Springboks player ratings vs Ireland | Nations Championship 2026
South Africa player ratings: The Springboks have suffered back-to-back losses for the first time in four years, falling 20-17 to Ireland at the Aviva Stadium, but doing enough to finish top of the Nations Championship southern hemisphere conference.
It was a disappointing end to a turbulent week for South Africa, with Rassie Erasmus suspended and therefore absent from the stadium following the fallout from the defeat to France, while Jasper Wiese’s ban forced Cameron Hanekom into the No.8 jersey.
There had been plenty of noise on the Irish side too, particularly surrounding Sam Prendergast after his citing was dismissed during the week, adding another layer of intrigue to a fixture that has developed into one of Test rugby’s fiercest rivalries in recent years.
It was certainly Ireland that showed the most fire and passion, and controlled the majority of the first half to go in at the break with a 17-10 lead.
Despite deploying the Bomb Squad early on, the Boks just couldn’t fight back in another gritty second half. here’s how the players rated:
15 Damian Willemse – 4
Frequently found himself in no-mans-land defensively, and while it was a tough job with the way the Boks defend, his decision-making was questionable at best. Only managed 25 minutes before leaving the field injured.
14 Kurt-Lee Arendse – 5
Did not necessarily receive the volume of ball he would have wanted, but remained a threat whenever South Africa shifted possession wide. His counter attack from deep and pass was one of the moments that helped the Boks claw their way into the match when Ireland were dominating early on. His pace kept Ireland honest defensively and his work chasing kicks was relentless, but he probably came off second best in the air.
13 Jesse Kriel – 5
Frantically flew out the throughout the match to try and minimise any Irish width, but the high-risk strategy wasn’t always effective. Carried hard and straight but to little effect, and knocked the ball on at the death.
12 Damian de Allende – 6
Took plenty of stopping with his direct carries and repeatedly dragged defenders into contact, creating opportunities for those around him. Added several subtle touches with the ball and it was no coincidence that the Boks’ performance improved as he touched the ball more, and operated as a No.9 to put Malcolm Marx in for his second-half try. Left the field for an HIA for the final 15 minutes, which was match-defining.
11 Ethan Hooker – 5
Was not able to get the better of Robert Baloucoune aerially and was largely anonymous in attack with the Boks being starved of the ball. The Irish attack went down his left flank a lot, but he didn’t necessarily make any defensive mistakes.
10 Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu – 4
A strong response was needed a disappointing evening in Paris last week, and the Boks didn’t get that. Maybe tried too hard early on, hitting a cross-field kick too hard and just couldn’t get his side ticking. An inside pass to no one at point summed up a real lack of cohesion. Stepped up with a huge defensive play to hold up Dan Sheehan when Ireland on the hour mark when the hosts looked destined to score, in what was a positive.
9 Morne van den Berg – 5
Was the beneficiary of a unstoppable scrum to score the world champions’ opening try by basically dotting the ball over the line. That came after perhaps looking flustered early on, but his service was sharp and he repeatedly identified opportunities around the fringes when Ireland became preoccupied with stopping South Africa’s forwards, chiefly his break early in the second half when linking with Pieter-Steph du Toit. Needed to play the full match and seemed out of ideas when he ran into his own player when South Africa were desperately searching for a try late on, and then produced an aimless pass.
1 Ox Nche – 5
In a week where he was described as “one of the best looseheads to have ever played the game” by Eben Etzebeth, he was not at his brutal best. Strong at scrum time mostly, but it didn’t all go his way, with Tadhg Furlong getting the better of him shortly before the 30 minute mark.
2 Malcolm Marx – 6
Conceded an early penalty to add to the pressure on his side as Ireland eventually score, but otherwise an imposing presence throughout. Didn’t have a lot of success at the breakdown, and was pinged by Christophe Ridley. But his try just before the hour mark was a real momentum shift, but he didn’t last much longer before leaving the field injured. Another injury that damaged the world champions.
3 Wilco Louw – 6
Absolutely destructive at scrum time, which, in truth, kept the Boks in the game in the first half. After giving away a free-kick for the first scrum, he got motoring thereafter, winning a penalty within the first five minutes and then a huge shunt five metres from the Boks’ line. Got through a respectable eight tackles before being removed early in the second half, having just conceded a penalty for going straight off his feet at a ruck. He looked shell-shocked at the pressure his side were under.
4 Eben Etzebeth – 7
Made his first appearance of November after missing the opening two matches and immediately reminded everyone what South Africa had been without. Brought enormous physicality to the collisions, particularly his kick chase, and seemed particularly determined to impose himself early. Charged down Jamison Gibson-Park in the final 10 minutes only to be pinged for offside. First match in a while, and was probably South Africa’s best player.
5 Franco Mostert – 6
A late addition to the squad following Ruan Nortje’s withdrawal, but there was no indication of disrupted preparation in his performance, and made a match-leading 15 tackles in the first half alone. Worked tirelessly during his time on the field.
6 Siya Kolisi – 5
Picked up a few scraps when the Boks’ play got quite loose, but found himself outplayed by his opposing back-row without being able to really impose himself either side of the ball.
7 Pieter-Steph du Toit – 7
Continually hammered Irish carriers behind or around the gainline and remained a threat himself when South Africa moved the ball wider. His half-break at the breakdown was the catalyst for a stronger second half. His capacity to repeat high-intensity efforts remains extraordinary, making 13 tackles before being forced from the field.
8 Cameron Hanekom – 6
Asked to replace the banned Jasper Wiese and seized his opportunity and showed his worth in the opening quarter, preventing Baloucoune from scoring with a last ditch effort over the line and winning a penalty over the ball. Made 10 tackles and two turnovers in his 47 minutes on the field, but didn’t impose himself with his carries. Nevertheless one of the Boks’ stronger performers in the first 50 minutes. Came on soon after to replace the injured Du Toit, and looked busier in attack.
Replacements
16 Jan-Hendrik Wessels – 3
Butchered his first throw moments after replacing Marx in the final 20 minutes, and then his next throw was not straight. A poor introduction to the match. His lineout throwing did get steadier, but his penalty in the dying stages for being offside when he carried at the breakdown summed up his display.
17 Gerhard Steenekamp – 5
Couldn’t get the better of the Irish scrum initially, but helped win a big penalty in the final 15 minutes when the Boks were pinned in their half.
18 Thomas du Toit – 5
Couldn’t really turn the Bok scrum into the force it can be and was penalised at the breakdown soon after coming on to give Ireland their first points of the second half. Gave away a free-kick at one scrum before eventually winning a penalty.
19 Lood de Jager – 6
Brought experience and authority to the second-row during the closing stages, with some effective nice carries and offloads when he got his hands on the ball. Did his best to help the Boks, but not enough.
20 Paul de Villiers – 6
Quick around the field, aggressive defensively and eager to make an impression at the breakdown, winning a huge penalty over the ball in his own half.
21 Marco van Staden – 3
Immediately attacked the breakdown and brought fresh aggression to South Africa’s defensive effort which helped pick up their performance, but his yellow card for his reckless and late clearout at the ruck was totally unnecessary.
22 Grant Williams – 4
Called upon on the wing this week after De Allende’s injury and was penalised for being offside just minutes later (although the penalty was cancelled). Didn’t do a lot else.
23 Canan Moodie – 5
Thrown into action in the first half, and ignited the match for the Boks with his kick and chase to the corner which had the Boks camped deep in the Irish half, with their first try eventually coming. Conceded the penalty that give Ireland their kick to the corner before half time, then was stepped by Ronan Kelleher at close range as Ireland scored their third. A poor couple of minutes. Then came close to scoring early in the second half, only to be denied by the touchline.

Watch Hemispheres collide as North faces South in the Nations Championship. Live matches, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV here
(*USA only)

