Northern | US

'Dupes is a good player': Why Ethan Blackadder was recalled to All Blacks and Kirifi missed out again

Ethan Blackadder of New Zealand in action during the Castle Lager Rugby Championship match between South Africa and New Zealand at Emirates Airline Park on August 31, 2024 in Johannesburg, South Africa. (Photo by Dirk Kotze/Gallo Images/Getty Images)
Comments
16 Comments

The announcement of the 44-man touring squad to South Africa featured a number of surprises in the loose forwards including Crusaders hard man Ethan Blackadder who found his way back into the squad.

ADVERTISEMENT

Blackadder won his place over the likes of Hurricanes openside Du’Plessis Kirifi who went on to lead the Hurricanes to the Super Rugby title this year.

The last of Blackadder’s 14 Tests was in fact in South Africa in 2024, the 31-27 loss to the Springboks at Ellis Park under former coach Scott Robertson.

Video Spacer

Video Spacer

After injuries have sidelined the versatile loose forward, Blackadder put in a solid 2026 season with the Crusaders featuring at openside for the first four weeks before exclusively playing blindside the remainder of the season.

Rennie highlighted his physicality and work rate as stand out qualities that the All Blacks selectors were impressed with.

“He’s obviously had a lot of injuries over time, but you know when he played this year, he’s really impressive,” he said of Blackadder.

“He’s just a massive engine, physical, and so we think he offers a point of difference around that.”

ADVERTISEMENT

With competition around the No.7 fierce, Rennie said that the existing squad members all performed very well making it tough for a specialist like Kirifi to break into the squad.

Up to four players can already cover openside while the addition of Blackadder adds a fifth.

Rennie’s message to Kirifi was to “stay ready” as they would fly out injury cover if needed.

“I spoke to a handful of guys, so I’m not going to go into massive detail, but you know, as you’ve seen with the guys that we used in the Nations Championship, those boys fronted well for us,” he said.

“Luke [Jacobson], Anton [Segner], Peter Lakai, Ardie can all play seven, and certainly, you know, Dupes [Kirifi] is a good player and had a good season, and so there’s there’s good players who’ve missed out, and not just him.

“So his job is to go away, keep working hard, be ready if an opportunity arises. I’d be surprised that we don’t call someone out at some stage.”

ADVERTISEMENT

 

Register your interest to receive priority updates on RWC27 ticket releases. Don't miss out, stay in the loop!


ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

16 Comments
O
OutRun22 43 days ago

Hes only an injury a way . rennies reason was hes not as good at passing the ball and hes too short. Blackadder you may as well use the injury prone guy. kirifi could still play after Blackadder. Though personally as rennie has also said nz has better 7s than kirifi ahead of him. Cassie is bigger and hes a 7 too he like Blackadder is a 6 and 7 and possibly an 8 too. kirifs a 7 only and a garden gnome to boot.

E
Emery 45 days ago

This is where we don’t want kirifi to leave as he is a great super player. They need to make super rugby a pinnacle competition instead of just All Blacks.

S
SC 45 days ago

Watch James Parson and Karl Ross’ analysis on their podcast of BIGGA scores of all NZ loose forwards, measuring work rate and impact, and Blackadder scored the fourth best amongst all NZ loosies this season and had a far superior score to Jacobson, Parker, STT, and yes Kirifi.


And Blackadder has a proven record of playing well for All Blacks in South Africa.


As he is healthy, he deserves his selection over Kirifi. He cleans rucks more effectively, makes more tackles per match, more dominant tackles per match, more metres per carry per match than Kirifi.

S
Skinny Pins 45 days ago

Blackadder is precisely the sort of loose forward to suit both Rennie-ball and a tour to South Africa. Great selection.

N
NoLongerARuck 45 days ago

Leaving out Kirifi will send him North or to Japan quite soon. Its clear they are looking for bulk and size and they feel they have enough mobile 7’s in the squad to cover all bases. Kirifi is now surplus and after a season of doing everything right will rightly feel aggrieved about missing out. A player in his shoes has nothing left to achieve in NZ. He will certainly look to cash in sooner rather than later

N
NucK 45 days ago

He's not to small he just hasn't got it done in a decent number of appearances for the ABs. I was rooting for him but I can see why they've gone in the direction they have. 0 turnovers in tests last year is not a good look for a 7.

O
Over the sideline 45 days ago

STT is such an exciting prospect and Im rapped he has been given his place, and Blackadder is an excellent 6 if needed, so I didnt see a place for DPK

J
Jordon 45 days ago

The ultimate “style of play” is winning. Kirifi did that all season and all season he was one of the best on the park. If he’s too small then so is kwagga smith and John de Villiers. It’s hard to see how he fits in to the test 23 but I would've thought he would be invaluable leading the mid week sides which will have your prestons and jacombs etc. Also calling kirifi a “good player” is just throwing needless shade, whether it be intentional or not. He’s clearly in the realm of very good player.

L
Locke 44 days ago

Kirifi lacks the explosive carry threat that players like Kwagga Smith and John de Villiers bring. Being undersized isn’t a deal‑breaker at openside, but you need top‑tier acceleration, leg drive, or evasiveness to offset it. Kirifi doesn’t consistently show those traits.

His jackal threat was disappointing too, which should’ve been his point of difference. He managed a couple of turnovers in one match I think, but otherwise struggled.

N
Nickers 44 days ago

I don’t think it has to do with his size. I think his lack of size is also massively overstated. He’s an absolute beast as I’m sure many bigger men who have been folded in half by him would testify. I think it’s more to do with his ball carrying and contact work - this is definitely the weakest part of his game - Rennie needs every forward to be able to carry, get metres, and provide quick ball in traffic. If we plan on carrying the ball from our 40 you can’t really have a weak link.

L
Lou Cifer 45 days ago

I would've thought he would be invaluable leading the mid week sides

Exactly what I thought too tbh. Has Rennie become that obsessed with size or is it only the fact that he is a specialist 7? probably both. Kwagga Smith & Paul de Villiers have shown there is room for smaller loosies

P
PS 45 days ago

Fraser McReight is cited as one of the best loose forwards in World Rugby. Whenever he has come up against Du'Plessis Kirifi in Super Rugby he has come off 2nd best.

It seems to be an unthinking reflex comment that Kirifi is “too small”

Maybe in a loose forward combo he doesn’t quite fit the profile of what is required against South Africa

Load More Comments

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

N
NoLongerARuck 1 hour ago
The Kennedy Tsimba shift series part three: Willie le Roux on the art of adaptability

I think when it comes to adaptability well you cannot develop it without exposure (in training and matches), continuity and review. Its about seeing pictures repeatedly and developing a response to that. Its not just a singular response but a cohesive one. Each player needs to instinctively know how to respond to the picture and act as one unit. That comes with time, combinations, exposure, experience. In training its developed by creating or exposing players to unstructured situations as a group and planning responses together when seeing the pictures in front of them with each player understanding their role in that situation and responding accordingly to the next action. Each action builds on the next and ultimately that leads to a highly cohesive side that can adapt to multiple situations in a game. That could be a response to a knock on, turnover, winning a contestable etc. The response is also dictated by where you are on the field and the match situation. In terms of continuity selection matters and combinations are crucial. Its about selecting the right athletes and skill sets for the system. The best player may not be best for the system. This is precisely why teams that have been together for long and have experienced success together can find cohesion in unstructured situations faster. When it comes to review its all about looking at responses to situations and mistakes that were made, reviewing them and discussing how that could have been done better. Its about reinforcing positive actions as well that led to positive outcomes. Review allows teams to adapt to the same pictures faster the next time. Doing the reps matters and if you can do it within a system of continuous review then adaptability can surely be trained.

11 Go to comments
Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close