Northern | US

The three most important players for the All Blacks and Springboks

Jesse Kriel of South Africa during the New Zealand v South Africa Rugby Championship match at Eden Park on September 6, 2025 in Auckland, New Zealand. (Photo by Craig Butland/MB Media/Getty Images)
Comments
42 Comments

The fun and games of the Greatest Rivalry Tour are over, and now it’s time to get deadly serious.

ADVERTISEMENT

Back-to-back Rugby World Cup Winners host the world number two in an epic four-Test match marathon across two continents.

Team tactics have been broadly speculated on, coaching styles have been analysed, and dark art tactics have been scrutinised openly in the media, but in just a few short days all will be revealed.

VIDEO

Although the two best sides in the world will only win if they play as teams, there are individuals amongst these behemoths of the game that will have substantial influence over the game, and should they be slightly off, injured, or absent from selection, then the opposition will gain the upper hand.

Springboks

1. Jesse Kriel, Outside Centre

It may appear strange, or even bizarre to some people, that an outside centre appears first on this list; many people would guess that any side would rely most on personnel in the front row, but for the Boks, this is not the case this tour.

The main reason for this is the enviable depth and immense talent the Springboks have in their propping stock. 

Ox Nche, Thomas Du Toit, Wilco Louw, Gerhard Steenkamp, the list goes on and on, and many of these power scrummagers would start if not be in the matchday 23 for most nations.

ADVERTISEMENT

The loss of one player here or there would not rock the Springboks’ ability to go about their business or rob them of a strength; however, the loss of Kriel would.

Outside centre is the most difficult position to defend at in rugby, and it is an even bigger challenge when you are part of such an aggressive rush defence as the Springboks have.

Kriel’s ability to read the attack, to make split-second decisions and to make crucial tackles is world-class, and there are few in the world that match him for his raw athleticism and strength. 

There’s also an element of Kreil having such a longstanding partnership with inside centre Damien de Allende. In fact, the pair are now the most capped centre pairing as a duo in Springboks history, overtaking the great Jean de Villiers and Jaque Fourie.

ADVERTISEMENT

While De Allende plays a big role in this partnership, Kriel is the glue of the backline, and he is irreplaceable.

Fixture
Internationals
South Africa
16 - 33
Full-time
New Zealand
All Stats and Data

2. Malcolm Marx, Hooker

While the front row is well stocked as mentioned, and the hooking stocks have some notable men as well, there is no one that is in the same league as Marx.

A man mountain is perhaps the only fair and accurate description, but how a man so big can get so low and become an immovable object when pilfering a ball is a true question of physics.

While Andre-Hugo Venter is a good replacement, and 39-year-old Deon Fourie terrorised the All Blacks’ breakdown in the opening match of the Greatest Rivalry Tour, Marx’s size, power, work rate, and game nous put him in a world of his own.

He knows what it takes to win big matches; he knows what it takes to beat the All Blacks, and whether it’s adding his shunt to the scrum, muscle in defence, or power attacking the Kiwis’ line, Marx is not someone who can be replaced.

Sometimes it’s just a question of class, and Marx is as classy as they come.

3. Cobus Reinach, Halfback

While a lot of the focus will be on the Stormers’ wonderkid Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu, the way rugby is being played and officiated means that halfbacks are actually the main drivers of the game.

While many will say Stormers halfback Grant Williams is just as good, if not better than Cobus, they would be grossly undervaluing Reinach’s ability to control tempo, and for a side like the Boks, that’s crucial.

It was evident in Argentina that Reinach was walking a fine line on the ‘five-second use it’ rule, but that is his prerogative.

It certainly aided the Springboks to forward their game plan, a plan that is likely to be replicated in the first Test at the weekend.

While the Springboks won’t be all ‘set-piece to set-piece’ and they will certainly look to inject pace and strike into their play, having Reinach at halfback will be a great foil for whoever is steering the ship from flyhalf.

Whoever is playing no.10 will be immaterial if the Boks get their way and can play to their blueprint.

Sacha is elite with ball in hand, Williams is lightning from the base, but that is not how the Boks will beat this All Blacks side. Reinach is crucial to the Springboks playing their best and most dominant rugby.

A special mention must also go to Damien Willemse, who is perhaps also irreplaceable at fullback, seeing as the jack of all trades covers so many positions almost as well as any master does.

Related

All Blacks

1. Cam Roigard, Halfback

This is no secret: Roigard is imperative for the All Blacks’ ability to play their style and to win Test matches.

As mentioned for Reinach, halfbacks often dictate gainline, momentum, and territory; they are now the generals of the team.

It started with Antoine Dupont for France; it’s been evident with Ireland’s Jamison Gibson-Park, and now it’s clear with Roigard for New Zealand.

It’s not that the All Blacks don’t have great game-drivers at flyhalf and fullback; in fact, they are all stellar and vastly experienced for the most part, but as mentioned, with the state of the game as it is, no.9s touch the ball the most, dictate tempo, and make the big calls.

This is also a tip of the cap to just how far in front Roigard is of the other halfbacks in Cortez Ratima and Kyle Preston; he is ahead of the pack by some margin.

Whether it’s his core skillset, his running game, or the ability to read the play, Roigard is a generational talent for the All Blacks, and it’s no wonder he has been wrapped in cotton wool so far.

However, he lacks the feats and experience to be on the same level as Dupont and Gibson-Park, as of yet.

2. Fletcher Newell, Tighthead Prop

Right here is a guy with the weight of the world, and he will have the weight of the Springboks’ pack, pushing down on his shoulders.

While he is not the best tighthead scrummager in the All Blacks squad, that title appears to lie with veteran Tyrell Lomax; Newell’s full-fitness status has him as a vital part of the All Blacks team.

Lomax is not yet back to his absolute best after a lengthy injury layoff, and while he is also a very important part of the puzzle, Newell will likely be made to bear the brunt of the challenge in the earlier Tests.

This is a great one-two punch for the All Blacks to have, but the Newell-Lomax axis is imperative for the All Blacks’ bid to keep the set-piece battle in the balance, for if even one of these two falters, the Springboks will have their way at scrum time.

Related

3. Jordie Barrett

Just like the man inside the five-eighth is important, so is the man outside him, and with Hurricanes’ flyhalf Ruben Love shaping to don the famous jersey, Barrett’s role has become all the more imperative.

Ellis Park in Johannesburg is one of the most hostile places to play in the world for a visiting team, and at 1,753 metres above sea-level, it will require all hands on deck to ensure the team is being driven into the right parts of the field.

Barrett is a world-class triple threat; he runs, kicks, and passes all as well as any other back, and his large stature means you aren’t going through him.

To have this sort of player outside you as a flyhalf is a dream come true, and with the weapons able to be deployed by South Africa in the loose forwards as well as the backline, they will need a staunch character in the No.12 Jersey.

While Roigard dictates tempo at halfback, Barrett at inside centre will be the eyes and ears to his flyhalf, and no one is giving better communication than Jordie.

While his skill set will be invaluable, it will be his ability to find space in attack and close space in defence with his outside men that makes him such an indispensable player for the All Blacks.

While Anton Leinart-Brown is also an experienced campaigner, there has been nothing in his recent form to suggest that he is close to Jordie’s level at the moment.

While the battle of the flyhalves is often a focal point between these two sides, there are far more influential members throughout both sides for this first clash.

This tour will be won by the better team, but the best teams have special players, and this group of players will be unmatched in their ability to influence their side’s ambitions to win the inaugural Greatest Rivalry Tour.

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

42 Comments
A
Ayre123 None 44 days ago

As for the Boks, it’s spot one: within the wealth of test players in SA, we have no adequate substitutes of strength vs strength for Jesse, for Marx and for Reinach. Fact, at their 30+ age there are still no replacements!

D
DanTheDowner 44 days ago

On a point of order.


Grant doesn't play for the Stormers

T
TT 44 days ago

Give me a AB V Bok test series over RWCs any day

(of course, I'll take both).


(we'll see how a feel about that tomorrow)


ABs by 8


THIS Bok team - backs good, forwards a force.


BUT most of this whole Bok team (eg 80%) haven't played together since the 2023 World Cup final,

ie for this team's majority that is zero 2026 play minutes together.


This maybe(?) their BIG potential weakness.


But while THIS Bok team's weren't totally dominant of = sides, they sometimes were, including THAT 13/09/2025 record capitulation by the ABs.


Few ABs supporters forget seeing ABs walking, quitting & lost. WORSE that was NEARLY the SAME 2 TEAMS.


Worse ABs had T.Williams. AND Love at 10! Carter at wing!


PLUS

1. de Groot

2. Taylor

3. Lomax


6. Vaa'i

7. Savea (VC)

8. Sititi


10. Love


11. Carter

12. J.Barrett

13. Tupaea

14. Jordan

15. McK


The AB diff = new coaching team.

ABs must be 150% & all go right.


& hopefully the AB feeling for revenge runs deep & focuses.


And it would help if THIS strongest Bok team were rusty.


Go ABs..by 8

J
JW 44 days ago

there are individuals amongst these behemoths of the game that will have

substantial influence over the game

Your threw me off a bit here JF.

and should they be slightly off, injured, or absent from selection, then the opposition will gain the upper hand.

Did you mean to say “tour”?


Absolutely agree Kriel is fundimental to the game, on the defensive side, but disagree about the tour or series. SA would be better off if he is not available.


The way you started the article every remember of the starting tight five’s is critical, if one has a bad day that is it for their team.


If you’re talking tour, for the ABs that’s EDG and Lomax, those two standout above the bunch so one going down or getting found out would be pivotal imo. Basically the inverse between props and hookers for you Marx selection.


I think South Africa have enough tour locking depth to match the All Blacks? For this game tho Eben would have to make the list, he’s back and playing right? Big question marks about whether he can still handle it.


Otherwise agree on the halfbacks either way, though again Williams would suit a dangerous bok team better.

J
John 44 days ago

You are absolutely right JW, I meant to write “tour”!

W
WJ 45 days ago

“However, he lacks the feats and experience to be on the same level as Dupont and Gibson-Park, as of yet.” Nonsense. Roigard is already well up with those guys. When the ABs played Ireland recently he was clearly the better in my opinion.

H
Hammer Head 45 days ago

This game is going to be closer than we think.


The Springboks could win it.

S
SF 44 days ago

It is going to be close. Both sides can win it. It’s great to have the AB'S touring here. It is still 9 hours to kickoff and I'm already nervous. For both teams it will come down to who executes their gameplan the best. It’s going to be a brutal first 20 minutes. We are in for a fascinating test match. Enjoy mate.

C
ColinK 45 days ago

Agree Hammer Boks most likely, but a near run thing also likely. Should make for fascinating viewing. You guys have fielded an excellent team, I can see some areas we may edge an advantage, but not many.

D
Drew 45 days ago

I think most would argue Grant Williams is ahead of Reinach in the pecking order. Either way they are interchangeable. But if we lose Damien Willemse or P S d Toit the step down to the next guy is much bigger.

J
John 44 days ago

While I think the step down from PSTD is major, I don’t think he is irreplaceable in the sense of fulfilling the role for the team. I think with a Marco Van staden or BJ Dixon, Hanakom etc, there would still be the requisite skill set and workrate to aid the springboks, but your right there is no one like PSTD. It will be interesting to see how Williams and Reinach go!

H
HM 45 days ago

I would argue that Ethan de Groot is far more important than Newell. Given, as you said, the 1-2 punch the ABs have with him and Lomax, meanwhile there's a significant drop to the next best loosehead. Bower will do a well enough job and Numia looks like becoming the other half of another 1-2 at loosehead but is still fresh to test rugby. Losing de Groot and/or Roigard would be catastrophic to the ABs chances, above any others I feel

J
John 44 days ago

It’s a good argument here mate, I’m looking at it a little more from the Springboks side, I think Ox Nche and Thomas Du Toit are the biggest scrummaging weapons on the LHP side, so the THP for the All Blacks is most important.


Nonetheless, I do agree De Groot is very important. Numia is urgently needed back. I do not have full confidence in Bower.

J
JW 44 days ago

He didn’t say anything about the importance of the bench? I can understand him thinking that’s the more important aspect, if he’s predicting the starting f/rs will be even.


I haven’t quite got that far yet and I’m like you and still stuck on the starting f/r doing a job. But then the article also talks about not being able to ‘select’ a player, and not being able to select one of these starts would be more important that Newell for sure.


If it was last years Newell then for sure he’s top, but he’s been out of sorts and not playing his best for a long time now.

c
cnw 45 days ago

Agree - a key here is that the Boks use the THP as a weapon - the nuclear go to. And with Louw now starting - backed up by Eben and probably PSdT - De Groot / Holland / Vaa’i are going to be very very important to scrum stability.

C
ColinK 45 days ago

Agree its a shame Numia injured, he is a better scrummager than Bower. But Bower is a solid bloke and will put in via a short front row off the bench.

L
Lou Cifer 45 days ago

for me….Lomax the TH is more important

J
Jmann 45 days ago

It ‘started with Dupont’? I rather think it started with Aaron Smith

C
ColinK 45 days ago

Dave Loveridge, one of the best 9s ever.

G
GrahamVF 45 days ago

Ever heard of Gareth Edwards?

L
LiamBerlin 45 days ago

Jacques Fouroux? He was the original „petit général“. 9s Running the game has been around for at least 50 years, just not so common in the English-speaking world

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close