Dave Rennie wasn't proven right on Lienert-Brown, assistants under spotlight next
After a week in which head coach Dave Rennie publicly sung the praises for Anton Lienert-Brown, his midfield selections didn’t exactly prove him right.
The typically world class Jordie Barrett had a game below his standard on his return, conceding errant penalties, missing four tackles, and lacking the usual brilliance on attack.
Barrett we know can produce much more, but for Lienert-Brown you can’t say the same. He got another start against England and made 12 run metres on four carries, meanwhile England found open pasture in the first half continually going wide through the backs.
It wasn’t that Lienert-Brown was missing one-on-one tackles, it’s that the midfield could not control the England attack and find a way to shut it down. Granted, the All Blacks could not hold the ball and control the game, but after the loss to Wales, many aren’t impressed with the selection when you have Rieko Ioane and Timoci Tavatavanawai waiting.
Most expect Lienert-Brown to try hard, make effort plays, but fans don’t see enough upside to justify it. He’s not a game breaker, and of his 96 Test caps, it’s been a long while since there has been anything of note. He even had a habit of getting carded coming off the bench for awhile.
Rennie’s number one priority is work rate over everything, which ignores to some extent, actual ability.
Timoci Tavatavanawai in the second Bledisloe Cup fixture wasn’t perfect in his first Test start, but he had more to offer than Lienert-Brown with ball in hand. He topped the defenders beaten charts with six, added a line break and an offload. Many want to see more game time from Big Jim.
The fans aren’t blinded by selection favourites and internal politics, they just see what happens on the field. They know that Tavatavanawai is more likely to break the England defence than Lienert-Brown. They don’t need to see the metrics, how quick he gets off the deck after a tackle. We know, ball in hand, Tavatavanawai is harder to bring down.
Ian Foster rebuilt the midfield around Jordie Barrett and Rieko Ioane for the 2023 Rugby World Cup, and you know what, that was the best it had looked since Ma’a Nonu and Conrad Smith. A fast centre and a physical playmaker at 12. Ioane brings speed but his best asset turned out to be his defence.
Now, this Twickenham loss had everything go wrong, so it’s not fair to lay blame on Lienert-Brown, only question the selections. But the best defensive centre is on the bench and the X-factor players like Tavatavanawai and Emoni Narawa are sitting in the stands.
We are now seeing signs that the All Blacks are not up to scratch in many basic areas which brings the spotlight onto the assistants.
The lineout was shocking at Twickenham, and it’s not the first time Codie Taylor hasn’t thrown well in 2026. The calls were basic and it looked like England had the read on it early and often.
Under Scott Robertson last year Bryn Evans joined as a lineout coach and for the most part it was one of the best parts of the All Blacks’ game. There was innovation, there were pet plays around the lineout maul, and Taylor threw at over 90 per cent.
The only question mark around the lineout came in the record loss in the Wellington Test against the Springboks where it melted down, and that came with third choice thrower Brodie McAlister.
In Super Rugby Pacific, assistant Tana Umaga coached the worst defensive team in the competition in 2026 and for the last three seasons they’ve been bad. Even in the resurgent 2025 season with MVP Ardie Savea, the points differential was -139 which ranked 10th out of 11 teams despite finishing 7th on the ladder.
It’s fair to ask where the defensive pedigree comes from as a coach. We know he brings aura and mana as an ex-player who can connect with the players. But as a coach, where is the defined track record of success? It’s scratchy at best.
In the five losses this year, this team has conceded 37 to England, 35 to Wales, 43 to South Africa, 29 to South Africa, and 33 to South Africa.
They are averaging 27 points conceded a game across 12 Tests so far. The best mark in the Six Nations this year was Ireland with 21.6, while South Africa are also averaging 21.6 points per game in 2026 as the leaders.
When conceding 27 per game, the bar is high for the All Blacks to even win Tests. It relies on all-out attack and racking up 40 points plus regularly. They weren’t able to do it in South Africa, and now in Europe have run out of puff.
If the All Blacks lose next week to England again, the six losses in a calendar year will match 1949 as the worst on record for the All Blacks.
After the 2022 Ireland series loss, Ian Foster lost his assistants. If Rennie is held to the same standard, there will be questions asked and potential changes made, and that puts the assistants in the firing line.
If the All Blacks coaching group are held to the All Blacks standard like Foster was, some of them will go.
The HSBC SVNS series heads to DHL Stadium in Cape Town on 5-6 December! Get your tickets now
