All Blacks player ratings vs Ireland | Rugby World Cup 2023
The All Blacks have defied the odds with a well-deserved 28-24 win over Ireland in Paris to progress through to the World Cup semi-finals.
Despite spending 20 minutes with 13 players on the field, New Zealand led the match from start to finish – but it still required over 30 phases of defending to shut out the game.
How the did the All Blacks rate in the win?
1. Ethan de Groot – 7
Held up his side of the scrum. Penalised once at the breakdown for not releasing the tackled player. Hit double figures in the tackle count despite not being on the field for the All Blacks’ big defensive effort at the end of the match. Off in 64th minute.
2. Codie Taylor – 6
Wasn’t able to get his running game going but was industrious on defence. Yellow-carded for bringing down a maul – although it probably could have been given to any All Black forward. Hit his lineout targets without too much trouble.
3. Tyrel Lomax – 8
Had the better of Andrew Porter despite spending plenty of time on the sidelines in recent weeks. Made countless tackles. Off in 64th minute.
4. Brodie Retallick – 7
Disrupted Ireland’s first lineout but wasn’t able to complete the steal. Secured an important breakdown turnover when Ireland were looking likely. Off temporarily in 65th minute.
5. Scott Barrett – 7
Another to put in a big shift on defence – and hit plenty of rucks. Moved to the backrow for the final quarter, where he was simply asked to make more tackles and hit more rucks.
6. Shannon Frizell – 5
Penalised in front of the posts off a kick-off for shepherding. Johnny Sexton duly converted into three points. One of two players stepped by Bundee Aki as the Ireland No 12 scored his side’s first try. Shifted plenty of bodies in the first half. Off in 60th minute.
7. Sam Cane – 8
A huge captain’s knock. Delivered a big tackle on Caelan Doris, facilitating a good opportunity for his loose forward teammate to initiate a steal. Forced a turnover of his own in of Ireland’s next attacking forays. Made a couple of nice runs with the ball. Made some more big hits late in the game and finished with 23 tackles, the most of any player on the park. Off in 75th minute.
8. Ardie Savea – 8
Huge on the carry (hitting double figures) but a bit overzealous at times on defence and in the breakdown. Pinged early at the breakdown for an illegal steal attempt but won one back moments later. Dotted down for a nice try in the corner with a great dive. Penalised again near the end of the first half and was then caught out when Jamison Gibson-Park dived over for a try from the following lineout drive. Forced another key penalty in the second spell and NZ scored a great long-distance try from the following lineout.
9. Aaron Smith – 5
A nervous game from the experienced halfback. Fluffed his first two passes. Yellow-carded for a deliberate knock-on. Might have saved a try at the time, but Ireland scored anyway from the ensuing possession. Plucked a Jamison Gibson-Park wide ball out of the air.
10. Richie Mo’unga – 8
1/1 pen, 1/2 con. Sent his first Gary Owen directly up in the air but mostly came right after that. Popped one chip kick over the line which Savea collected. Deputised well at halfback with Smith in the sin-bin. Measured up to Peter O’Mahony under the high ball. Made a great break off a lineout to spark the All Blacks’ third score. Penalised once for a high tackle.
11. Leicester Fainga’anuku – 6
Grabbed the opening try of the match after some nice back and forth with Rieko Ioane. Struggled at times to contain Mack Hansen and later Jimmy O’Brien. Stripped of the ball by Doris at one stage. Did some good work under the high ball. Off in 64th minute.
12. Jordie Barrett – 8
Threw himself into contact. Timed his pass to perfection in the build-up for the opening try. Made good use of his hefty boot. Kicked a nice penalty from near halfway. In what was perhaps the biggest play of the match, somehow prevented what looked like an almost certain try, holding Ronan Kelleher up over the line off a driving maul with fewer than 10 minutes to play.
13. Rieko Ioane – 7
Stepped by Bundee Aki. Delivered two try assists with two key passes in the wide channels. His speed in the outer channels helped shut down one Ireland counter-attack. Penalised once for not rolling away from the tackle.
14. Will Jordan – 7
Kicked a nice 50-22 – although NZ had the penalty advantage regardless. Missed Gibson-Park for the halfback’s try. Scored a try of his own after running a good support line off Mo’unga.
15. Beauden Barrett – 7
Sparked New Zealand’s opening try with a well placed chip and chase in the middle of the park. Looked cool as a cucumber on defence and covered the backfield well.
Reserves:
16. Dane Coles – N/A
On in 65th minute.
17. Tamaiti Williams – 5
On in 64th minute. Maintained the scrum standards but was otherwise quiet.
18. Fletcher Newell – 7
On in 64th minute. Continued Lomax’s good work at the set-piece and earned a penalty at his first scrum.
19. Sam Whitelock – 7
On in 60th minute. Pinged for not rolling away at the breakdown. The hero in the 83rd minute, forcing a breakdown penalty to end the match.
20. Dalton Papali’i – N/A
On in 75th minute.
21. Finlay Christie – NA
Unused.
22. Damian McKenzie – N/A
Unused.
23. Anton Lienert-Brown – 6
On in 64th minute. Delivered one big tackle late and rallied well late.
I don’t understand why Planet Rugby website continually to mentions that Jamison Gibson-Park, Bundee Aki and James Lowe are all born in New Zealand
I am absolutely fed up listening the media all mentioning that for the Ireland Rugby Squad
MEANWHILE
The Kiwi’s have been doing this for decades --- Ethan De Groot is an Aussie / Tyrel Lomax –Australia U20s Tonga Born Samisoni Taukei’aho –Former Tonga U19s Samipeni Finau – Tongan - Shannon Frizzell/ Forner Tonga U20s Leicester Fainga’anuku – Tongan Samoa Born - Nepo Laulala – Emoni Narawa –Fiji Born and raised lastly Finley Christie is Scottish
whoooah easy cowgirl roowwwhh feel better now franky sez relax mmm,,ok
Because almost all of those guys were brought up in New Zealand. Admittedly a guy like Frizell is a poach, but claiming guys like De Groot and Christie who were already growing up in NZ before they even began playing rugby is a laughable stretch. And even then, the other guys you mention spent time growing up in NZ too. Hardly similar to importing senior players that have multiple years playing NPC and Super Rugby.
And beyond this, non-Pacific fans like yourself simply have no idea of the cultural dynamic of the Pacific. Tonga’s population is ~105,000. Now guess how many Tongans there are in NZ. Over 80,000. It’s not as cut-and-dry as you make it out to be - unlike a Kiwi playing for Ireland.
Why are these ratings so low? Run in 96 points against the turnstile Italian defence and everyone gets 8s and 9s.
Epic game for the ages that required every ounce of skill any of these players possess and you’re giving people 5s?. I think that was the best game Ardie Savea has every played. Likewise Sam Cane.
Basically you are rating people lower because they are playing against the best defence in the world and didn’t run up 50 points.
Best Performance from The ABs - particularly the ruck n maul. To the Ireland team it was the best quarter final, so intense and exciting 83 minutes, should have been a semi or Final.
Im sure many young Irish lads will be proud of the achievements of there team, and are inspired to play Rugby.
Almost a masterclass from jordy Barrett good to see Al b standing up. Newell carry on from last game good to see solid bench work
Give a cheer today to Peter O’Mahoney and his world class sledging of Sam Cane last year and helping Sam reach Richie McCaw-level of world class 7 performance .
Peter O’Mahoney got a bit ahead of himself. Humble Pie was baking in the oven since then.
Absolutely no clue on these ratings mate. Best ABs performance since 2015 and theres heaps of 6s and 7s. Aaron Smith’s boxing kicking was perfect. Frizell was massive. ALB was not a 6, Beauden a 7 wtf lmao.
Nah, i think Smith had a poor game. His passes, especially in the first half, were not in front of the receiver and they had to stop and take it from a standing start.
He's had a good career, but it’s well and truly time to finish it.
Don’t forget BB gets 4 just for turning up! :(
Ireland conceded three tries tonight. Last time they did that was also against the All Blacks in the series decider last year.
Sexton acknowledged that Ireland had to work harder to get their tries by comparison to the All Blacks.
Yep. I noticed that. Ireland make a lot of their structured approach to scoring. But they just got beaten by a team that relies more on unstructured footy. The difference this time is the AB setpiece and defence was better than their attack.
Rating for ALB doesn’t match review.
Admit to being wrong about him being able to bring that sort of effort, well done.
Great game, so intense. Enjoy the win boys
Thank you so much ! France vs All Blacks will be a perfect final ! ;)
Nah, repeat of 1995 world cup final is on the cards
Think will be SA, I’m an optimist
Not this WC Boks are going to slaughter the chickens tonight
I’m not a Sam Cane fan but credit where credit is due. He was amazing!
Harsh on Frizell, the ABs dominated the breakdown and that was in large part due to Frizell shifting bodies. I don’t know how Reiko gets a 7 when his poor positioning opened the gap for Bundee and Frizell was trying to cover his mistake.
Yeah I think he covered more than given credit for too. Ireland took it easy on him though.
Sam Kane 8/10? 😂 being carried is an understatement
You should stop watching rugby Fraser
Well said, he was two captains in one tonight, carried the team on both his shoulders.
planned all along?? (pay back for the lost series on home soil - the ultimate revenge)
So does this mean we don’t get to hear zombie for 4 more years?
Talk about the weirdest fan song ever..
Bring on the all Southern Semis
Sam Cane was clearly Man of the Match in this performance. Needs to be recognised considering all the negative commentary aimed at him over the last few years.
Ardie Savea was a very deserving MOM.
But I agree that Cane was brilliant today.
I am ardent Bok supporter but today I was cheering as loudly as any Kiwi for the All Blacks. What an amazing game and an absolutely spectacular performance by the All Blacks. It was one of the best games of rugby that I have watched. That defence at the end was Herculean. Well Done to the New Zealanders.
Same here, green and gold in my blood, but one reaches a point where you cannot take this Irish-arrogance on and off-field anymore, and the subtle disrespect for whom they were up against tonight. So it was the right thing to do to stand behind the All Blacks whom just again showed how professional they are, and how good they are for rugby as a sport. Class act. SA vs NZ final please.
“Worst” All Black side in history, goes on to finish the “Best” Ireland side ever. They dug deep, the All Blacks are alive and well. What a game- game of the tournament every minute was intense.
Every SH team win this weekend will be an upset. In the Northern Hemisphere that is.
Well done NZ. Massive performance. 🙌
Well well well…looks like the cup will remain in the southern hemisphere! Well played NZ!
Seems like the southern hemisphere teams are just too good for the northern hemisphere teams
The Six Nations and European Championship are obviously not strong enough to produce a RWC winner. Maybe more regular games in a competition against Southern hemisphere opposition would bring those competitions up to World standards.
😉
Ardie with an 8 is ridiculous, he was a 9 atleast
Sam Cane a 9.5 in my opinion & I’m probably his harshest critic (for some very good reasons I might add). Brilliant Captain’s knock, effort & leadership. About time. Repeat in semis please.
Like the All Blacks of old. Amazing defense and give them a sniff of the try line, they score. A true World Cup team.
Savea is a machine
One in the eye for some of the ‘analysts’ on this site. The ratings here could have been pulled from a hat.
They are.
All you Cane haters, time to eat humble pie. What a warrior.
I’ve never been more happy to eat it! ABs fans enjoying it more than POM I’m sure.
Made anonymous O’Mahoney eat his words. Was absolutely fantastic.
That was Sam Cane’s greatest test ever on par with Richie McCaw’s best tests.
What a wah
I am loving that pie right now JD
Agree. This is the performance we’ve all been waiting for. Now he has to back it up in the semis.
Someone please tell Tom that the All Blacks beat the number one team in the world amd ended their 17 test winning streak.
Not one starting All Black deserves less than 7 today.
And Savea, Cane, DeGroot, Lomax, and Jordie Barrett deserve 9.