Select Edition

Northern Northern
Southern Southern
World World



Welsh rugby enveloped in its latest existential crisis

As Wayne Pivac teeters on the edge of finding new gainful employment after a series of disappointing results, the wider-lens story tells of dysfunction and frustration

RugbyPass+ Home

Welsh fans taking positives as yet another talent lost to English system

By Josh Raisey
Welsh fans are reaching for positives

A trend that has been worrying Welsh fans over the past few months is the number of uncapped regional players that are making a move to England.


Another name was added to that list recently, with Cardiff Blues and Wales under-18 lock Christ Tshiunza moving to Exeter Chiefs. He joins fellow Blues rising star Rhys Carre, who moves to Saracens next season.

The 21-year-old prop Carre has been hotly tipped as a player of the future in Wales, and has already been called up to Warren Gatland’s World Cup training squad. However, as he is yet to play for his country, he joins a growing number of Welsh-born players that are opting for more lucrative deals abroad while they are young.

Players are making this move as they can still play for their country. Although they have under 60 caps (which usually prohibits a Welsh international being selected if they play abroad), if they are uncapped when they signed their contract with their club, it does not matter. This has been seen with Josh Adams, who could represent Wales while with Worcester Warriors, as he was initially uncapped. However, now that his contract has expired, he has had to move to Cardiff to keep his international career alive.

Some Welsh fans are disappointed that this is happening in their system, and are rueing the number of promising players that are leaving the regions. Welsh domestic rugby is not particularly strong at the moment, with no team challenging in either the Pro14 or European competitions last season.

This exodus of young players from the regions will not help, and that is what is concerning may fans on Twitter:


However, while there are obvious downsides to these moves away, a number of Welsh fans are taking positives out of this exodus.

Not only will these players benefit from the coaching of other clubs, but it will not cost the Welsh Rugby Union anything. Saracens and Exeter were the two Premiership finalists last season, with Saracens winning the Champions Cup as well. Both clubs have developed many great players over the past few years, and the Welsh national team can benefit from this.

While the regions will be hampered in the meantime, the fans feel that the players will come back better, and it has been no financial incursion on the WRU.

This is what has been said:


These moves away for uncapped players seem like an inevitability in rugby, and something the WRU cannot stop. But an encouraging step is that the fans are seeing this now as a positive rather than a negative.


Join free and tell us what you really think!

Join Free
TRENDING World Rugby issue findings from Nic White incident probe World Rugby issue findings on Nic White HIA probe