Northern | US

'I guess they've earned that arrogance': Ex-All Black on Springboks supporters

South Africa line up for the anthems during the 2026 Nations Championship match between South Africa and Scotland. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)
Comments
35 Comments

Ex-All Black Justin Marshall has responded to the Springbok supporters laying claim to the favourites tag ahead of the Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry Test series, labelling the confidence “arrogance”, but stopping short of disputing its validity.

ADVERTISEMENT

Marshall said he was “really enjoying the banter” he’s been subjected to since touching down in South Africa as part of Sky Sport’s commentary team, with plenty of locals letting him hear their thoughts on the upcoming four-Test series.

Beyond the local interactions, he’d seen pundits and podcasts framing their predictions in a way that made the Springboks clear favourites.

VIDEO

Making his usual appearance on The Good, The Bad & Rugby Australia & New Zealand podcast this week, Marshall was asked by host Andy Rowe what the feeling was on the ground, and whether “they feel like we’ve got a chance”.

The question came after Rowe saw a headline along the lines of ‘Can the All Blacks beat the Springboks?’ and for Rowe, “that felt like a level of arrogance that I’m not used to as an All Blacks fan, from the opposition.”

“Valid question from you, Andy,” Marshall responded. “It’s good to see that you were upset, and rightly so. But, I guess they’ve earned that arrogance with their success; back-to-back World Cup champions, and equally, they have had the number on us over the past few encounters. So, they’re on the right side of the ledger to have that arrogance.

“Generally, the chat over here has been one of excitement about the Test series that’s coming up. But equally, in terms of how they see the All Blacks here, the success that they’ve had against the All Blacks recently has given them that ability to say that they feel they deserve to be the favourites.

ADVERTISEMENT

“A lot of the chat, with a slight tinge of arrogance about it as well, has been around if the All Blacks could draw the series, then that would be a result for the All Blacks. So, they are rubbing it in a little bit.”

Related

With New Zealand owning just one win in the last five games between the two teams and three of the tour’s four games being played on South African soil, there are plenty of factors leaning in the Springboks’ favour.

Kiwi pundits are hoping new All Blacks head coach Dave Rennie and his brains trust have some tricks up their sleeves, with word out of camp this week suggesting New Zealand will look to keep the aggressive South African defence on its toes.

Dave Rennie said on Tuesday that his squad will need to “play at our best and force them to be below their best”, a sentiment that Marshall agreed with when the former Test halfback was sharing his prediction for the weekend’s result.

ADVERTISEMENT

“This is what it’s about,” Marshall said. “This All Blacks team is capable of beating the world champions. We have to be perfect, we have to be at our best. They know that, the coaches know that, we all know that. But I’m really, really positive that we can be that team this weekend.”

Watch Rugby's Greatest Rivalry LIVE

Two rugby giants collide. Stream live, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV. 

Watch on RPTV

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

35 Comments
G
GRB13 26 days ago

That is laughable New Zealander’s are some of the most arongant rugby supporters there are in the sport. To be fair this has been lead from the pundits, the media and online comments. The arrogance since Razor has left has been second to none!

C
ColinK 26 days ago

I don’t see arrogance, like Hammer said I see confidence. Indeed the coaching staff have shown humility at times when referring to the All Blacks. I wish they were arrogant as it makes them harder to beat than when they are more grounded.

As for fans and pundits, well we have some idiots on both sides.

j
johnz 26 days ago

I don’t think you want your Boks being arrogant - as the saying goes, arrogance preceeds the fall.


That’s certainly what happened to NZ rugby through their perioed of relative decline and chronyism. Teams that become too arrogant stop innovating - not something I’ve seen with the Boks yet.


In fairness, the quote was taken out of context, as always. Marshall was refering to comments from pundits, rather than the Bok team itself.

p
proooooovince 26 days ago

This is for the parts of NZ media and fanbase who are supremely confident after the warm up games, and busy questioning if SA really has depth. I would argue that you can rank the expected strength of these sides in this way:

1- National A team

2- National B+ team with some A players

3- National B team

4- National Experimental team (mostly B players plus bolters) / Strongest club team

5- Club team missing A players

6- Club team missing A players out of season

7- Club B team


You can expect a side that is ranked only one level lower to challenge the next level, but of course they will not be favorites. Two levels below would really be an upset. Three levels starts to be supremely unlikely, and 4 is probably never going to happen.


I would estimate the NZ sides that played at around 2 or at worst 3 (although some would claim it was 4), and the URC sides were around 6. So no suprises for me at the results.


Also, what these people conveniently forget is the SA foreign legion. That is the equivalent of another strong URC side worth of Boks. I don't think when people are talking about the depth of South African rugby that they are talking about the depth of the Stormers or Bulls - quite the opposite, it is clear these sides cannot yet compete well in both the URC and Champions competitions at the same time. It's the Springbok depth that is looking good, when you take the best of the URC sides, and then add some quality and experienced players from Europe and Japan.


I can't wait for Saturday! I think the Springboks are favourites, certainly at home, but only by a touch. Never underestimate the All Blacks! 

j
johnz 26 days ago

I wouldn’t label us confident, in terms of believing we will win. Optimistic is a better word, which has been overused a bit in NZ at the moment - but it is the overiding feeling. Our team is clearly on an upward tragectory - something we haven’t seen for a long time. There’s still a mountain to climb on Saturday though.

D
Dean 26 days ago

Marshall🙄 He wrote the book on arrogance.

H
Hammer Head 26 days ago

You’ve got much bigger problems than springbok supporters.

u
unknown 26 days ago

There is a very big difference between ‘arrogance’ and ‘confidence’ may the best team on the day win. All I ever ask of my team (Springboks) is that they give their best🥲

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close