Ref Watch: Pundits but not experts
We’ve had 16 games over two weeks in an enthralling World Cup and it is time to take stock.
There have of course been plenty of talking points from a refereeing perspective – many of which have centred on the head contact debate – but what else has caught the eye?
The Main Men
Refereeing the World Cup final is the goal of every official that picks up a whistle in an international and plenty that get nowhere near that far – this one included!
But to date only eight have received the ultimate officiating accolade with South Africa’s Andre Watson twice at the helm – in 2003 and in the eyes of many less controversially so in 1999.
With four years between competitions, there is a fair body of evidence with which to rank the officials. I venture to suggest that Craig Joubert’s appointment to the 2011 final has been the only mild surprise during the 36 years that have passed since the late Kerry Fitzgerald took charge of New Zealand and France in 1987.
We can with some confidence therefore predict that one of Wayne Barnes or Jaco Peyper will accompany the 2023 finalists at the Stade de France next month. What we don’t yet know is which one…
Barnes began his tournament this weekend when he took charge of Ireland and Tonga. While his style is not for everyone, his supreme calmness and ability to think in logical straight lines is a real asset. He communicates clearly and while you may not agree with all his calls you are in no doubt why he makes them.
Barnes – at his fifth World Cup – is the world’s most experienced referee and it shows. He has the respect of everyone and his standards rarely drop. After the mild hysteria stoked by social media and some TV pundits during the opening week it was comforting to see him in charge since regardless of the complexity involved in modern law interpretations, he is totally on top of his job.
I thought South Africa’s sole representative in this year’s referee group also did a solid job when asked to deal with the pressure of France v New Zealand on opening night.
Peyper is equally as unflappable as his English counterpart and very accurate in law. His manner – like the London-based barrister – is not for everyone but he gets very little wrong which is surely a good starting point. His communication is minimal and to the point but his message gets across and the players know where they stand. Lots to like.
Across the rest of the ref pack I enjoyed the performances of Ben O’Keeffe and Luke Pearce during the opening two rounds of action.
Taking charge of France v Uruguay, a game which eventually proved harder work for the hosts than many predicted, O’Keeffe showed excellent communication skills and ensured both sides remained focused on a night when frustration and ill-discipline could easily have crept in. This match involved a head contact yellow card which the bunker team chose not to upgrade – but of course this is outside the referee’s control.
Pearce impresses me more with each passing season and there was again plenty to like in his handling of Australia v Georgia. The young English official is really good at keeping the tempo high in his games – next time you see him look out for how often he hustles the players to get the ball into scrums and lineouts and not to create unnecessary down time. A possible final referee in 2027?
Referee in the TV team?
Nigel Owens periodically joined TV coverage of Japan 2019 and he has since intermittently been seen on our screens during big international occasions.
Four years on ITV’s coverage in the UK features Irish-born former Premiership and international referee JP Doyle in the same role.
As a former referee, I generally enjoyed Owens’ input as he appeared to be operating with a brief to explain incidents through a referee’s eyes and to help unpick complicated situations for a viewing audience many of whom probably watch rugby union on a very occasional basis.
He also took a sympathetic approach to dealing with onfield errors and struck a good balance between explaining what should have happened while also putting across suggested reasons why the man with the whistle had reacted differently.
By contrast – perhaps through a change in editorial policy – I am really uncomfortable with Doyle’s role. At the point that the commentary team reveal he is messaging them from London to nit-pick tiny pieces of detail in the referee’s performance is he really helping anyone?
He feels like the most critical referee assessor around who instead of privately debriefing the referee on a one-to-one basis post-match is instead on a soapbox lecturing the world by the medium of TV.
Where football leads rugby union follows…
Pundits but not experts…
It is now 20 years since England won the World Cup and for a variety of reasons it really is time to pension off those involved from the TV pundit’s sofas.
Jonny Wilkinson seems a lovely bloke and he probably has plenty of insight to offer but every time I hear him speak I feel like I am lost in a secondary school and have inadvertently wandered into a sixth form psychology lesson.
At the point that his response to a question about kicking a drop goal became a discourse on ‘communicating with the ball’ I’m afraid I was done.
Given that the law-makers response to reducing head contact has been the dominant feature of professional rugby’s development in the last five years is it unreasonable to expect Sir Clive Woodward and his mate Lawrence Dallaglio to grasp the basics of what is going on?
They both seem completely unable to get beyond phrases like “it was an accident” or “that’s a rugby incident for me” or “he’s not a player that would do that deliberately.”
Love it or loathe it, intent is no longer a factor that the officials consider when head contact takes place.
Comments on RugbyPass
The Black Ferns 7’s have been without Captain Sarah Hirini now since Dec 23 in Dubai where she suffered a bad ACL injury - hopefully she is on the road to recovery for Madrid and Paris. Now also have Tyler King and Shiray kaka on the Injured List but the Team still found a way to win in Singapore and claim the overall Title.
1 Go to commentsUtter grub, hope he gets his leg broken. Shocking he is still playing after intentionally breaking quinn tupaeas knee
2 Go to commentsGreat to see NZ 7s teams finally coming into form and playing at the level that is expected of them.
2 Go to commentsChief Cheapshot on the market again.
2 Go to commentsCrusaders went all in to buy Hotham and Kemara staight from Hamilton Boys. Then they picked up Reihana and Hohepa; all have been dropped for superstar Havili, who is a very good fullback, that’s it. Ennor and Goodhue were schoolboy stars too but went backwards at the Crusaders. Maybe they have finally decided to give another poach Levi Aumua the ball?
10 Go to commentsJoe S has some talent to pick from. The Reds loosies look the best in Super? Aus might just give Razor a headache this year. Int. experience v Cantab greenhorn:) Should be fun.
10 Go to commentsEnd to end play, “THE FANS” this game was entertainment of the best. The conditions added to the spectacle.
1 Go to commentsSorry to say, but sadly the sadas were just ordinary and havilli at 10 as an abs selection just won’t cut it. He’s better suited in the centre’s and is a victim of past charge down kicks, he’s too slow under pressure. There’s better talent further north and I don’t mean dmac however I believe razor will sort him out. A feature of his presents on the park is the fact that the guys will follow him.
10 Go to commentsMarler was brilliant throughout both in the scrum and open play. His slap made virtually no contact with Ramos who milked it for a penalty when he could have been a decent sportsman and laughed it off, it was non-violent and shouldn't have been penalised. Smith failed repeatedly to kick when necessary and put up a couple of bombs into the TLS 22 that just handed back possession at key moments to the other side.
3 Go to commentsCros was outstanding and rightly awarded France TVs player of the match award. Mallia was brilliant as usual (the y is below the 6 on a UK keyboard and he deserves better than that). Level also seems to have been scored harshly as he walked the ball into touch under pressure from a Lynagh kick from well outside his own half which should never have led to a 50-22. Agree with BullShark that Dupont, while class at times, seemed to go missing for patches in the second half with props, hookers and wings frequently filling in at 9 as he couldn't get off the deck and up to the next ruck on time. A 7 by his standards at best, his kicking was also too long, too often. Kinghorn's overall contribution was worth well more than a five.
3 Go to commentsThe Harlequins team must be in minus figures. Did the reporter actually watch the game?
3 Go to commentsHow on earth did Walker escape a red card? Not dangerous? Dupont has his face in a mask earlier this season. Shocking decision. What is the point of TMOs? We had the Fassi ‘non-penalty try’ yesterday and now this.
2 Go to commentsCould have been a different result but yet again French tv able to affect the result by not showing the very clear high shot on harlequin centre if this would have been on a French player would have been on screen at least five times
3 Go to commentsAmazing. The losing team’s ratings are higher than the winning team’s. Mallia definitely didn’t deserve a y. What game were you watching? Should have got a w or an x. ADP hardly featured in that second half. At one point I wondered when he’d been subbed. Seems to me as if he gets an automatic 9 just for getting onto the team sheet.
3 Go to commentsI’m sorry. That second half was far from enthralling. It was painful to watch.
2 Go to commentsVery generous! If you’d missed the game, reading this you’d conclude that it was the Quins front row that cost them the game. Marler getting a blanket 6 for his demented contribution to the game. Puzzling.
3 Go to commentsCan’t see Toulouse beating Leinster at this rate.
7 Go to commentsADP was having a very average game until winning that penalty for Toulouse, sticking his big head in the way. “The head of God”?
7 Go to commentsHarlequins doing their best to do as little damage as possible with all the possession. Looks like they skipped catch and pass drills this week.
7 Go to commentsSeeing pictures of Jacques high-fiving it with Irish players breaks my heart. Too soon. I need more time.
1 Go to comments