A bittersweet Welsh joke when the national side is preparing for an upcoming game against the mighty All Blacks: the coach leads the players out on to the training paddock. He stops and says, ‘Okay boys, take up your usual positions.’ Without pausing to think, the players trot to the far end of the field and huddle underneath the goalposts. Some are already looking up to see Beauden Barrett or Richie Mo’unga popping over the conversion in their mind’s eye.
HSBC SVNS returns to Cape Town this December!
Don't miss your chance to see the world’s best rugby teams take centre stage 5-6 December in Cape Town.
That is the kind of black humour which always circulates around the M4 corridor, and gushes up and down the valleys of South Wales when New Zealand comes to town. I remember the two times they came closest to victory clearly. At the old Arms Park in 1978, Wales were without Gareth Edwards and Phil Bennett but the rest of the Grand Slam-winning side was intact. Wales led 12-10 when English referee Roger Quittenton awarded a penalty to the All Blacks after Frank Oliver and Andy Haden catapulted out of the final lineout. Brian McKechnie kicked a nerveless goal to win the match.
“I knew straightaway that it was a con job. When we found out later that they had planned it the night before, that really got to me. I’ll never forget that as long as I live,” said Pontypool, Wales and British & Irish Lions hooker Bobby Windsor in the aftermath.
The dinner table at the after-match function was shared by players from both teams. ‘Can you pass the salt and pepper?’ Haden enquired of Wales second-row Geoff Wheel sitting next to him. Wheel shoved the pots along. There was a momentary silence when they toppled over. ‘Where have I seen that before?’ mumbled the ‘Mumbles Ripper’. Black humour, see.

The second occasion was in November 2004, when I had graduated from fan to insider. I was working on Mike Ruddock’s staff at the time, previewing Wales’ opponents and helping build strategies against them. We lost agonisingly by one point, 25-26. We could have won the game.
With Wales four points adrift but weighing up a penalty inside the Kiwi 22 as the clock wound down, captain Gareth Thomas chose to take a kick for goal, which Gavin Henson landed, instead of opting to kick for the corner. “They really had the squeeze on us,” said rookie skipper Richie McCaw afterwards. “If they’d had a crack, God knows what would have happened.” God only knows, but at least Wales won the Grand Slam for the first time in 27 years the following season. That was some compensation.
The field may have been turned through 90 degrees, the old Arms Park has long since become the Principality Stadium, but the heroes of 1953 have at long last been honoured. For the first time in 73 years, Wales beat the All Blacks last weekend. That is truly a lifetime for most people.
For Wales it will mark a turning point, but it is only one step along the winding path back to rugby respectability. Head coach Steve Tandy is a grounded man of the Neath valley, a salt of the good Tonmawr earth. He will remember only too well that Wales lost their last two games against the world champion Springboks by a combined score of 116-0, home and away, within the last 12 months. Forget the weekend of tears and hysteria, they will have to wait for the cold light of day of a Monday morning. Tandy has built his rugby life around robust defence, not free-flowing attack.
Make no mistake, defence won the Red Dragons the game on Saturday afternoon, and that will also have a cascade effect on the future planning of All Blacks supremo Dave Rennie.
Back in 2018 he left for the far side of the world and pitched up in Australia, willing to work his way around the country for free. He finished as the defence coach of Super Rugby’s Waratahs, building ‘the blue wall’ in New South Wales, rather than his native South Wales. Upon his return, he was building another blue wall, this time of a darker hue for Gregor Townsend’s Scotland, for the next six years.
He was appointed defence coach for Warren Gatland’s ill-fated, mid-Covid Lions tour of South Africa in 2021. The mark of the Bok is upon him, and Tandy will never forget it. On his watch, there will be no new Wales without solid defensive foundations in place.
Make no mistake, defence won the Red Dragons the game on Saturday afternoon, and that will also have a cascade effect on the future planning of All Blacks supremo Dave Rennie. The intellectual backwash of this result will not go quietly into the good night. It will not be dismissed as a one-off, especially with England looming on the horizon at the Old Cabbage Patch in round six of the Nations Championship.

Rennie’s comments as the dust began to clear were very revealing: “It’s been a challenging couple of days post-game and again yesterday, it’s a very quiet group. That feeling, they know that we let ourselves down, we let the country down.”
“A lot of stuff we talked about wasn’t a lack of effort. Our ability to do the obvious is our point of difference, and a lot of stuff that we’re showing is six-on-twos and five-on-twos, and a short ball to someone in a hole [is on].
“He’s got no-one in front of him, and there were just probably 10 or so of those examples. Maybe under pressure, it just became real tunnel-visioned and carried into contact, and we didn’t do the obvious.
“So we talked about that. We’ve talked about the pressure guys felt, and confidence in our structure. That if we are really disciplined around that, then we’ll get the ball to space, wherever that space is.”
The interest level in those observations peaks sharply when juxtaposed with the reaction of chief forwards assistant Neil Barnes:
“There was actually a message at half-time that we wanted to go to the lineout drive a bit more. But sometimes, when you have a penalty five metres out from the goal-line, you’re running a risk of not even winning that ball.
“But the last one in particular, I know Jason Ryan was yelling out that we should be going to our driving maul. Personally? Yeah, I would have gone to the lineout maul.”
While the two forward coaches are talking about varying play with a driving lineout, the head man is still banging on about doing more with the ball in hand outside it. That conversation becomes even more fascinating when you look at the attacking stats Rennie’s All Blacks are generating after five rounds of Nations Championship play:

The All Blacks are so far ahead of the attacking curve – five minutes more time spent with ball in hand, 42 more rucks set above the average – that most of the other nations in the tournament can only watch their dust-trail in the far distance, and the same stats from the match in Cardiff were even more eye-watering:

Wales may have been compelled to make 353 tackle attempts over the 80 minutes, but they were never run off their feet and they were still completing at over 92% by the end of the match. 19 rucks per break, and 48 rucks per try are not efficient scoring averages. You can almost hear Rassie cackling in the background.
Over the last half-hour, the All Blacks deserted the close-range lineout maul, and they completely forgot that kicking the ball is just as progressive a way of exploiting space as running and passing. When does the notion of identity become an obsession? The loss to Wales raised a very red flag against the essence of the Rennie game-model.
In that last 30 minutes, the All Blacks were still making breaks, but they were making them a long way from the Welsh goal-line:
https://t.co/ypGU39Bzpl
— William Bishop (@RPvids1994) November 17, 2026
As soon as Wales were defending in their own half, they added an extra body to the line and left one solitary man in the backfield:

It is notoriously difficult to break down a 14-man defensive line with ball in hand, and the men in black did not achieve any significant line-breaks against that red-brick wall, nor did they launch any attacking kicks into the inviting spaces either side of the single backfield defender. The lack of basic game-intelligence was breathtaking, especially when you consider the combined experience of the two men in the starting spots at numbers 10 and 15:
https://t.co/OwaymnJdcu
— William Bishop (@RPvids1994) November 17, 2026
https://t.co/jfoHzZ0871
— William Bishop (@RPvids1994) November 17, 2026
https://t.co/2muXxHMryv
— William Bishop (@RPvids1994) November 17, 2026
By the end of the match, Wales were presenting their 14-man brick wall well beyond the halfway line, because they knew New Zealand would run through their shapes ball-in-hand without any balancing threat from the boot. Even when a break is made, the density of the 14-man line allows for ample recovery time in the first two clips on the next couple of plays.
Rennie’s ruck-and-run philosophy is in grave danger of foundering on the rocks of predictability. Against an obdurate Welsh defence cast in the mould of its head coach Tandy, the All Blacks enjoyed enough possession to win two games of rugby, let alone one.
But they never produced enough variety in the last half-hour – no attacking kicks, no drives from lineout – to earn the victory. Tandy outsmarted Rennie in the coaching box, and the leaders out on the field could not either alter or reverse the trends set in concrete during the second period.
With England up next, the New Zealand coaching staff will still be seeing red. And another troubadour from the Neath valley, Max Boyce, will be passing an unlikely triumph into rugby folklore for many years to come:
“There’s an old Welsh saying I like, that I should turn to song.
“That says, with just some simple words, that every wait is long.
“But now that wait is over and many tears are shed.
“When New Zealand were defeated, and the clock had turned to red.”
NEW IN THE APP: Official World Rugby Rankings hub! Compare team rankings side-by-side, with data going back 20 years.
Download the RugbyPass app on the App Store (iOS) and Google Play (Android) now!

First, huge congratulations to Wales who put in such a monumental yet clinical performance. I thought that they were much improved in the 6n without much reward and the young players blooded these past few years are maturing nicely.
Let’s not be surprised though if their performance next week is a big come down. That effort will have taken everything out of them.
Horrible performance by us though. As you say, incredible to see Mo'unga and BB so consistently fail to take the correct option when Love and DMac have driven the team so well, and the attack in general has been so effective all season. Cam and Jordie are the two players we can't afford to lose next year.
RM will need to show a marked improvement next year if he’s to challenge for selection.
Really good points:
Mo’unga did his reputation/chances a lot of harm in that Test. He has generally been a good thinker, rather than relying on being an especially gifted athlete.
Still, B Barrett should’ve been able to see the opportunities, sitting back at 15. Why wasn’t he communicating to Mo’unga. He was Captain he has the authority, it was his place to do so. That Test made both of them seem a bit second rate.
I’m not saying McKenzie would’ve gone better. He’s also an instinctive player. He’s had the benefit of Roigard and J Barrett supporting him this year.
It would’ve been interesting so see how Love would’ve gone e.g. coming on at half time (if he was fit), could he have turned it around?
It also would’ve been a great opportunity to see if Jacomb could be ‘chucked in the deep end and see if he swam’; e.g. put him at 10 in the second half and seeing if he could’ve turned it around. But that would’ve been a bit rough and probably not great player development.
Agree, they were badly missed. It just shows how much of the success that All Black 10s have shown this year is heavily related to the support of the 9 and 12.
I wonder if Tupaea at 12 would’ve been a better than having Lienert-Brown at 12?
Bloody good on Wales might have got a lil bit of the rub of green with ref but ultimately there discipline accuracy and effort on D was good stuff.
The ABs have been guilty of being predictable phase play many times over the pro era but what we can’t get away with now is just having the obviously better X factor dudes ( we have been blessed that way) as most sides can put out athletes in saying that ABs are lacking abit of that imo .
What I would like to see them do more is get more square when the come round the corner and look for a few more inside passes .
For Wales hope they can carry on playing well stink result for my beloved ABs but great for footy.
On to England big match for everyone involved ahead ( including many others great comp)
Thanks Nick
A different team and different tactics, but it reminds me of the Wallabies inability to crack the Scotish line too.
TBH we looked rudderless when we went 19 phases and didn't do anything
And even South Africa on Friday- obviously in a very high quality test.