Northern | US

LONG READ 'A bad day at the office, or did Wales expose fundamental All Blacks problems?'

'A bad day at the office, or did Wales expose fundamental All Blacks problems?'
7 hours ago

These days with the All Blacks, it’s all about trajectory more than results. That effectively means the All Blacks are judged more by vibes than they are win ratios, but this is how it is after former coach Scott Robertson was axed earlier this year.

HSBC SVNS returns to Cape Town this December!

Don't miss your chance to see the world’s best rugby teams take centre stage 5-6 December in Cape Town.

Robertson delivered a 74% win rate, but according to New Zealand Rugby chair, David Kirk: “We weren’t seeing the trajectory that we wanted and fans will probably share that view that there were things in the way we were playing and ways we were falling short of the excellence that we were looking for that never really got addressed over the year.”

This brave new world of being judged by gut feel rather than cold, hard statistics is good news for incumbent coach Dave Rennie who has presided over seven wins and four losses for a 64% win ratio since he took over in March.

It’s a low return by the standards set by any of his peers and seeing that number against the 87% of Steve Hansen, the 85% of Graham Henry and 82% of John Mitchell, it doesn’t look great.

Dave Rennie
There are positive signs in the early throes of Dave Rennie’s rein, but his win rate does not yet stack up to those of his predecessors (Photo by Dan Mullan/Getty Images)

But there are mitigating factors. Rennie was only given the job in March at a time when he was coaching in Japan and so had to pick the team remotely and try to sort out his coaching team and management group from afar.

He was also handed one of the most brutal and demanding schedules of the professional age – starting with a Test apiece against France then Ireland before taking on an eight-game tour of South Africa that included four Tests with the last one in Baltimore, USA.

Then came a two-Test Bledisloe series before the final leg of the Nations Championship. It’s not a longer itinerary than any handed to his predecessors, but the tour of South Africa was enormously physically and mentally demanding.

These are not excuses – just facts – and they form some of the context in trying to understand how it was the All Blacks, ranked second in the world, ended up losing to 10th-placed Wales.

It will be one of the great sporting mysteries, best attributed to an incredibly brave and resilient performance by Wales. Sport does this – it throws up great and inspiring stories, and this one was as good as they come: written off Wales, given no chance, stun the All Blacks with a performance of a lifetime.

So was the Welsh defeat simply a mad day at the office, or a sign of there being something more fundamentally wrong with the All Blacks that was not previously realised until Wales exposed it?

No-one saw this result coming. There was not a shred of evidence Wales could compete the way they did and it begs the question about what to think of the All Blacks’ trajectory.

Ahead of the game in Cardiff, there was confidence they were on the right track – despite the 3-1 series loss to South Africa – picking the right players, playing the right brand of rugby and executing it well. They were attacking sharply – scoring more tries than they did in either 2024 and 2025 – had a developing kicking game and they seemed united and tight, with underlying respect for the coaching group.

So was the Welsh defeat simply a mad day at the office, or a sign of there being something more fundamentally wrong with the All Blacks that was not previously realised until Wales exposed it?

Rennie appeared to subscribe to the former when he fronted media in London. “We picked a very good side, and a side that I was really confident that if we played to our potential, would perform well,” he said.

“It wasn’t a lack of effort but our ability to do the obvious is our point of difference and a lot of stuff that we’re showing is six-on-twos and five-on-twos or a short ball to someone in a hole who has got no one in front of him.

New Zealand struggled to find the killer touch to capitalise on a glut of possession and territory in Cardiff (Photo by Jan Kruger – Nations Championship/Nations Championship via Getty Images)

“There were probably 10 or so of those examples. It may be under pressure they just became real tunnel-visioned and carried into contact and didn’t do the obvious, so we talked about that.”

Rennie’s assessment was his team created enough opportunity to win the game but were inexplicably bad at capitalising on it. The incredible resistance of the Welsh defence also heaped the pressure on, and the All Blacks, who had made 10 changes to their team from the week before, melted down.

And, maybe, when Ethan de Groot, Codie Taylor, Fabian Holland, Tupou Vaa’i, Cam Roigard, Damian McKenzie, Jordie Barrett and Will Jordan are recalled for the England game, the All Blacks return to their winning ways and reset their trajectory.

But to shift away from vibes for a second and look more closely at the data, it tells a story that can’t be denied.

It would be financially catastrophic to ditch Super Rugby and go it alone, but does it make high-performance sense to continue to work with the Australians who show little sign of improvement?

The All Blacks have seen a win ratio of 87% between 2010 and 2019 drop to 72% between 2020 and 2026. In the past six years the All Blacks have also endured an historic first loss to Argentina (they have subsequently lost two more times to the Pumas) and a first loss to Wales in 73 years. The win ratio against South Africa since 2020 is 28%, against France and Ireland it is 57% and against England it is 50%.

Also, the demise of the New Zealand Under-20s team has been telling. From being untouchable when the tournament first began in 2008, New Zealand are now struggling to keep up with South Africa, England and France. Victories came in 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2015 and 2017 – but no titles have come since then and on two occasions in the last eight years, New Zealand haven’t made the semi-finals.

It has had a high-performance meltdown of sorts, with NZR just about admitting as much having made the decision to totally restructure the department and bring in heavy hitters Don Tricker, Conrad Smith and Michael Collins. These three may well preside over improved communication between all parties and build tighter, better flagged pathways for elite players. Their idea to amalgamate the Blues with Auckland, and all the other major urban unions with their respective Super Rugby clubs, may prove inspired.

The question, though, will remain whether New Zealand’s elite players are being exposed to a tough enough professional competition.

The decision has already been made to reject a plan to blow up Super Rugby and build a 10-team domestic professional competition and instead continue with things as they are. NZR says the 10-team proposal would have increased the player wage bill by $33m and dropped the value of broadcast rights to leave the national body with a $40m annual deficit.

It would be financially catastrophic to ditch Super Rugby and go it alone, but does it make high-performance sense to continue to work with the Australians who show little sign of improvement?

Super Rugby Pacific may not provide the same strength of competition as the previous iterations which included South African franchises (Photo by PA)

Again, sticking to the facts, no Australian side has ever won a play-off game in New Zealand, and none of the Waratahs, Reds or Force have been consistently good enough to regularly beat Kiwi teams in the last four years. The Brumbies have been the exception, but they fell away this year.

New Zealand’s high-performance decision-makers say, however, that the country’s elite players need a level between NPC and the All Blacks and that Super Rugby is best-placed to operate as that bridge. The question was put to Rennie as to whether he was supportive of a continuation of the current system, and if so, why.

He said: “Yeah. I am. I think NPC is crucial and I reckon it is our point of difference. There are a lot of countries in the world that would like to have a semi-pro competition like we do and as we can see there is a constant stream of kids coming through who end up going into a Super Rugby comp that we also need for the step up into international rugby.

“In the old days when you had African teams in there and you had to deal with the travel and the attitude and all the other things that go with it, it was a real high-quality competition.

“Now it is more trans-Tasman and probably not quite what it was, but it is probably the best we can do at the moment.

“I know there were lots of thoughts about how do we get some cross-over games or how do we bring other teams in. I am not sure how likely it is but there would be two, three or four Japanese clubs keen to join the competition at some stage and that may allow us to pick players from that competition because you are comparing apples with apples.

“Financially there needs to be some planning done but I think it is the right decision to keep both those competitions.”

The All Blacks can’t afford, long-term, for there to be a divergence between their results and trajectory and Super Rugby needs to start making a definitive case it is the right vehicle for New Zealand’s elite players.

World Rugby Rankings now in the RugbyPass App

NEW IN THE APP: Official World Rugby Rankings hub! Compare team rankings side-by-side, with data going back 20 years.

Download the RugbyPass app on the App Store (iOS) and Google Play (Android) now!

Comments

3 Comments
R
Rugby3 5 mins ago

Wow, such a lack of self awareness.


Rennie’s record is actually flattered by playing a second string French team and a weak confused Australian team that is being crippled by three assistant kiwi coaches. Yes that’s right, kiwi coaches from the land of amazing …..apparently.


Then to top it off, kiwis are now complaining that Australian Super Rugby teams are not providing strong enough competition for NZ teams, after years and years and years of hopeless kiwi coaches dragging Australian rugby down. Just wow.


What NZ rugby lacks, is being challenged by innovative, exciting, highly intelligent, thinking Australian coaches challenging kiwi teams to improve and be better. NZ rugby has been obsessed about undermining Australian rugby for some two decades and yet are now complaining we are not strong enough. Fair dinkum !


Wake up to yourselves bros.

B
Bazzallina 11 mins ago

Bit of both Gregor and credit to Wales..no sides are immune to this.

I just hope it doesn’t make Renz hesitate on continuing to make calls with selections and go to conservative assuming Jordan don’t play

Grooter Codie Tosi

Lord Holland

Tupou V Lakai Segner

Cam Richie

Jordie Reiko

Fehi Dmac Fihaki


Aumua Bower Newell Scooter Wallace Preston Leicester Moorby


I’m packing the bench with some of the big hitters and giving some class dudes in Richie Leicester backing to do their thing

E
EvilMockingJay 18 mins ago

This New Zealand coach has simply forgotten the foundation of rugby : respect. He fielded an average team thinking "it's Wales, it will be easy" and he was punished. It's a good thing the Welsh reminded him of that.

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Watch Nations Championship - Round 5 LIVE

close

Hemispheres collide in the new Nations Championship. Stream live, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV.

Watch on RPTV
Starts 4th July 2026 - USA only.