Steve Diamond lifts lid on failed 'Manchester City Sharks' pitch

“One of those teams won the league in each of those years so yes they were worse. If I was a fan of either of those four teams I would rather have been a fan of a team that won a trophy than didn’t.”

That’s true - I would too. With regard to Stormers I think their trophy was very much enabled by the fact that they weren’t playing in europe, so were able to rest their players much more than the non-SA teams were so I’m not sure whether I would or wouldn’t consider them to have had a better season than Leinster in 2022, but clearly Munster and Glasgow (respectively) had better seasons than Leinster in 2023 and 2024. But if I was a fan of one of those 3 teams I would rather be a fan of a team that won 66 URC+CC matches over the course of 3 seasons (Leinster) than a team that won 46 (Munster) or 42 (Glasgow). If you think trophies are literally the only thing that matters, do you think Blackburn Rovers are a more successful Premier League team than Tottenham Hotspur are?

“You contradict yourself alot. Trophies matter in one post and in the same post coming second consistently makes you better.”

Its going to get really frustrating if you’re not willing to read what I write. I said: “Trophies matter. They matter a lot. But so does winning games. So does making finals.” How does that contradict my assessment that Leinster were better than Stormers?

“I doubt Leinster would say they have been the better team in any of the seasons you keep going on about.”

Teams generally downplay talk of them being the best, so that wouldn’t surprise me. But crucially I don’t think Leinster were the best team in 2022, or in 2023, or in 2024, so I’m not sure what you think you’re responding to.

“Lets make it clear though - you are the one who went on and on about previous seasons with your deep dive into la Rochelle and Stormers etc.”

Yeah - I did that because you brought up Leinster’s trophyless record from 2022-2024, so I thought that was worth responding to. If you’d like though I can stop responding to the things you say?

The squad investment to replace those that departed will be informative, particularly when compared to the other provinces.

I don’t like Ikitau-Daugunu at all. Both left-sided, Daugunu not as reliable as Len on D… Lots of negatives.

I feel like Robbie Deans lost trust in Quade Cooper after the 2011 World Cup, which was somewhat understandable after his performances against South Africa and New Zealand. By the time 2013 rolled around, he was the right choice to play flyhalf.

Thats a fair call on the props too, there is potential there for a couple to go with Lomax, but I’d more call them serviceable than quality in re to the discussion of if they can take this backline to the top of the club world.

Though I give you he was also their in 19’, along with possibly the worse in Bridge..