Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
World World

'Shocker' - Andy Goode floats theory over hefty Brad Shields' ban

By Kim Ekin
Brad Shields /PA

Trending on RugbyPass

More News More News

Andy Goode has a theory as to why the Wasps’ backrow Brad Shields copped such a hefty ban for a controversial hit last weekend in the Heineken Champions Cup.


Many believe that Shield’s hit against Munster loosehead Dave Kilkoyne did not merit a red card, but high-profile referee Romain Poite thought it deserved the highest sanction and sent the New Zealand born forward off.

It was a huge decision that tilted the game heavily in favour of the visiting Irish side.

Video Spacer

Episode 14 – Ali Price, Quarantine Hotels & Champions Cup Rugby
Video Spacer
Episode 14 – Ali Price, Quarantine Hotels & Champions Cup Rugby

There was an expectation that Wasps could successfully turn over the decision in the citing commissioner’s disciplinary panel, but instead Shields was landed with a four-week ban.

The panel judged that the influential former England flanker made contact with the head and neck area of prop Kilcoyne at the CBS Arena, thereby warranting the red.

Wasps, however, are convinced it was harsh and with an appeal likely to be held tonight [Thursday, December 16], a successful challenge could mean Shields becomes available for the Stade Ernest Wallon showdown.

“I can’t say too much yet because I’ve not received the written judgement,” head coach Lee Blackett said.


“Once we’ve received that, we will appeal it. Saying that we’re appealing it probably tells you all you need to know.

“Brad is desperate to play. He probably feels harshly done to a little bit. Whatever will happen will happen, he’s the ultimate team man and he will react positively.”

Former Wasps and England standoff Goode has floated a theory on the decision on Twitter.

“Crazy decision to ban Brad Shields for 4 weeks for the tackle on Dave Kilcoyne. Initial contact was with the chest, the disciplinary panel have had a shocker and are probably just going with it because it’s a top tier referee in Poite who made the decision.”


It’s quite a shout from Goode. Either way, Wasps will be hoping the commissioners see it drastically different in tonight’s appeal.

– additional reporting PA


Join free and tell us what you really think!

Join Free
TRENDING Scott Barrett and Jack Goodhue get positional shifts for Crusaders' clash with Drua Barrett and Goodhue get positional shifts