Northern | US

Two Englishmen on referee panel for Greatest Rivalry Series


DUBLIN, IRELAND - MARCH 16: Referees, Karl Dickson and Matthew Carley watch the TMO during the Guinness Six Nations 2024 match between Ireland and Scotland at Aviva Stadium on March 16, 2024 in Dublin, Ireland. (Photo by Charles McQuillan/Getty Images)
Comments
41 Comments

The four referees for the Greatest Rivalry Series between South Africa and New Zealand have been announced by World Rugby, with Matt Carley taking charge of the first Test at Ellis Park in Johannesburg on 22 August.

ADVERTISEMENT

Groundbreaking Georgian official Nika Amashukeli has been handed the second Test at the DHL Stadium Cape Town a week later, while Australian official Angus Gardner will run the rule over the third Test, which takes place at the FNB Stadium in Johannesburg on 5 September.

The Series will then head to the United States, where the fourth Test in Baltimore will be refereed by Carley’s fellow Englishman, Karl Dickson.

VIDEO

Carley and Dickson ran touch in the final of Rugby World Cup 2023, a 12-11 win for the Springboks over New Zealand.

Related

The four tour matches against South African franchises will be shared between the quartet, who have all run the rule over previous Boks vs All Blacks clashes.

All three of the previous fixtures in which Carley was the whistleblower ended in wins for the Boks, including the then record 35-7 victory in London on the eve of RWC 2023.

And South Africans will remember only too well the record 43-10 win for South Africa in Wellington last year, which was refereed by Amashukeli.

ADVERTISEMENT

However, the head-to-head is 2-1 in New Zealand’s favour when Gardner has been the man in the middle, while Dickson’s only previous experience of the fixture as a referee was the 24-17 win for the All Blacks at Eden Park in last year’s Rugby Championship.

The four Tests in Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry Series are part of a 22-match international schedule between August and October, which will involve 16 officials from nine unions.

Eoghan Cross (Ireland) will referee the first test of the window between Japan and Australia in Osaka on 8 August with Luke Pearce (England) taking charge of the last, the second Bledisloe Cup encounter between Australia and New Zealand in Sydney on 17 October.

Related

Follow your favourites in the RugbyPass App

Your home for rugby. Download the RugbyPass app on the App Store (iOS) and Google Play (Android) now!


Follow your favourite teams, tournaments and players, and get personalised news and Match Centre notifications direct to your device.


From live rugby streams and upcoming fixtures to breaking news, in-depth analysis and live scores, RugbyPass has everything you need to stay connected to the game.

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

41 Comments
B
B 44 days ago

The AB’s senior players know the referees and must get onside with them to figure out what to expect…

That's Ardies job but Taylor, Jordie and Jordan will be there to help him keep everyone focused on their game plan…

R
RD 44 days ago

Home games and NH refs give SA a head start. SA players experience NH refs more often and their style of game is understood by the NH refs who have difficulty keeping up with a faster game. So advantage SA!

T
Tooly 44 days ago

They do their best !

J
Jmann 45 days ago

what terrible news for this series. WR let everyone down yet again..

H
Hammer Head 45 days ago

This is great news. The Boks chances of a series win just went up a notch…

E
EvilMockingJay 45 days ago

I like that way of doing things. With NH refs for SH teams and the reverse for NH teams. That way, SH and NH teams learn how they handle the wistle in the other side of the world.

What I saw is that SH refs “let it play” a lot, while NH are more strict, and will not be afraid to wistle. Would be nice to close as much as possible the “interpretation gap” and harmonize the rules so every ref is doing the same thing for every team in the same situation.

But, as long as it ain’t done, well, it’s a cool thing to do. I saw that during the Nations Championship. Most of the games had a NH ref. I bet it will be the contrary in November, with SH refs coming north.

I actually prefer NH way of doing things a lot more. I mean, if there is a rule broken, it’s normal to wistle. It’s not the ref that should stay quiet but the players that should do better and not break rules. I don’t understand SH way. I mean, it’s rugby not free for all fight with an oval ball. There is rules, rules are here to be followed.

If a SH specialist could explain me ? I would love you to explain me the thing. Since I'm in NH it’s a bit complicate to fully understand by just look at some random games located in SH.

J
J Marc 45 days ago

I think you forgot a way of refering : the NH one ,the SH ref in international game and the SH ref in SRP.

I watched the the SRP final with Nic Berry ,when he refed the advantage of the advantage of the advantage, and with this crazy wind, I was totally lost in this game…

T
Timmyboy 45 days ago

Matthew Carley loves making it all about him and loves handing out cards, so prepare for a rubbish first test.

R
RD 44 days ago

A replacement for Barnes in that respect.

T
TokoRFC 45 days ago

I’d love a stat breakdown of games reffed by each one.


I have my prejudices against some of these guys. I’d like to see them tested

J
Jon 44 days ago

South Africa have won 5, NZ 3 in the 8 games the quartet have reffed

c
cnw 45 days ago

I groaned when I saw the headline, and then groaned some more when I read the article. 3 of the 4 tests could be a train wreck for both teams…. But probably more so for ABs whose high temp rugby could see them hit more in 50/50 judgments just by dint of the fact they play with the ball more in hand.

L
Lou Cifer 45 days ago

at least it’ll be a better spectacle with Nic Berry not involved👀

J
Jacque 45 days ago

Ben Smith already coming up with the excuses😂😂

u
unknown 45 days ago

You can forget the rugby in the Fourth test it will be all about little Karl.

B
Bazzallina 45 days ago

Cold dude..not saying you ain’t right tho

J
JJ 45 days ago

So New Zealand to win the third test!

T
Tom 45 days ago

Relax lads, you're in good hands. We're on it.


Disclaimer - you might not actually be in good hands for one of those tests

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close