Northern | US

Age-old rugby debate triggered over Bok prospect Ethan Adams

Try scorer Ethan Adams of South Africa during the U20 Rugby Championship match between South Africa and Argentina at Nelson Mandela Bay Stadium on April 27, 2026 in Gqeberha, South Africa. (Photo by Richard Huggard/Gallo Images/Getty Images)
Comments
2 comments

Few U20 performances have lit up social media this quickly. Ethan Adams’ latest try for the Junior Springboks; a brutal, break-and-carry effort against Argentina U20 in the SANZAAR U20 Rugby Championship this week, has reignited an age-old rugby debate on X.

ADVERTISEMENT

Adams, who is listed at 1.75m (5’9) and 104kg, ran straight through or shrugged off six defenders to score. He scored a second, equally violent 40 metre charge to the line in the same game, running over a hooker on his way.

The SA Rugby Magazine podcast summed up the moment simply: “He beat two guys with his feet and four guys with his body… built like a prop, but scores like a centre.”

VIDEO

SuperSport echoed that assessment, posting after the try: “The Junior Boks inside centre showing why he is regarded as one of the best young talents in the world.”

It’s nothing new for Adams, who has been scoring similarly destructive [and viral] tries at a schoolboy level and in the Bulls academy systems for the last few seasons.

But alongside the praise came familiar reservations. One South African rugby account wrote: “Ethan Adams had a good performance but I still think his physical size (height particularly) would make it awkward for him to thrive at 15s game as an inside centre (compare against Ethan Hooker [1.94m] for example). I think Adams should join the Blitzboks and become a flanker like Kwagga [Smith].”

That summed up a sceptical view held by some: while Adams’ power is not in dispute, his height is seen by some as a potential limiting factor at senior professional or Test level, particularly in the 12-channel.

ADVERTISEMENT

The irony of that list was not lost on Adams’ defenders, many of whom used it to underline the opposite point. As the debate grew, comparisons became central. Oom Rugby laid out the numbers explicitly:

“On this, it is an interesting comparison… Ethan Adams 1,75m 104kg; Ngani Laumape 1,71m 103kg; Bundi Aki 1,78m 102kg; Scott Gibbs 1,74m 99kg… My feeling is it is less about size, and more that Ethan’s top speed after acceleration hits a ceiling.”

That post shifted the discussion away from height toward speed, suggesting Adams’ explosive acceleration may not be matched by elite top-end pace.

That, too, was challenged almost immediately. One response countered: “Literally every person in the world’s top speed hits a ceiling after accelerating. Ethan Adams runs a 100m in 10.8. speed is even worse an argument than height in comparison to the 3 others.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Others rejected the premise entirely, arguing that Adams’ height is not a flaw but a key part of his effectiveness. One supporter wrote: “Low man wins… That compact, powerful build is exactly what you want in a ball carrier. Built like a [NFL] running back.”

Another added: “His height is part of his strength, there’s nowhere on his body that people can tackle where they won’t get hurt.”

The historical comparisons kept coming.

“If height mattered then Laumape would never have been an All Black. Adrian Jacobs would never have been a Springbok. Shane Williams would never have won World Player of the Year,” read one post. “Ethan Adams is a tank, he’s extremely talented and people will realise just how good he is soon.”

If you ask this rugby writer,  the response would be: If he’s good enough, he’s big enough.

RugbyPass App Download

News, stats, live rugby and more! Download the new RugbyPass app on the App Store (iOS) and Google Play (Android) now!


Whether you’re looking for somewhere to track upcoming fixtures, a place to watch live rugby or an app that shows you all of the latest news and analysis, the RugbyPass rugby app is perfect.

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

2 Comments
f
fl 1 hr ago

“I think Adams should join the Blitzboks and become a flanker like Kwagga [Smith].”

A yes, centres need to be tall, but famously height doesn’t matter at all for back row forwards 😂


Give him a pre-season to train at hooker. If scrumming, maulling, and lineout throwing comes naturally to him then he could be incredible there. If not, keep him at 12. If he’s good enough he’s tall enough.

I
Itsallacademic 1 hr ago

There was a time many people were saying Kolbe was too small to be an international wing and look how that turned out.


Players should not be pigeonholed according to stereotypical physical attributes - that just leads to myopia.


If they have the skill and can find a way to deliver the required outcomes, that is all tha matters.

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close