Northern | US

England player ratings vs All Blacks | Nations Championship 2026

at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham

England's centre Seb Atkinson (C) celebrates after scoring their fifth try during the Nations Championship rugby union match between England and New Zealand at Allianz Stadium, Twickenham, in south-west London, on November 21, 2026. (Photo by Glyn KIRK / AFP)
Comments
14 Comments

England player ratings: England continued their fine November with a resounding 37-12 victory over the All Blacks at Twickenham’s Allianz Stadium on Saturday.

ADVERTISEMENT

England experienced a far-from-perfect build-up to the match, with British & Irish Lions wing Tommy Freeman being withdrawn from the squad moments before kick-off.

But an ill-disciplined start from the visitors gave England a comfortable foothold into the match, who dominated the first quarter. They didn’t, however, get the points they deserved following many trips into the All Blacks’ 22, with a staggering 50 per cent of the first half played in that area of the field.

Steve Borthwick’s side didn’t live to rue their profligacy, and built a 19-5 lead at the break and only built on that lead in the second half, with their bench providing firepower the All Blacks couldn’t handle.

It was the biggest win a northern hemisphere side have ever recorded over the All Blacks, and only the second time in their history England have recorded back-to-back wins over them, as they head into the finals weekend unbeaten in November. Here’s how the players rated:

Match Summary

2
Penalty Goals
0
5
Tries
2
3
Conversions
1
0
Drop Goals
0
174
Carries
109
13
Line Breaks
3
9
Turnovers Lost
16
5
Turnovers Won
6

15 George Furbank – 8.5
Drove a 50:22 from the gods to give England a five-metre lineout soon after their first try, but they couldn’t capitalise. Joined the line exquisitely to carve through the visitors’ defence, and then offload, to launch an onslaught and another try-scoring opportunity to England which they spurned. Couldn’t catch up with Beauden Barrett as the All Blacks scored their second try, but continued to be the creative force in the wider channels that makes this attack really click.

14 Will Joseph – 8
The All Blacks clearly looked to test the three-cap 24-year-old under the high ball, and he largely stood up to the challenge. Made some ‘Immanuel Feyi-Waboso-esque’ runs off the No.9 and in close contact – maybe not his style, but was effective nevertheless. Unsurprisingly, he had nowhere near the space he did in his five tries against Japan, but was freed a couple of times, notably in the lead-up to England’s fourth try with a sprint down the right flank.

ADVERTISEMENT

13 Henry Slade – 9
Continued his fine November with a try in the opening five minutes, being perfectly in sync with Fin Smith to chase his grubber kick to dot down. His match was littered with touches of pure class and even had a solo try for the ages when he was put away and then chipped over Barrett. At the age of 33 and with 80 caps to his name, England are witnessing the very best version of Henry Slade.

12 Seb Atkinson – 9
Distribution flat at the line was once again a key foundation to any attacking shape and fluency England showed. He may not be blasting through defences, but he still makes some hard yards with his carries and isn’t afraid of trucking it up. Max Ojomoh impressed in the No.12 jersey last week, but the Gloucester star showed why it is his jersey for the time being. Resolute in defence, and even had a clean rip in there as well and a try late on.

11 Cadan Murley – 9
A very late addition to the squad following Freeman’s withdrawal, but didn’t seem to miss a beat. Was on the end of an intricate move to slice through the All Blacks’ defence on 15 minutes and put a kick in for Joseph to chase and then burst through the line again to launch the attack, which resulted in England’s second try. Could have potentially run in England’s fourth try but had the presence of mind to feed the weightier Ollie Chessum in the corner. Three line breaks and four defenders beaten – not bad for someone that wasn’t expecting to play when he woke up this morning.

10 Fin Smith – 8.5
Dropped a grubber in to perfection for England’s opening try, and had the backline running smoothly right from the off with a passing range that was always the right choice and caused maximal damage. Had a rough patch midway through the first half, kicking a bomb out on the full and then missing touch with a penalty kick (with it eventually running dead), but seemed to rebound from that, and it didn’t cost England. His partnership with Atkinson is looking more lethal with every game, and the way he wraps behind his centre causes so many problems – chiefly as he put Murley through a gap in the build-up to England’s second try. Kicking from the tee was 50 per cent, although one was a touchline conversion. Worryingly, left the field before the hour mark.

ADVERTISEMENT

9 Jack van Poortvliet – 8
Kicking wasn’t always precise and even fluffed a pass from the base when England were deep in the All Blacks’ 22 in the opening quarter, but he tightened up his game and produced a tackle to force a knock-on from Tupou Vaa’i when the All Blacks were starting to develop some momentum and then just a matter of minutes later was leaping over two tacklers to score England’s second. Brought his forwards into the game really well, providing sharp passes which led to quite a few breaks. Perhaps he was just slightly slow in preventing Ethan de Groot from picking-and-going to score the All Blacks’ only try of the first half just before half time – but that is being overly harsh with the attack played at speed.

1 Fin Baxter – 7.5
Penalised for collapsing the scrum shortly before the 30 minute mark in a contest where neither side could get the upper hand. The partnership Baxter has formed with Joe Heyes in an England shirt was so sorely missed while he was out injured this year. Puts in so many effective tackles in the middle of the field, marching back any attack. Nine carries too in his 53 minutes on the field.

2 Jamie George – 7.5
Charged around furiously in defence in the first half and seemed to have the bit between his teeth. Dived to prevent his counterpart Codie Taylor from scoring from the back of a maul, though the visitors did score the following phase. Lineout worked perfectly too.

3 Joe Heyes – 7
Gifted the All Blacks a penalty and their first foray into England’s 22 for a knee-drop tackle (they were always going to be hotly officiated this week), but it did no damage to his side. He was the first to be pinged by Nic Berry at the scrum after a few even contests, but responded with a penalty of his own a few minutes later.

4 Maro Itoje – 8.5
The England captain’s carrying and rucking plays a deceptively crucial part in this new-look high-tempo England set-up as it requires a high work-rate from the forwards, with Itoje frequently being the first option to either carry, or then clear out the ruck. Had Damian McKenzie in his crosshairs all match, and made sure the All Blacks fly-half was alway under immense pressure.

5 Alex Coles – 7.5
Packed down at No.6 again, as he did against Australia, and brought an all-court game. His long pass from a maul showed his blossoming distribution game and how well he fits into England’s system. Proved to be a real nuisance at times as well, particularly at the lineout. Body shape was wrong at one point to be held up over the line as England wasted yet another try-scoring opportunity in the open half-hour – the one negative of an otherwise fine display.

6 Ollie Chessum – 9
Patrolled the left flank as he did against the Wallabies, and no one was stopping him from smashing his way over for England’s bonus-point try minutes into the second half. England’s go-to at the lineout again, and caused relentless problems for the All Blacks on their own throw. His hit on Scott Barrett in the closing stages to dislodge the ball summed up the day for both sides.

7 Ben Curry – 7.5
After Lewis Moody lined up with England to face the Haka, Curry channelled the spirit of the Mad Dog, throwing his body into tackles and rucks with reckless abandon. Had made the most tackles of any England player when he was replaced on 53 minutes.

8 Ben Earl – 9.5
33, yes, 33 tackles for England, with eight defenders beaten, two line breaks and 138 metres carried to go with them. Played with fast feet right at the line to disrupt the All Blacks’ defence, and his carrying was by far the most damaging it has been all November. With that said, there wasn’t too much sophistication to his try in the first half, as he simply barrelled over Cam Roigard from the base of the scrum. As close to a 10 as a player could possibly get – Ben Earl carried and tackled like he was running on rocket fuel.

Replacements
16 Luke Cowan-Dickie – 7
Stuttered in the lineout slightly, with one stolen five metres from the All Blacks’ line, but brought plenty of threat, not least a clean turnover at the breakdown in England’s 22 when the All Blacks were looking to claw their way back into the game.

17 Ellis Genge – 8.5
Added some wild ferocity to the closing 20 minutes with some carries leaving tacklers in black scrambling to ground him. His carrying only helped take England up another level in the second half, and his clean break resulted in England’s fifth try a few phases later. Even chipped in with a scrum penalty.

18 Will Stuart – 8
Part of a strong scrummaging effort in the final 15 minutes as England looked to twist the knife, winning two scrum penalties.

19 George Martin – 6
Added invaluable and unparalleled physicality in the closing quarter, but was removed for an HIA which limited his game time.

20 Greg Fisilau – 7
Brought pure carnage from the bench last week against Japan, but wasn’t as effective this week, as expected. Conceded a penalty for not wrapping in the tackle when England had the All Blacks trying to attack from deep in their half. Had a strong carry deep into the All Blacks’ half late on, swatting away tacklers at will.

21 Henry Pollock – 6
On the wing again for England but simply could not get involved in the action as hard as he tried late on – he may have a few words with Fisilau with the Saints free and on hand following a break.

22 Ben Spencer – 7
The perfect man to bring on for the final 15 minutes, managing the game adroitly.

23 Marcus Smith – 7.5
Given 25 minutes to bring the win home for England, and started with a penalty kick to settle in. Put Atkinson in for England’s fifth with a short pass right at the line.

Related

Nations Championship

Watch Hemispheres collide as North faces South in the Nations Championship. Live matches, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV here

(*USA only)

HSBC SVNS returns to Cape Town this December!

Don't miss your chance to see the world’s best rugby teams take centre stage 5-6 December in Cape Town.

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

14 Comments
c
cnw 19 mins ago

Well done England, just too good.

H
Hammer Head 26 mins ago

It’s a very rare occasion for me to shout for England.


And what a performance from them. Great game.

T
Tom 6 mins ago

💖

D
DP 27 mins ago

Stuffed. Loved it. Well done England. Earl put in a clinic for a no.8. Been putting in big shifts for years and walks always with a MOTM in a record win against New Zealand. So good.

C
ColinK 27 mins ago

Well played England, I would say they were superb. Sad days for my beloved team we will need to try and find a way back from an error ridden approach. We need to start by picking the young guys not the endless stream of veterans. In the end though England were just a lot better than us no excuses.

T
Tom 32 mins ago

Murley 9?!


He butchered several attacks single-handed. He did do a few good things in fairness but nowhere near a 9.


England FINALLY have a world class centre partnership after 23 years.


Earl, Chessum, Genge awesome. Jamie silenced the critics.


My one criticism is a few too many attacking kicks creeping back in, I felt there were several times where we were impatient in attack and coughed up possession when we could have taken an extra phase.


It's funny because some people complained about the caveats being given on the Australian and Japanese wins but unfortunately there's still the same caveat, the ABs were poor. Huge credit to England though they played great.

c
cnw 16 mins ago

England looked great - finding their potential. Mix of youth and experience, power and pace. ABs never in it.

L
Lucas98 34 mins ago

Ben Earl 31 tackles? Are you mad?

M
MH 34 mins ago

Ben Earl unreal, Slade getting better with age and a demolition job from big red and itoje

T
Tom 32 mins ago

The big difference with Slade is England are playing to his strengths for the first time.

f
fl 39 mins ago

31 carries for Earl, no?

L
LE 29 mins ago

I was surprised, if it was 31 of both he deserves a 10

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close