Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

What Ben Earl 'actually thought' about England's Roman horror-day

By PA
Ben Earl of England (L) is consoled by team mate Ben Spencer after their defeat in the Guinness Six Nations 2026 match between Italy and England at Stadio Olimpico on March 07, 2026 in Rome, Italy. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)

Ben Earl has defended England’s performance in their historic first loss to Italy amid mounting pressure on head coach Steve Borthwick.

ADVERTISEMENT

England are facing the prospect of their worst finish in the Guinness Six Nations after conceding 13 unanswered points at the Stadio Olimpico to crash to a 23-18 defeat.

Their third successive collapse was met with a statement of support for Borthwick from the Rugby Football Union, although the backing extends only as far as this year’s Nations Championship and not the 2027 World Cup when his contract ends.

VIDEO

Earl, Borthwick’s most impressive contributor for much of the last three years, believes there was plenty to admire in Rome.

“There’s an element of pride really because I actually thought we played pretty well,” said the Saracens number eight, who won his 50th cap on Saturday.

Fixture
Six Nations
France
13:10
14 Mar 26
England
All Stats and Data

“There was a moment in that game I thought there was only one team that was going to win.

“If that game ended at 60 minutes you’d say that was an unbelievable performance by England, but unfortunately the result didn’t go our way.

“It was honestly one of the most enjoyable games I’ve played for 60 minutes. Because we had two good teams throwing punch after punch, tactical nous versus tactical nous, and we were on top.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Excuse my French but there’s going to be a s*** ton of noise, whatever, but Italy are a very good team. They’re going to go and beat some good teams.

“That doesn’t mean that we can’t improve and we can’t beat them, but I thought there were large parts of that performance that were brilliant.

“It was a performance where we brought the gameplan to life and Italy won a couple of moments in the last 20 minutes to win the game. That’s Test match rugby. That’s another lesson for us.

“Of course at some point you say ‘how many lessons can you take?’. But, again, I keep saying I’d rather learn these lessons now than in Brisbane at the 2027 World Cup.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Former internationals Austin Healey and Andy Goode have called for Borthwick to be sacked but Earl believes the players should be held responsible for the recent slump.

“Just have a think about what this team’s achieved since Steve took over. We’ve gone third in the World Cup,” he said.

“We’ve won 12 out of 15 games, but had won 12 on the bounce. We’ve beaten the All Blacks for the first time in Twickenham since 2012.

“The noise is actually bonkers, I think it’s crazy. If anyone is letting Steve down, it’s us, the group.

“And we need to play better at certain moments because we’re playing well for 50 minutes, playing well for 40 minutes, playing well for 30 minutes. We’ve just got to put it together – and we will.”

Related

Create your ticketing account and unlock presale access for Rugby World Cup 2027 now

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

21 Comments
E
Eric Elwood 7 hours ago

Not backing Earl but I feel it is now as difficult to win in Rome as it is in Murrayfield or Dublin for England.

It looked to me that Italy had blown the match by conceding the late first half try. The scoreboard pressure from Garbisi chipping the lead was good tactics. Underhill’s yellow was one of those things. Itoje’s put the Test win in extreme peril.

A culture of “No Penalties” was always insisted on around the 60 min mark in big teams according to Sam Warburton. There is no leadership in that England team. I don’t blame Itoje because hoping leaders will stand up during the match instead of having leadership and communication systemically drilled into the team means two words…Amateur Hour.

Where were the leaders at the 60 min mark? Getting a silly yellow card.

b
benny_pea 8 hours ago

Borthwick built us a game plan that obliterated the all blacks, Australia, and made us the second best team in the world in 2025. We were the best at the new kick chase laws, and now everyone has caught up to us. You cannot change how a team functions in a month, we will change.

u
unknown 8 hours ago

The game plan is flawed and there was no plan B which is a coaching failure. England were never the second best team in the world (based on rankings and performance). The winning run wasn’t as good as people think, if you look at it it consisted of fortunate home wins over France and Scotland, wins over the worst Welsh team in a long time, a series win over an under strength Argentina, wins over Fiji and USA, beating an Australia team burnt out from the Lions tour, and the weakest NZ team in a long time. Most of the winning run was played at home as well. The success was based on kick chase, high intensity defence and ruthless efficiency in the 22. All that success has gone. Other teams have adapted and play a high tempo ball in hand style. Borthwick has never shown the ability to apply such an approach either at Leicester or England. It’s time for him to go and some of the delusional players as well

E
Eric Elwood 8 hours ago

The All Blacks was a close match actually and in the balance till close to the end.

s
sh 8 hours ago

England rugby has been a shambles since ‘03. going from one mediocre tournament to another.

how do you change the best part of a team and expect to win.

Wigglesworth is totally out of his depth, no track record. Borthwick looks lost. Only blacket is worth keeping.

Comments of delusional are totally right. This team has too much smoke blown up their backsides and believe it. Being beaten happens, but in this manner is inexcusable

S
SB 10 hours ago

I thought there were large parts of that performance that were brilliant.

Hmmm.

B
BH 11 hours ago

Deluded, no other word for it.

Cognitive dissonance within the squad.

The emperors’ new clothes syndrome.

It is one thing being being insular and trying to keep the external “noise” down but there comes a time when facts need to be faced.


The plan whatever the hell it is, is not working SB and WW are strangling the life out of the players.

T
Tom 8 hours ago

Wichard Wigglesworth?

P
PM 15 hours ago

“ ..unfortunately the result didn’t go our way.”


That sounds too passive and fatalistic.

u
unknown 15 hours ago

Wow so from that it’s very worrying what the mindset is of the players. Based on his comments he doesn’t seem to grasp some key things:


- Rugby is an 80 minute game and you need to play well for 80 minutes.

- Winning 12 in a row is irrelevant if you’ve nothing tangible to show for it.

- History is not an accurate indicator of future performance. It doesn’t mean you are entitled to win games, that has to be earned through hard work.

- Beating a poor NZ is not the pinnacle. They have dropped off massively since that game.

- England showed no tactical nous so maybe Earl doesn’t understand what this means. Constantly kicking the ball away and failing to clear out rucks shows they have no tactical nous.

- Rugby is a results business. You are only as good as your last game and England have just put in three of the worst performances in living memory in the last three games.


The only accurate thing he said is that Italy are a good team.

u
unknown 16 hours ago

I can’t believe the level of delusion in what I’ve just read. England were dreadful for the majority of the game. Italy were the better team and I think that was probably their weakest performance of the tournament. Earl obviously doesn’t understand the level of performance required. Personally I think Earl is massively overrated. He doesn’t do the grunt work in the back row, doesn’t impact the breakdown enough for a 7 and isn’t a destructive enough ball carrier to play 8. This interview is further proof that changes are needed

J
John Breslin 15 hours ago

Earl is 4 inches and 10 kilos off being a test #8


He doesn't pick himself so it's maybe another one chalked up to the coach


Maybe Borthwick thinks he's getting there, bit by bit. So he starts there in Paris


France could go 3rd choice at #8 and ragdoll him

J
John Breslin 16 hours ago

Aye, they were class for 60 mins.


Top drawer, world beaters.


Join the concussion lawsuit, fella. Too many blows to the head

g
ge 19 hours ago

Wow. Well this reveals quite a lot about the ‘culture’ within the camp. Utterly delusional 😳

u
unknown 16 hours ago

Forget the men in white shirts, they need the men in white coats to come into Pennyhill and cart off this lot. To suggest there was anything outstanding about their performance is lunacy and to think that only one team were likely to win is offensive, delusional and smacks of the inept complacency that is rife in this team. A clear out is needed

T
Tom 17 hours ago

100%


It's an echo chamber of delusion at this point. They don't realise what modern test rugby looks like. The reality is, they actually implemented their gameplan better than they did in the previous two games but the gameplan sucks. All the messaging from the camp is that they're really close to clicking and it's small margins etc. it's not. We're playing rugby from 2015.

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close
ADVERTISEMENT