Northern | US

LONG READ 'They’ve become folk heroes' – Ireland’s plan to neutralise two of South Africa’s biggest weapons

'They’ve become folk heroes' – Ireland’s plan to neutralise two of South Africa’s biggest weapons
7 hours ago

“You can’t have one team with a really good scrum and try to legislate them out of it,” Mike Ross told me, before adding a question of his own. “How about you guys just get a bit better?”

HSBC SVNS returns to Cape Town this December!

Don't miss your chance to see the world’s best rugby teams take centre stage 5-6 December in Cape Town.

It was the Monday after Ireland had been clipped, clumped and trod upon by a punishing Springbok pack. Irish supporters had howled and jeered, on previous Saturday, as the Boks sought to scrum their side back to the stone age. It had been a humbling night.

Among the suggestions offered up on social media, podcasts, opinion pieces and national airwaves, were forcing straight scrum feeds (necessitating attacking’s hooker to hook), awarding free-kicks for airborne knock-ons and not allowing teams to select ‘scrum’ when they won a scrum penalty. The island was scrambling for answers and Ross, an Irish tighthead of some renown, was the voice of reason. Get busy. Get better.

As soon as the final whistle sounded, in Dublin, on November 22nd 2025, most rugby fans were aware the rematch had already been booked in. Three hundred and sixty four days later, same place, slightly different line-ups, new silverware on the line. Ireland have had a year to batten down the scrummaging hatches. The storm is nearly here. Time, and set-pieces, will tell if their defences hold out.

“I want to be the next Ox. I want to be the next Malcolm”

Andrew ‘Tank’ Lanning has been coaching young, hopeful scrummagers for as long as he can care to remember. It was always a privilege – feeding into that South African love of forward grunt. He is a scrum mentor at the Stormers Institute, in Stellenbosch, and scrum coach to the Stormers U20s side. Work, for the longest time, was gruelling and far away from the spotlight. In recent years, though, he has become busier and busier. Scrum dogs are now superstars.

“Scrummaging is a huge part of the Springboks culture, now,” says Lanning. “I’ve got young guys, 13 and 14 years old, coming in to me who, in the old days, wanted to be the next Danie Gerber, Jean de Villiers, Schalk Burger or Duane Vermeulen. I promise you, I’ve got Laaities (youngsters) coming in saying, ‘I want to be the next Ox Nché. I want to be the next Malcolm Marx’. They have become folk heroes.

“The Bomb Squad also played a huge part of that. Rassie bringing on six forwards at once. Young players see that and want to be the next Bomb Squad.”

Ireland v <a href=
South Africa scrum” width=”8017″ height=”5029″ /> Ireland and South Africa have had many titanic tussles but the Boks have the upper hand in the power stakes (Photo Matthias Hangst/Getty Images)

“I started a scrum school, about six years ago,” he adds, “because I saw that many coaches did not have the time to do the individual work. I’ve got guys coming to me, now, that are under nine or under 10, which, personally, I think is ridiculous. But that’s what the Springbok scrum has done.”

A keen student of the scrum, Lanning notes how Argentina – with their Bajada (eight-man push) techniques – had the early jump on rival nations. The pack as a brotherhood is something that has gained momentum due to law changes, elsewhere. “In South Africa,” Tank explains, “there has always been forward dominance and basing the game around gaining the advantage, there. Since they brought in the driving maul from the lineout, the easiest way for the Boks to get a penalty is through the scrum. Then, you kick for the corner and go for the driving maul. That has become so unbelievably massive in the last 10, 12 years. It has been very much ingrained in our rugby culture.

“Another thing that is very much a part of South African culture, certainly with the Afrikaans, is just the sheer size of players. These Afrikaans boys are on the farm – they’re basically born eating meat, carrying huge straw bales around and working on the farm.”

If you were designing your perfect prop and put all your points into scrummaging, that’s what you’d get with Wilco Louw

Mike Ross, former Ireland prop

In rugby’s professional era, Lanning feels Os du Randt was the first superstar scrummager for South African fans. Tendai Mtawarira, who converted from flanker to prop, was the next to draw acclaim for his dismantling of the British & Irish Lions scrum, in 2009. Du Randt and Mtawarira could shift around the park, if needs be. Lanning has noted how, since World Rugby pushed for loose- and tighthead cover on the replacements bench, props can now be ‘less mobile scrummaging animals’ that don’t need to go the full 80 minutes.

“If you were designing your perfect prop,” Ross proclaimed, last year, “and put all your points into scrummaging, that’s what you’d get with Wilco Louw.”

Louw, tipping the scales at 135 kilos, is the prototypical scrummaging animal Lanning refers to. He is not the only one at the disposal of Rassie Erasmus and his coaching staff. When Ireland faced the Boks in Dublin last November, their starting pack (916kgs) was 32 kilos lighter than South Africa’s. In Paris, last week, the world champions had a 64 kilos advantage over France, who gave up eight scrum penalties.

Wilco Louw
South Africa have props who are revered for their size and power, like the 22st man mountain Wilco Louw (Photo Jean Catuffe/Getty Images)

Lanning tries to put into simple words how much having a heavier pack can mean when both sides pack down. “64 kgs,” he exclaims. “Imagine that. It’s massive. That’s eight kgs per forward. It makes a huge difference, especially down the tighthead side. Wilco is a monster. Depending on whether he has had his lunchtime steak, or not, Wilco is between 135 to 140. The Boks love a big tighthead lock, so another 120kgs. If the right-hand side flank is hovering around 118 to 120, you are talking about 360 to 370kgs coming down one side of the scrum. The opposition loosehead has his side on the outside of the tighthead. If you can get your angle and your height right, it is unbelievable the difference it can make.”

Quality of opposition is crucial, too. Iron sharpens iron. While the likes of Andrew Porter and Tadhg Furlong are going up against the likes of Sam Illo and Tom O’Toole in training, the Boks have a seemingly endless conveyor belt of apex scrummagers. “When (Stormers tighthead) Neethling Fouché spent some time with the Springboks,” says Lanning, “he obviously had to earn his stripes. He was always in the pack that was scrumming against Ox and Wilco. He told me, ‘It was flippin’ tough’. You have 16 of the best forwards in South Africa, but the reserve pack is always that bit lighter. Every kilo counts.”

Ireland will be seeking to do all in their power to minimise the amount of scrums that referee Christopher Ridley and his touch judges have to oversee, on Saturday. France and New Zealand proved adept, in recent clashes, at quick scrum feeds that spewed the ball out before the Boks pack could get to work. Jamison Gibson-Park and Craig Casey will have been flat-out trying to replicate that, in training, all throughout this Nations Championship window.

Ireland usually love sending up contestables, but do not be surprised if Gibson-Park and Sam Prendergast send their kicks longer. Aerial knock-ons, by either side, are not what they are after. Irish jumpers will be told, if they do not think they can make a clean catch, to swat balls back. All scrums cannot be avoided, though. Ireland are aided by having Joe McCarthy in their second row. They will be buoyed by Porter, Furlong and Illo winning multiple scrum penalties in recent games, while acknowledging Saturday’s assignment will be a grisly as they come.

Tadhg Furlong Andrew Porter
Tadhg Furlong and Andrew Porter will be expected to pass the ‘alpha’ test against the Springboks on Saturday (Photo Hans van der Valk/Getty Images)

Irish supporters are realistic. Parity may be a pipe dream. However, if the Irish pack can minimise the Springbok scrummaging impact, the home crowd, and team, will feel they have a chance.

“I’d like to think I’m more of a ball-player”

There will be pitched battles and personal jousts taking place in all corners of Aviva Stadium, this weekend.

Drilling into a clash of partnerships, it will be fascinating to see who gets the upper-hand between the veteran midfields. Stuart McCloskey and Robbie Henshaw (combined age of 67) are set to face off against Jesse Kriel and Damian de Allende (66). The four men have been around several blocks, and have been knocked off several more.

McCloskey, in the form of his life at 34, is relishing the challenge. “Damian De Allende will probably go down as one of the best 12s to have played the game,” he says. “In general, though, we’ve always had a pretty good, even contest, whenever we play each other.”

“I played against De Allende and Kriel a couple of times,” he adds, “then played against Damian a few other times, when he was at Munster. They’re very physical. De Allende is such a workhorse, with the amount of carries he gets through, the damage he does in breakdowns, and defensively. That’s his key.

Damian de Allende Jesse Kriel
Stuart McKloskey and Robbie Henshaw will be enlisted in keeping, arguably, the world’s best centre partnership, Jesse Kriel and Damian de Allende quiet (Photo Steve Haag/Getty Images)

“We’re slightly different, that way. People would assume that I love doing that, as well. And, yeah, I do a bit of it but I’d like to think I’m a bit more of a ball-player than he is. He does some of the physical stuff a bit better. I’d love to be at his level, in terms of that. He is a great player.

“Kriel, then, is just an athlete. He’s probably one of the best athletic 13s you’ll ever see. He’s still got the break in him and, like all the South African team, he’ll make the breakdown an absolute nightmare.”

Register your interest to receive priority updates on RWC27 ticket releases. Don't miss out, stay in the loop!


Comments

0 Comments
Be the first to comment...

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT