Northern Edition
Select Edition
Northern Northern
Southern Southern
Global Global
New Zealand New Zealand
France France

What seperates Barrett and Jordan as fullbacks for All Blacks

Beauden Barrett and Will Jordan of New Zealand celebrate after teammate Aaron Smith (not pictured) scores a try that is later disallowed during the Rugby World Cup Final match between New Zealand and South Africa at Stade de France on October 28, 2023 in Paris, France. (Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

New Zealand is blessed with plenty of depth in the backfield, but rarely do you get as high-profile of a selection battle as Will Jordan vs Beauden Barrett.

ADVERTISEMENT

Barrett is no stranger to battling for a starting jersey, as he did for so many seasons with Jordan’s former Crusaders teammate Richie Mo’unga and the black 10 jersey.

While the desire to play first receiver is still very much alive for Barrett, who clarified at the start of the year that is his preferred position, Damian McKenzie’s form and youth has demanded selection over the more experienced Barrett.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

However, the playmaking skillset of one of New Zealand’s most iconic No. 10s and back-to-back World Rugby Player of the Year is hard to turn down, even with the X-factor of the try-scoring phenom that is Will Jordan.

“I do think Beuady at fullback is someone who can tactically kick, contestable kick and probably looks at that kick first and then looks to inject himself into that running game once they’re in that phase play shape,” former All Blacks James Parsons analysed on the Aotearoa Rugby Pod.

“Whereas I think Will’s a run-first sort of guy. Not saying he doesn’t;t have the ability to kick, but I definitely think from what we’ve seen of him he’s a run-first guy. And then, in that phase play I think he’s always looking for that chip out the back, we’ve seen that when Beaudy’s played at 10, that beautiful chip that led to one of his tries against Australia.

“He is all-out attack. If we look at what we have seen early on (from the All Blacks), they are all-out attack, and the Crusaders coaching group that had Will is very similar to what we have now in the All Blacks.

ADVERTISEMENT

“So, I think there’s that relationship and that trust if he does start.”

Related

Acting as his own devil’s advocate, Parsons then offered a counter-argument to Jordan’s selection based on the opinion of a former Wallaby.

“I was listening to an interview with Rob Kafer and they were talking about the Wallabies, but he spoke about the Marshall, Mertens, McDonald at the Crusaders. The Gregan, Larkham, Joe Roth relationship at the Brumbies, and he goes ‘I just don’t understand why rugby’s gone away from building these solid combinations through Super Rugby teams into the international rugby that allows them that success.

“And that’s the only thing that challenged my thinking around this. Initially, I was like they have to give Will a crack, he’s definitely part of their plans, he’s definitely, probably who they wanted at fullback.

“But, then you’re like, well, what impact does that have on Damian? We really need that combination, that nine-ten – we’ve got disruptions at nine – Damian’s solid, Beaudy’s done really well, do we fiddle with that?”

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

1 Comment
S
SM 318 days ago

I hope we fiddle, nows the time.

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Features

Comments on RugbyPass

f
fl 2 hours ago
‘Props are awesome…so why don’t they win prizes?’

“The reason most props don’t last the whole game is that they expend proportionally more effort than players outside the front row. Should they be penalised for that?”

No, they don’t last the whole game because they are less fit than players outside the front row. I’d be interested to know if you’d apply this logic to other positions; do PSDT and Itoje regularly last longer than other players in their positions because they put in less effort?

None of this is about “penalising” props, its about being realistic about their impact on a game.


“While scrums are a small part of the game in terms of time spent in them, they have disproportionate impact. Dominant scrums win games; feeble ones lose them.”

Strength at the breakdown wins games. Good kicking wins games. Good handling wins games. Strong defence wins games. Good lineouts win games. Ultimately, I think that of all these things, the scrum is probably the least important, because it demonstrably doesn’t correlate very well with winning games. I don’t think Rugbypass will allow me to link articles, but if you google “HG Rugby Crowning the Best Scrum in Club Rugby” you’ll get a pretty convincing analysis that ranks Toulouse and Bordeaux outside of the 10 best club sides in the scrum - and ranks Leinster outside of the top 30.


“Or there’s Joe Marler’s epic performance in the Bristol v Quins 2021 Premiership Semi-Final, in which he finally left the pitch 15 minutes into extra time having signed off with a try saving tackle.”

Yeah - that’s a good example actually, but it kind of disproves your point. Marler played 95 minutes, which is unheard of for a prop.


“Maybe we need a dedicated Hall of Fame with entry only for props, and voted for only by props.”

Well we have the World Rugby XV of the year. Its only been going for a few years, but in time it’ll be a pretty good record of who are perceived as best props - although the lack of interest most people have in scrums means that perception of who the best props are doesn’t always match reality (e.g. Tadgh Furlong was great in 2018 - but was he really the best tighthead in the world in 2021, 2022, & 2023?).

7 Go to comments
LONG READ
LONG READ Two Lions outsiders make strong Test cases amid Dublin defeat Two Lions outsiders make strong Test cases amid Dublin defeat
Search