Northern | US

Non-South Africa fans making same observation after Ellis Park loss


Players greet each other at the end of the Rugby's Greatest Rivalry international rugby union match between South Africa and New Zealand at Ellis Park Stadium in Johannesburg, on August 22, 2026. (Photo by PHILL MAGAKOE / AFP via Getty Images)
Comments
29 Comments

South Africa’s 33-16 defeat to the All Blacks at Ellis Park prompted a wave of reaction from rugby fans and pundits alike, with many observers making the same damning assessment of the Springboks’ performance.

ADVERTISEMENT

Despite dominating at scrum time and leading 13-12 at the break, the hosts unravelled in the second half as New Zealand ran in five tries to one to seize a 1-0 lead in the Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry series.

RugbyPass writer Ben Smith was quick to point out South Africa’s deficiencies: “All Blacks 33-16. Five tries to one. Boks had nothing but a scrum. Two yellows with 10 to go, well deserved. Under pressure and infringing on the try line. Grant Williams and Sacha no control. 1-0. On to Cape Town to try wrap it up.”

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

Martin Gillingham wrote: “Springboks imploding. Their citadel has crumbled. Fancy they’ll come back in the weeks to come but this, in the end, is a humiliation. Dave Rennie’s impact is bearing immediate fruit.”

One rugby fan wrote: “All Blacks are humbling the Springboks”; another that “The Springboks have imploded and not in a good way.”

Even hardened Bok fans conceded that their side had taken a pummelling: “All Blacks have fully deserved this. Boks humbled at Ellis Park,” wrote one South African fan, another noting: “Springboks having a complete meltdown, it’s sad to watch.”

There was also a lot of criticism for halfback pair Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu and Grant Williams, who failed to fire against the New Zealanders.

ADVERTISEMENT

One irate Springboks fan wrote: “Rassie you took too long to sub our 9 & 10, we didn’t convert inside their 22 especially that scrum in their 5m, too many handling errors, our backline wasn’t firing at all. I thought we had them first half with our physical dominance. We need our Captain [Siya Kolisi] back this was kak.”

Fans were also dismayed at the Boks’ inability to convert 22 entries into points, the home side managing just 0.9 points per entry into the All Blacks 22.

“We deserve this. You don’t get into the 22 that many times, fail to convert those chances, and still expect to win. At some point, you have to take your chances and put the game to bed…”

SA journalist Brendan Nel wrote: “Rassie said it this week, you are only as good as your last game. This was embarrassing as a result. This was terrible from the Boks. Well done All Blacks – 5 tries to 1. An emphatic result. Advantage New Zealand.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Former Bok turned broadcaster Cobus Wiese noted: “Wake-up call for the Boks! You simply can’t argue with 5 tries to 1 and we looked vulnerable under pressure.”

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

29 Comments
D
D-RoD 30 days ago

🤫🤫🤫 - you have been weighed, you have been measured and you most certainly have been found wanting. If you can’t scrum, mual, own the collisions you cannot beat the Boks

K
Koos 44 days ago

All blacks needed that win! Well done…..they playing on their home turf this weekend!!!!

p
pm 45 days ago

Best team won ..This sets it up nicely for the remaining tests .. Looking forward to Cape Town as a neutral & rugby fan..

H
Hellhound 45 days ago

No one stays top forever. Once you reach the peak, there is nowhere else to go but back down again. The Boks lost at Eden Park and then came back with a vengeance. Never write off any team. As a Saffa I hate the loss, but for the Boks to win another WC, they needed the wake up call. They were getting complacent, even the coaching team. You learn more lessons out of a loss than a win.


The Boks made it easy for the AB's. No offence to the AB's. They were playing a great game. They thoroughly deserved this win. They lost a few in a row against the Boks, which is unheard off. They were hungrier for the win. I couldn't understand when some AB's fans and podcasts said this tour was more important than the WC. I still don't understand it, but the AB's came for revenge. They came to play and not F around. Time for Rassie to stop giving more talent chances and start getting his WC team ready by cutting spots, not adding to it.

T
Tk 45 days ago

The Boks went with size, physicality and set piece as their ace cards and initially it was working. But then they went all in and gave up points to convert that scrum advantage into yellow cards. If they had instead taken the 3’s when on offer and just maintained that physical dominance then the outcome could have been quite different. The ABs rode some luck into a lead, then a silly yellow quickly followed by a brain explosion yellow sealed it. Relatively small margins and next week could easily go the other way.

J
JW 45 days ago

I’d say bok fans feel more like this than anyone else.

M
Mzilikazi 45 days ago

In the end a magnificent victory for the AB’s, and for the Rennie coaching team. Congratulations !


There is a lot for the expert writers and analysts to work through in this game. I look forward the writers like Nick Bishop and Geoff Parkes commenting.

f
frandinand 45 days ago

I said elsewhere Mz that the game played out as Nic predicted. As long as the ABs were competitive with 20 to go they should prevail.

I fear for the Wallabies.

H
HS 45 days ago

What is the observation? That the Boks lost and the ABs deserved to win? I think everyone would conclude that.

J
John 45 days ago

ABs played well, but Boks gave it to them. Why do the Boks kick front foot ball away in opposition's half and passes not going to hand?

ABs wouldn't have stood a chance if Boks had to build phases, retain possession and ran at them.

Kriel & De Allende are great centres, but they do not make a dangerous combination. Boks have the ability to claim the rest of the 3 games. Team selection and game plan just needs to be correct.

O
Over the sideline 45 days ago

Bokke didnt GIVE nothing. ABs TOOK it.Gave Bokke NO CHOICE about it at all.

P
PB 46 days ago

- Why are we trying all these fancy tricks to force yellow cards out of the scrum. The boks is the best team in the world, do the scrum, get the penalty if awarded, crush hard, play wide and score the tries( like everybody else!) We don’t have to do it against 14 players.

- Rassie, we do have excellent centers, wings and fullback! Why not give them ballto run. The ball passed Sacha once and Andre scored a try!

m
mJ 46 days ago

They’d get gain line and do nothing with it. Just kept trying to bash through the front door. It was a big step backwards for the Boks, one dimensional. They previously have been expanding their game but today they just went back to the old Bok way without the lineout and maul tries.

T
The Bulgarian🇧🇬 46 days ago

Amazing how quickly the Springboks are written off! I would put the same Springbok team in next week and would bet my house on them coming out on top. Rugby is about rivalry, winning some and losing some. That's what makes it such a great game. The All Blacks were brilliant in the second half. Well done guys!! Let's go again next week😂🥳

J
Jay 45 days ago

I send you a good real estate company mate!

J
JW 45 days ago

I hope they do, SB have so many talented players I wouldn’t want Rassie to use too many at once.

u
unknown 46 days ago

One thing a lot of supporters are losing sight of, this All Blacks team has been playing together for the last three or four weeks and you can see that cohesion.


This Bok side haven’t really played together as a team, we have been experimenting and brining in a lot of new players!


I agree with you, next week, same Bok team and I think we win!!


That Bok side is seriously strong.


Today was just a bad day at the office. 🇿🇦🇿🇦

u
unknown 46 days ago

It wasn’t even a great game

Z
Zac 45 days ago

I thought that it was a grt game mate ,probablybecause we won..but last time out you gave us a flogging., biggest hiding that we have ever had..we gave up and tarnished the AB legacy…no AB team has ever given up before that test.

A lot of us were gutted…this game was about regaining face/ self respect…this is the Cultural rebuild that we need..Rennie is responsible for this..the Boks smashed us but the AB'S didn't fold..they hung tough…Rennie has got them developing much needed resilience and mental toughness which disappeared under Robertson.


We all know the Boks will come hard at us next test…I'm looking forward to it..cheers

O
Over the sideline 45 days ago

A fantastic game. I ABSOLUTELY LOVED IT.

T
Tim 46 days ago

Guess it depends on who you support. All the talk of the bench grinding the ABs into dust didn't come to much. You'd expect next week to be closer. ABs are building into some great form and riding a wave of confidence. Yet to lose under Rennie while stopping the Boks winning run. Great game.

D
DB 46 days ago

Well done AB. I agree with the article. Can’t win with scrum as your only weapon. It’s becoming too predictable.

u
unknown 46 days ago

Love this Bok side but today we were just not good.


The All Blacks deserved that win.


Besides the scrum, the Boks offered very little. We were flat, lacked ideas on attack and never really looked like taking control of the game.


Credit where it’s due, the All Blacks were the better side today. 🇿🇦🤝🇳🇿


Let’s Go Game two loading…

J
JW 45 days ago

You did a lot better than that. Won the lineout against the best lineout team in the world. Won the maul contest, won the ground game possible too. Won the collisions, the kicking game, had the control.


Just your patterns play tight and NZ were able to tin arse some wide tries and counter attacks like they do best.

T
TokoRFC 46 days ago

Cheers for the humility mate that was the intensity we were all expecting and then some from your boys


I thought we were going to get rumbled after that first half. The physicality was 11/10, Wiese especially, wow. Kolbe and Arendse coming off was unfortunate, those guys are elite. Can’t believe the scrum momentum shifted too, went from a certain yellow to us to marching back down field. The scoreboard pressure eventually got to the boks in the end.


Sacha wasn’t at his best, it’s so hard for a 10 to come straight back in and play at their peak

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close