Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

'Frustrating': Pundit weighs in on where the All Blacks struggled in Chicago

Illinois , United States - 1 November 2025; Players from both side's tussle during the Gallagher Cup match between Ireland and New Zealand at Soldier Field in Chicago, USA. (Photo By Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile via Getty Images)

For long periods of the All Blacks‘ Test victory over Ireland in Chicago, Scott Robertson’s side struggled to wrestle momentum in their favour, and couldn’t build phases to hurt Andy Farrell’s side.

ADVERTISEMENT

But then suddenly, with about 20 minutes to go, like the All Blacks of old, they clicked into gear with the bench making a real impact to take the game by the scruff of the neck.

This was the turning point of the encounter, after Ireland had frustrated the Kiwis in the opening half by trying to slow the game down.

Current Sky Sport commentator and former Bay of Plenty prop Ben Castle says that Farrell’s side found a way to try and slow the All Blacks down, which worked well in the first half.

Related

“Though, when you look at this performance for Scott Robertson and this coaching team, they might be thinking to themselves, they’ll like what they’ve seen in parts, but they won’t like how teams have found out a way to slow them down,” Castle said on The Breakdown on Sky Sport.

“Kick the ball out, slow down that line out, get it into the crowd so they can’t go quickly. Slow down the defensive play. Slow down the ruck, get the ball away, make them chase back.

“So I think from an All Black point of view, we’d love to attack and love to counter attack but it’s often taken away.

“It frustrates them, and we saw in the first half, but what they will see on the other side is how good it was in that second half. There’s still stuff to work on, but how good it was in that second half, how they controlled possession, and that got the width and tempo into the game.”

Former All Black centurion Mils Muliaina believes that the bench players are starting to understand their bench roles, as well as applying the game plan effectively.

ADVERTISEMENT

Both Tamaiti Williams and Wallace Sititi came on and affected the Test match in a positive way, scoring a try each to close out the game for the All Blacks.

Fixture
Internationals
Scotland
17 - 25
Full-time
New Zealand
All Stats and Data

“I think they’re starting to understand, those lessons that they’ve sort of had from that not being able to finish with guys understanding their roles.

“We’re starting to build really good depth, in some cases right now, when your captain and vice captain go down, but the guys that sort of step in are beginning to become comfortable, being uncomfortable now.

“From not being able to finish guys understanding their roles, and possibly the coaches are also starting to understand what game plan they want to sort of implement around these guys, so the game was was messy, but they won in a fashion that sort of showed, hey, we have a plan and we’re going to stick to it, and everyone is aligned.”

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

7 Comments
j
johnz 35 days ago

Kicking the ball out with more focus on set piece is a huge part of test rugby, this is not Super rugby where all teams play similarly. Test rugby has always been that way. It’s a game of chess, where one team tries to nullify the strengths of the other.


If they were to look more objectively, Ireland were excellent in phase play for 60 minutes of that match. Well drilled, sharp and with super quick ruck ball, while the ABs looked slow and predictable in the same facet of the game.


The difference was the ABs found a way to break the game open for short periods and capitalise on those moments by playing what’s in front of them. Faiung’anuku and Sititi were big factors in allowing the ABs to play that way.

J
JW 34 days ago

Sadly Ireland have chosen to play checkers rather than Chess.


Their strategy could be made null and void with a sensible ref and one or two free kicks.

P
Poorfour 35 days ago

Although Ireland came out of the 20 minute red card period ahead, I think it took a big toll on them in terms of the level of effort they’d had to expend, and that combined with the age of their squad and the ABs fitness made the difference late on.


But Scotland and England will be looking at the game and seeing areas where they can pressure this NZ side. They’ll still be vulnerable to moments of magic, but I think they’ll see where they might be able to build a defensible lead.

J
John H 35 days ago

I think those 2 x pundits are away with the fairies.

Yes Ireland slowed it down a bit, but the ABs were horrendous, get into good position make a mistake, drop the ball, lineout stuff up. Stupid behind dummy runner passes. They never took it straight up th middle to the Irish, always trying for miracle balls.

Last 20 or so they became a bit more direct

B
Budhachief 35 days ago

Isn't it amazing when we start being direct we look like a different team? The whole reason Quin Tupaea looks good is he plays direct. It's basic rugby. Earn the right to go wide.

R
Ron Burgundy 35 days ago

Yes we had ball but the basic skills in that first 50 were some of the worst I’ve seen

Not helped by a ridiculous 55min first half too for both sides

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close
ADVERTISEMENT