stuart

Itoje/Chessum

Pepper/Curry/Earl


With the bench being:

Baxter/George/Heyes

Coles (will be Martin eventually)

Pollock & Ben Curry


I have no idea which way we are heading with the backs. That’s down to Blackett to decide but I hope we stick with Fin Smith at 10 and build that exciting attack we saw in the 6N’s.


Hopefully they will final;ise a way forward with the backline attack and we can start to see some consistency.

G
G.Osk 29 days ago

there is no parity in these november test matches, every team will struggle against southern hemisphere teams that just competed in Rugby champs, how can you put teams toghether that have been in training camp for a week or so with battle hardened world class teams that have months of preparation behind them?? I am just a rugby enthusiast who would like equal conditions for all the teams involved. Current international window is just not fair, plain and simple.. You can not replace experience with anything in any sport.

P
PMcD 28 days ago

That’s fair for the first two weeks but by game 3 they should be where they need to be. There is no excuse, let the best team win next week between ENG vs NZ. It’s going to be very close.

H
Hammer Head 29 days ago

Pesky Earth’s axis. So inconvenient.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close
ADVERTISEMENT