Northern | US

'I don’t envy being a referee at the moment'

Captains Yutaka Nagare of Japan and Martin Sigren of Chile join Referee Nic Berry at The Asahi Coin Toss prior to the Rugby World Cup France 2023 match between Japan and Chile at Stadium de Toulouse on September 10, 2023 in Toulouse, France. (Photo by Justin Setterfield - World Rugby/World Rugby via Getty Images)
Comments
Comment

England wing Anthony Watson hopes World Cup officials can find a greater level of consistency on sanctioning dangerous tackles, but accepts they have a difficult job to do in interpreting the laws.

ADVERTISEMENT

Tom Curry was red-carded and banned for two matches after a dangerous tackle on Argentina’s Juan Cruz Mallia in England’s opening game last weekend.

However, similar incidents in matches involving South Africa and Chile went unpunished by officials.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

Watson, who missed out on a place in England’s World Cup squad because of a calf injury suffered on the eve of the tournament, told the PA news agency: “There is a bit of inconsistency there, but you’re always going to get inconsistency when it’s interpretation of a law. There’s no black or white answer to them all.

“Would we like it to be better? Yes, we definitely would. But I don’t think we can ever get to a position where we can say ‘this is a red card and this is not a red card’.

“It always has to be an interpretation, and what comes with that is a little bit of inconsistency. What I would say is that we would probably like a little bit more consistency than there currently is. But I don’t envy being a referee at the moment.”

Watson added it was “not great” for players either trying to adapt to the stringent new rules, but said everyone is training extremely hard to minimise the number of tackles deemed to be dangerous.

ADVERTISEMENT

Related

“If you take Tom Curry’s one – which he has accepted was a red card by the way – when you go into a tackle with as much commitment as he does and someone’s head drops as much as (Mallia’s) did, it’s very, very difficult for him to change his body position,” Watson said.

“So I don’t envy players, and it’s not great being a player at the moment and trying to do that. But what you can do is work on it and try to mitigate it as much as possible by making sure the majority of your tackles are within a certain bandwidth, and all of the lads are doing that because we practise three or four times a week.

“There are some incidents where it’s extremely difficult, but you have just got to try to be as conscious as possible about your tackle height as often as possible.”

Watson accepts the tackle laws are crucial, not just to protect current players but also to set the right example to children looking to get involved in the sport, and their parents.

ADVERTISEMENT

He attended a grassroots training session in Crewe on Friday to mark Concussion Awareness Day. Led by UK Coaching, the club delivered a session highlighting that every sport’s first priority must always be safety and well-being, and the role of education and support for coaches.

Related

Watson said: “Safety in sport is massively important and today is about raising the awareness of UK Coaching’s Duty To Care toolkit, which provides resources for coaches.

“That can be anything from the mental health of the coaches themselves or their players to concussion, which I think is most prevalent here at a rugby club. It is about being able to see the symptoms of concussions and work with players on how they can mitigate those risks, and to pull players out if they see those symptoms early.

“Putting the rules in place in the elite game and making sure the right example is set means that kids don’t see ridiculous high tackles where people are getting injured and try to copy that, because it’s the wrong thing to be copying.

“The bigger picture sometimes gets lost with these rules. You want to create change in the players’ habits to get them to tackle lower, and that is because we don’t want to see as many concussions in the game, and we also want kids and their parents not to be scared of getting concussions and to enjoy the sport as much as possible.”

:: To find out more about Duty to Care and to access the Hub, visit https://www.ukcoaching.org/duty-to-care and for resources on concussion visit https://www.ukcoaching.org/resources/concussion.

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

T
TL 1 hour ago
Joe Schmidt bows out on a high - but can the Wallabies escape 'the twilight zone'?

It’s hard to see how any coach could have done much better and that coaches can only shift the dial so much in Australia, we’ve had some of the best in the world and the trajectory has been the same. The win/loss record is obviously an important metric, but it is only one metric, and not necessarily the best to assess a team that is really still in a building phase (2024 was recovery!). You could look at something like average losing margin, and the trajectory there is much better, with the 2025/2026 results close to half the losing margin in 2024 and during Eddie’s reign (roughly 10, compared to closer to 20). Much has been made of the so called merry-go-round at 10 (really sick of that phrase but here I am using it), but losing Noah, Lygnah and Dono between Fiji and SA games in 2025, and Carter then Dono in 2026 had nothing to do with Joe. He consistently backed his first choices and backed youth at 10 when he could. The injuries led to a massive increase in uncertainty around whether to risk players who weren’t ready or back experience but lose the future benefit. In that situation I think we need to permit our coaches a greater degree of experimentation and error. Much has been made of the LSL situation, but what about how Joe’s selections at lock have led to some real depth of capability there, with players that weren’t as conspicuously impressive (e.g. Williams, Canham). Joe has made his mistakes, but he righted the trend that was heading sharply down, and I suspect that as with what he left in Ireland and as with Stuart Lancaster your old mate, the true test of his time will be what happens in the wake.

245 Go to comments
Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close