Northern | US

Jake White: This All Blacks side lack something no NZ side has ever lacked


South Africa lock Eben Etzebeth #4 is tackled during a match between the New Zealand All Blacks and the South Africa Springboks at M&T Bank Stadium on September 12, 2026 in Baltimore, Maryland. (Photo by Roger Wimmer/ISI Photos/ISI Photos via Getty Images)
Comments
79 Comments

Well, that was a blast. What a series. As the dust finally settles, the first thing I’d say about Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry is that South Africa and New Zealand are clearly the two best teams in the world. That’s not even controversial. It’s stating the obvious.

Of course, the All Blacks getting off to a winning start in Johannesburg gave the series the perfect platform, but in the deciding Test, when Ardie Savea went off in the 31st minute, it appeared New Zealand’s hopes went with him.

So, what have we learnt? Well, firstly, the Springboks have shown their cojones again. Down 1-0 and with their backs against the wall, they showed their teeth and bulldozed their way to a 3-1 series win. For that, you have to give them immense credit.

As is often discussed, they have a clutch of ageing players, so to win three consecutive wins over three weekends shows their detractors that they still have the burning desire, and most importantly legs, to go the distance, because they’ll need to do just that in the World Cup knockouts.

There have been question marks raised in some quarters over the longevity of Pieter-Steph du Toit, Malcolm Marx, Jesse Kriel, Eben Etzebeth, Damian de Allende and even Deon Fourie, who is 40 in a week or so, but they’ve answered doubts unequivocally. They’ve gone to some dark places and come through the other side.

Fixture
Internationals
Australia
42 - 38
Full-time
South Africa
All Stats and Data

It’s funny, I was asked yesterday, what should the Springboks change? Well, I would say nothing. Without being arrogant, it’s for the chasing pack to catch up.

There are, of course, always going to be selection posers, for instance, who covers for Malcolm Marx at hooker? Could Ox Nche or Jan Hendrick-Wessels be converted over the next 12 months? Whoever it is, Rassie always seems to come up trumps. Whenever he unleashes a plan, it works. We openly pondered who would be the next top-quality scrum-half off the rank and then Morne van den Berg puts in a Player of the Match performance. He has had to bide his time, waiting behind Faf (de Klerk), Grant Williams and Cobus Reinach, but that’s what you have to do to get a Springbok cap.

Then there’s the flanks. Ethan Hooker’s ability under the high ball has provided the perfect counterbalance to the hot-stepping wingers, Cheslin Kolbe and Kurt-Lee Arendse. Rassie has interchanged positions and personnel very well, and fellow Test coach rained plaudits in his direction, and I agree. Fans and pundits are quick enough to castigate you, but when you get things right, you have to pat him on the back

What has impressed me is Rassie’s powers to motivate, time and time again, because there was no doubt they were chastened and under pressure after that first Test loss. He has to bottle that special sauce and use it to fire the players, staff, wider support group and even fans to lift that squad to new heights.

As for the All Blacks, we can justifiably say they’ve truly turned a corner, but what I’ve picked up from numerous commentators is them documenting how the Springboks have ‘made yards with every carry’. In living memory, I am struggling to remember when that has happened before. Sure, it happens to other sides, but not the All Blacks.

Now one of the key principles of rugby is to go forward, but it’s easier said than done with modern defences. That momentum allows you to put the defence under pressure. Look at Jasper Wiese, Ox Nche, Damian de Allende. They are all comfortable carrying straight and hard and it hurt New Zealand. A word for Jordie Barrett, however. Amidst the onslaught, I thought he was outstanding in defence. When they were on the back foot, they used their power to drive the All Blacks backwards, inch-by-inch, away from the try-line. To the naked eye, they don’t have the likes of Jonah Lomu, Jerome Kaino, Ma’a Nonu, Brodie Retallick or Tana Umaga to punch holes in the same way. Take that 32-phase try, finished off by Will Jordan. It was incredible, but it must have taken so much out of them. You can’t do that for 80 minutes. It’s too much. They need to find guys who can get post-contact metres. Maybe with Caleb Clarke and Leicester Fainga’anuku back in situ, they might have more punch.

As much as they’re making progress, they’re still chasing the Springboks’ tails. In the post-match interview, reporters asked Richie Mo’unga if this Springbok team was better than the 2023 World Cup vintage. His answer, ‘yes, they are incredibly good at creating pressure without the ball’. Kieran Read agreed, when he said, ‘they fight for everything on the ground. Every player goes hard at the breakdown, whether it’s the scrum-half, the hooker or the outside backs, they don’t give away any territory lightly’.

That’s a collective decision. A collective responsibility and collective physicality. It comes off the bench; it comes with rotation, and behind closed doors is most likely Rassie holding them to account. The secret for any coach is how you keep that burning desire on the field. I’ve coached against them and New Zealand used to have it in spades. The Jerry Collins, Sam Whitlocks and Richie McCaws gave you absolutely nothing. They were like Terminators. They just kept coming back. Those comments tell me Mo’unga was left feeling under the pump, and if you can make the 10 feel under pressure all the time, the whole game plan starts to shift in your favour.

Of course, it would be naïve to think the World Cup is a fait accompli because historically, there’s always been an upset or a curveball to upset the status quo, like New Zealand losing to France in Cardiff in 2007, but it’s clear these are the two sides who will have to be beaten on the way to the Webb Ellis Cup.

France are probably closest to challenging the world order because of their power and strength-in-depth and it is interesting to see there have been changes out there regarding limiting game time, and they are taking their assault on the trophy very seriously. On their day, they can beat anybody.

It’s funny, in 2006, I rested players and people told me I was crazy. Looking back, perhaps historically I could have had more wins in the ledger, but if the jewel in the crown is a shot at a World Cup, then so be it. The message is clear to the players; they are being put first, and there is a unified aim. That end-of-year Test will tell us how close Les Bleus are to breaking up the RGR hegemony.

I’d love to hear your thoughts. Can anyone break the South Africa-New Zealand axis of power?

Related

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

79 Comments
S
SC 28 days ago

One thing Jake White has absolutely correct is that this is the softest All Black pack we have seen since John Hart’s 1998 and 1999 team.

E
Eric Elwood 28 days ago

SA were playing win at all costs (see Test 2). NZ not so much. NZ have a lot more to learn and gain from that series.

M
Mid 28 days ago

You mean NZ had a devil-may-care, que sera sera approach to the RGR?


Are you on particularly strong medication?

A
Ayre123 None 29 days ago

The ABs were easily exposed lately by the ruthless Boks, they missed 5 or 6 kiwis in the line up😆

C
CG 29 days ago

Smugness is an exploitable. Weakness

See how good these beefed up bullet heads are without the ‘roids

P
Perthstayer 29 days ago

Why are there so few drug tests in South Africa than around the world? Of those that are taken they have the highest % failure rate.


The last 7-8 years Bokke have been remarkable, Rassie is remarkable. But the testing is a shadow.

L
Lou Cifer 29 days ago

Kriel & Marx are 32 Jake….not 42🙄


France can break that axis, but lack consistency when it matters. Ireland could be in with a shout, however there are quite a few BUTs….


England have the player base to challenge but aren’t picking their best & Borthers seems a bit lost….trend follower not setter as Doc Ras so cunningly mentioned

j
jH 29 days ago

ABs problem was there tactics. They decided to move the ball at all cost, to avoid the set piece, problem being as Jake said this takes a lot out of you and then you make mistakes, what happens then you have a scrum or the ball turned over.

ABs need to be a bit more confrontational, so selections are crucial

Tour showed up that Vaii is not an international lock, and sorry he is not a 6 either. Parker had a good 2nd test, never to be seen again.

Is Jacobson right for 7 most likely not, maybe Segner. Blackadder plays basically the same Wether at 6 or 7 as does Lakai.

So a forward pack with Lord or Darry with Holland at lock. Parker at 6 this strengthens the lineout, which to be honest was a shambles.

4th testcwe had Mounga playing, but he wasn’t the playmaker, same trap as Foster and Hansen fell into. Mounga is the quarterback let him run the show.

No penetration in midfield, ie linebreaker, maybe give Jim a go for 40.

Re the high ball, Jordy to FB, Jordan 1 wing, Clarke or Fihaki on the other.

C
CD older/wiser 29 days ago

What has Lord done, we must be desperate, there has to be better locks out there somewhere. Start picking the best, regardless of the province they represent.

B
Blackmania 29 days ago

I completely agree.

Rennie’s honeymoon period is over, and he’s going to have to be less stubborn about some of his choices.

All these coaches do seem to have an unfortunate tendency to become quite set in their ways, and then struggle to adapt when circumstances change. I think the status of some of the senior players is no longer justified: Taylor, Lomax, Vaa’i and McKenzie.

Jacobson has avoided that radar for now, but I think his margin for error is extremely thin compared with Blackadder, and especially Segner, who I see making a big push over the coming months.

There’s something else that concerns me, and I’ve mentioned it several times: the composition of the bench, with a centre and a winger who aren’t impact players. It makes absolutely no sense. It’s poorly constructed and brings nothing to the team.

I hope Faingaanuku’s return will change the situation.

And yes, we really do need more impact players, as J White points out. All Blacks who don’t give anything away. Some players are giving away far too much… You simply cannot accept a performance like Leroy Carter’s in Soweto. It’s not possible. That kind of performance completely undermines the team. You don’t need to give him a hug — just send him back to NPC and teach him how to tackle.

If the selectors excuse these kinds of mistakes and are satisfied with that level of performance, the All Blacks won’t get where they want to be. They need to be extremely demanding if they want to become the best in the world again.

I have faith in Rennie, but this is the first major warning sign.

T
Tooly 29 days ago

Will Rassie keep the ball rolling against Australia and Argentina or give a couple of mugs an even break ?

I suggest go hard and then relax in Europe .

L
Lou Cifer 29 days ago

That match up in France in November seems like a massive psychological showdown when you look at the bigger RWC 2027 picture….maybe a bit of both??

S
Spew_81 29 days ago

It goes back to the 2016-2019 RWC cycle. Hansen and Foster kept thinking it was all about fast, skilled players.


But brutal power is also needed. Especially to batter apart rush defenses. Also, if the play makers are B Barrett and McKenzie (2016-2019 RWC cycle). Both of them are far more effective when they beat the first defender and offload (rather than produce a ‘thread the needle’, miracle, pass). But rush defenses are really good at stopping the playmaker from beating the first tackle.


Getting a power runner to break/bend the line first, then offload to the playmaker is far more viable.


The All Blacks haven’t been able get their offloading game going. That is where they are at their most dangerous. That’s where they can run 50-80 meters and tire big packs out.


At least one of the midfield needs to be a power runner that offloads. If R Ioane was good at offloading, he and J Barrett would work together well. But R Ioane dies with the ball too often, and misses wide open outsides.


Yes, Tavatavanawai also has a tendency to dies with the ball. But he won’t get better without opportunities. Also, the raw power of Tavatavanawai is something that R Ioane lost about a decade ago, and A Lienert-Brown never had.

d
d 29 days ago

One thing that people keep forgetting is that a side that everyone agrees has a long list of things to be fixed, still took a match off the Boks at home. Now what does that say about the potential for these players under a coach that can fix even half of their flaws? My main concern is exactly what Jake has spelled out; this side simply don’t seem to have the steely resolve to be excellent, as evidenced buy a coaching team who want to blame everything on bad luck and bad refereeing.

P
PB 28 days ago

To be fair, the Boks showed incremental improvements in their game as the series went on. The Boks were very rusty in the 1st test, Rassie clearly gambled on losing that one in the gain of keeping his players fresher for the tests to come.

It paid off! The Boks have a few levels they can go up, and have some new players and injured players that can add strength and vigour to their RWC squad.

RG Snyman, Riley Norton for example

G
GrahamVF 30 days ago

For two hours, twice a week, for two years, I sat spellbound listening to Doc Craven speak. About the history of the Olympic games, about philosophy and life but mostly about rugby. And this is the simple take and I quote (More or less 🙃) “Rugby is a game about space. The team that owns the space own the game. In the lineout, in the carry, in the tackle. The team that own the most space wins nine out of ten times.”

Jake has put his finger on it. Man for man the Boks own more space than the All Blacks.

A
Alex 30 days ago

If I were France, I'd be loving this chat. To be underestimated is a brilliant thing

d
d 29 days ago

I’d still hate to be a french fan; no-one ever knows what version of France is going to turn up on the day.

O
OtagomanII 30 days ago

Not picking Tavatavanawai on the bench for the 4th test was a missed opportunity. Instead they gave another wasted cap to Barrett.

K
Kia koe 30 days ago

For me it is ALB who should be out. I just don’t get how two different head coaches have faith in this guy over and over. He is probably that player that trains incredibly well but plays badly. I get so frustrated when he gets in the 23

H
Hammer Head 30 days ago

A week is a long time in test rugby.


A year is eons.


The storybooks around this game, indeed every game and their fabled teams, are filled with drama.


What will make the Springboks story more dramatic and entertaining than a three-peat? Losing in a dramatic QF against the ABs. Something no-one saw coming. Or because of an Australian referee.


What would make the ABs story more fascinating than it has already been? Losing to France in a final, in Australia. Or winning the World Cup, when no-one expected it. Because of an Australian referee.


If there’s one thing I've realised following this great game, is to count your chickens after they’ve hatched and to expect edge of your seat drama.


Love it.

N
NoLongerARuck 29 days ago

Looks like you also realised not to trust Australian refs🤣

S
Spew_81 29 days ago

Agree, much can change in a year.


The Nations Cup finals in November will show really interesting insights for RWC 2027.

H
HS 30 days ago

I’d say that France should be able to beat NZ 7 out of 10 times if they both play their best teams.

C
Chiefs Mana 30 days ago

They don’t play together enough to have the cohesion to win consistently, brilliant on their day with no shortage of top players

H
Hammer Head 30 days ago

11 out of 20 times at best

D
DZ 30 days ago

I dont believe. All Blacks will fix their issues but france is overrated. Look at how They struggled to win 6 nations . All Blacks will beat them many things

S
SB 30 days ago

Realistically only France and to a lesser extent Ireland can keep up with numbers 1 and 2.


The series proved to the world just how good they are. Results aside, it was bone crunching rugby. Had the privilege of attending the Cape Town test and it was captivating throughout. Both teams have the ability to crank it up. What made it even more special is that they do so with very contrasting styles too, which as a spectator is magnificent to watch. Thoroughly enjoyed it. And the win off course 😜


Its such an incredible pity that they will most likely face off in the RWC 2027 quarter final. Criminal from WR if you ask me.

E
Eric Elwood 28 days ago

This was the fairest RWC draw format in the history of the RWC. Just because it definitely affects the big boys for once we are getting the hissy fit. Ireland and France supporters pointing out the farce of playing recent world champion teams in pool as well as quarter final were “Whingers”. Suck it up now.

S
Spew_81 29 days ago

All Blacks vs England in November will be very interesting. Also, All Blacks vs Scotland.

When on form England is a ‘viable’ contender. But they have been up and down over the last year or do.


The others being: Springboks, All Blacks, France, Ireland, Scotland and the Pumas (they do well at RWCs).


But Springboks are the clear, favorite.

H
Hammer Head 30 days ago

France are my number 2 in the world

T
TokoRFC 30 days ago

Agree SB it’s nuts they are facing off in a QF.


I’d say England on paper have the players to do it, especially if they select their French based players. But I don’t feel they are well coached

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close