Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global

Rennie can't turn rocks into diamonds but not all hope's lost for Wallabies

By Tom Vinicombe
(Photo by Mark Runnacles/Getty Images)

Dave Rennie is a smart operator, but he’s no miracle worker.

Contrary to what’s been said over the past few weeks, although there may have been much chopping and changing to the Wallabies team throughout the year, you can bet your bottom dollar that Dave Rennie has a very clear idea in his head who would make the line-up in a World Cup knockout match if it were being played next weekend.


There’s a narrative going around that Rennie needs to settle on a first-choice side now but that’s not the approach the Kiwi adopted when he led the Chiefs to back-to-back titles in 2012 and 2013. Every week, five or six players would shuffle in and out of the run-on XV, bar a few men who simply couldn’t be left out. Come the finals series, however, Rennie picked a team and stuck with it – and it paid massive dividends.

Undoubtedly, Rennie is taking a similar approach to his stint in charge of the Wallabies. A clear selection pattern has emerged in some positions and the vast majority of punters could select the bulk of the starting side that Rennie would opt for if Saturday’s match against Wales were a World Cup final.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

James Slipper, Dave Porecki and Allan Alaalatoa have missed just a handful of matches between them and are the clear-cut first-choice front row.

In the loose forwards, Michael Hooper is nailed on at No 7 and Rob Valetini has started all but two Tests this season at the back of the scrum (he was rested against Italy and shifted to the blindside flank in the second Bledisloe Cup clash).

Nic White has been a constant at halfback, a fit Samu Kerevi is world-class and Len Ikitau has made the No 13 jersey his own since debuting last year.

Throw in Tom Wright and Marika Koroibete, and you have a consistent spine of players who Rennie has called upon week after week.


There are a number of strong back-ups across the board too, with Angus Bell, Taniela Tupou, Folau Fainga’a, Pete Samu, Jake Gordon and Hunter Paisami regularly featuring in the 23 or stepping into starting roles when injuries have forced Rennie’s hand.

Said injuries have complicated things in a few positions, of course – as well as the unavailability of some players throughout the season.


The locking situation is somewhat unclear, with Rory Arnold and Will Skelton getting limited opportunities due to the above issues. Matt Philip, Cadeyrn Neville and Nick Frost have all been afforded plenty of minutes throughout the year while Jed Holloway has split his time between the second and back rows.

The No 10 jersey remains the biggest concern, with Quade Cooper ostensibly the first-choice in the position but getting just one start there this year. Bernard Foley is serviceable, as is James O’Connor – but they’re not going to win Australia a World Cup.


Perhaps the biggest blight of Rennie’s career has now been bringing in a new talent at flyhalf but the only real option in that role is Noah Lolesio. If Rennie had stuck with Lolesio throughout 2021 and 2022, would the Wallabies be in a better position heading into next year’s tournament?

Outside of Lolesio, the cupboard is bare. The likes of Tane Edmed, Ben Donaldson and Will Harrison will never be greats of the game and putting Australia’s faith in one of that trio to lead them to glory in 2027 will backfire spectacularly.

That really emphasises the biggest problem in Australia – and it’s not Rennie’s selection policy.

The fact of the matter is that the players are simply not as good as the generational talents of the past. Perhaps that’s a product of the resources in Australia or the ongoing battle for talent with the NRL, but it’s clear as day that the youngsters coming through the ranks aren’t up to the standards of a top-three Test rugby nation – and that means no matter who’s in charge of the Wallabies, they’re always going to struggle to compete with the likes of New Zealand, Ireland, France and England.

That doesn’t mean they can’t grab wins against those nations. The recent loss to Ireland showed that it’s entirely possible for Australia to remain competitive with the best sides in the world, but there’ll also be a few 40-point thumpings along the way. The Australia of 2022 is no different to the Ireland side of the early 2000s, or a post-2003 England.

In years gone by, the Wallabies would be able to put out a second-string side and still put Italy to the sword – but that’s just not the case anymore, as Rennie found out in Florence.

A World Cup title looks out of reach for the Wallabies at present but with Rennie at the helm, there’s the distinct possibility that a semi-final finish is in reach – and that would be a mighty fine achievement for the current Australian side. Should Rennie’s men top their pool in France (their main competitor is Wales), they’ll almost certainly face off with Argentina in the quarters, giving them a very real chance of progressing to the next stage of the competition.

They could even cause an upset in the semi-finals – as they almost did in Dublin in the weekend gone.

But ultimately, Australia’s lack of success this year or next won’t be a result of too much chopping and changing by Rennie. There are bigger issues at play.


Join free



Trending on RugbyPass


1 Comment
Sam 600 days ago

I understand in the eyes of New Zealanders, apart from Paul Cully, Dave Rennie can never do wrong. But the evidence that consistency of selection and cohesion leading to successful teams is overwhelming and one of the few evidence-based variables shown to lead to successful teams.

I'm looking forward to this comment being proven wrong "The likes of Tane Edmed, Ben Donaldson and Will Harrison will never be greats of the game and putting Australia’s faith in one of that trio to lead them to glory in 2027 will backfire spectacularly".

All of these players are 23 years old or younger. If you've watched enough of these players play you will realize that Australia currently has the best batch of junior playmakers they've had in over a decade. They just need more time to develop.

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

Jon 3 hours ago
How Maro Itoje terrorised the All Blacks lineout

Yeah England were much smarter, they put their much vaster experience to use in both the scrum (bending/not taking hit) and lineout (Itoje early sacks) law vagaries. Really though, I know what is there, I’m more worried about Englands locks. We only got to see Itoje and Martin, right? Depth allround in the England camp was probably the difference in the series and the drop off when Itoje reached his minutes limit for the season (it was like the plug was pulled from the charger) was up there with keeping Sexton on the park in that quarter final. What happened there? You have a lot of watching hours experience with locks come blindsides Nick, especially with a typical Australian player make up, have you see a six the size of Barrett absolutely dominate the position and his opposition? I can easily see Scott, and even Martin for that matter, moving to the blindside and playing like Tadgh Beirne with the amount of top locks we have coming through to partner Patrick. Still with the English mindset, because despite running the best All Black team I’ve seen in a long time close, they do need to find improvement, and although I thought they had a lot of good performances from their 7’s (over the years), I really like the prospect of Cunningham-South in his 8 spot and Earl on the open. Can you see Martin as mobile enough to take over Lawes? I absolutely loved his aggression when Jordie ran upto him to try and grab the ball. That alone is enough reason for me to try him there.

39 Go to comments
TRENDING Jono Gibbes' reaction to France U20s putting 55 points on New Zealand Jono Gibbes' reaction to France U20s putting 55 points on New Zealand