Argentina player ratings vs France | Nations Championship 2026
Argentina player ratings: For the best part of an hour Los Pumas were right in the fight, bullying France at scrum time, taking a deserved first-half lead and asking plenty of questions of a side that knew a bonus-point win would send them through. In the end, a red card for a cabbage moved by Mayco Vivas, a costly yellow for Julian Montoya and the class of Antoine Dupont and Kalvin Gourgues proved decisive.
Even so, there were several worthy Argentinian efforts. Boris Wenger, Tomas Albornoz, Justo Piccardo, Geronimo Prisciantelli and Pablo Matera all emerging with considerable credit.
1. Boris Wenger – 7
Brilliant in the loose and one of Argentina’s best early performers, at least while on the pitch. The loosehead gave Sipili Falatea plenty to think about during Los Pumas’ dominant scrum spell and also popped up around the field with surprising regularity. Sadly left after just 17 minutes.
2. Julian Montoya – 5
A frustrating night for the captain. The veteran threw great darts, topped Argentina’s tackle count with 11 and never stopped fronting up physically, but the yellow card for cynical play arrived at a moment when his side could least afford it. France were already punishing the Vivas dismissal and Montoya’s trip to the bin effectively extinguished any hope of a fightback.
3. Francisco Moreno – 6
The 147kg giant managed some good work against Neti in the first half when Argentina’s scrum was causing genuine problems. Helped lay the foundations for sustained pressure inside the French 22 and never looked overawed by the occasion.
4. Guido Petti – 6
Worked hard in the engine room and was part of the pack that dragged France into an arm wrestle before half-time. Conceded a couple of penalties and eventually found himself spending more time defending than attacking as the French pressure mounted.
5. Tomas Lavanini – 5
Showed flashes of the usual Lavanini mix of physicality and confrontation. Drove into contact hard and helped Argentina establish a foothold during their best spell, but the monster lock faded badly.
6. Juan Martin Scelzo – 6
One of the busier defensive performers, finishing with eight tackles. Not spectacular but certainly not lacking for effort as France repeatedly tested the edges of Argentina’s defence in the second half.
7. Juan Martin Gonzalez – 6
A dependable shift. Finished with nine tackles, got through plenty of breakdown work and kept hunting for involvements even after France began to take control. Fell away though.
8. Facundo Isa – 5.5
A relatively quiet outing by his standards but still carried with purpose whenever given the opportunity. One turnover lost slightly blemished an otherwise steady contribution. Went off at the break and was replaced by Matera, who showed him up.
9. Simon Benitez Cruz – 6
Kept the attack ticking over during Argentina’s promising first half and carried six times himself. Gave away two childish penalties that hurt his side, but there was enough positive work with ball in hand to avoid a lower mark.
10. Tomas Albornoz – 7.5
Arguably Argentina’s most dangerous attacker at times. Made over 40 metres, produced Los Pumas’ only real line break and kicked them into a 10-7 lead and regularly threatened to open France up whenever he challenged the line. One of the few visitors to show up.
11. Ignacio Mendy – 5
Carried eight times and but never made much of the ball he got. Opportunities were admittedly limited as France increasingly controlled territory, but he at least remained willing to chase work and was involved on both sides of the ball.
12. Justo Piccardo – 8
A performance full of incident. His failure to deal with Dupont’s kick gifted France the field position that led to their opening try, but he responded in magnificent fashion. Bounced off two defenders to score Argentina’s first try, carried 11 times, made nine tackles and consistently challenged the French midfield. A proper Test match display.
13. Lucio Cinti – 6
Made eight tackles and worked hard defensively opposite the dangerous Kalvin Gourgues. Lost a turnover and missed three tackles, which slightly dulled the overall impact of an otherwise committed shift.
14. Bautista Delguy – NA
Cruelly denied the chance to influence the game after being forced off early through injury. His departure brought Rodrigo Isgro into the action far earlier than expected.
15. Geronimo Prisciantelli – 5
A proper mixed bag. The full-back was decent in attack at times, carrying 11 times and often looking like Argentina’s most dangerous broken-field runner. However, he also lost two turnovers, missed three tackles and struggled to consistently tidy up everything France threw at him from deep. Produced enough quality moments to catch the eye, but there were too many errors mixed in with the good stuff to warrant anything higher.
REPLACEMENTS – 5
A bench of highs and lows. Rodrigo Isgro was arguably the standout, winning two turnovers, making six tackles and injecting real life into the contest after Delguy’s departure. Pablo Matera rolled back the years with his interception try, pouncing on a moment of French brainrot close to the line and generally bringing the edge that has defined his Test career. Agustin Moyano worked hard but lost two turnovers, while Facundo Bosch, Joel Sclavi, Efrain Elias and the excellent Pedro Rubiolo all had moments.

Watch Hemispheres collide as North faces South in the Nations Championship. Live matches, replays and highlights free on RugbyPass TV here
(*USA only)