Sonny Bill Williams is right. We’re overdue for a Pacific Island or Maori coach of the All Blacks and not just in an assistant’s or advisory role either.
In the same way New Zealand Rugby might benefit from a female chief executive, so the All Blacks could do with a Pasifika head coach.
At provincial level Alama Ieremia and Filo Tiatia have done well with Auckland, but Darryl Suasua’s just led Counties Manukau to relegation.
Wherever you look, the plentiful supply of Pasifika players at all levels of our game simply isn’t replicated in the coaching ranks and that’s a problem.
Rugby’s traditionally been a mono-culture. We work hard, we play hard and everyone’s equal. Or at least equal in the sense that anyone who’s different is made to conform to the prevailing view.
Australia’s Israel Folau couldn’t do that and look where it got him. More importantly, look at the team-mates who endorsed his infamous Instagram post.
The rest of us condemned Folau and rightly so. Or at least that’s what we told ourselves. After all, we’re right and he was patently wrong.
I’m not here to support Folau, but his employment issue with Rugby Australia provides an interesting illustration of how badly things can go wrong when management of one colour tell staff of another what they can and can’t do or say or think.
Let’s go back to Williams who, when asked to endorse Ian Foster’s candidacy as the next All Blacks head coach, instead said it would be nice to see Pacific Island or Maori coaches in the mix. After all, as Williams said, “there are a lot of island boys, a lot of Maori boys who play for the All Blacks.”
How much better might those guys play if they felt truly valued or included in team culture? No-one’s saying they’re excluded, but the hierarchy of that side is pretty Anglo-Saxon and almost always has been.
That’s fine if that’s the prevailing background of your players, but the issue now for rugby is it’s not.
— RugbyPass (@RugbyPass) November 2, 2019
Take a look at Tiatia, who’s assistant coach of Auckland and, by the looks, a million miles away from an All Blacks post.
He’s been a head coach of Ospreys in Wales, then Toyota Verblitz in Japan. From there he was assistant coach to Eddie Jones with Japan, before assistant and head coach roles with Super Rugby’s Sunwolves.
They’re pretty fair achievements and, if nothing else, suggest Tiatia’s held in high esteem overseas.
Here in New Zealand, though, he had schools, Development XV and B jobs before taking on the Auckland role with Ieremia.
— RugbyPass (@RugbyPass) November 2, 2019
Here’s a born-and-bred New Zealander, who went to traditional boys’ school Wellington College and became a Hurricane and All Black, has his own appreciation society in Wales, but can hardly get a coaching gig in his own country.
Something’s not quite right about that.
Maybe Tiatia’s a great coach, maybe he’s not. The problem is that we might never actually find out while he, and others with his background, are denied a meaningful opportunity.
People and their attitudes can change. Not so long ago the idea that a woman would be named New Zealand Rugby player of the year was laughable.
But last December Kendra Cocksedge became that woman and no-one regarded it as a joke. Instead it was fair recognition for a truly outstanding and dedicated player.
View this post on Instagram
"We can change anything together if we want to, as one." Siya Kolisi #RugbyWorldCup #EnglandRugby #Springboks #Southafrica #ENGvsRSA #rwc2019
We once looked upon Umaga’s ascension to the All Blacks’ captaincy as a watershed, but 14 years on from his retirement not a lot’s changed. The players at most levels of the game are still brown and the authority figures are still white.
But at least Williams has helped get a conversation started, as only he can. His play, and status within the All Blacks, might attract criticism but Williams is a pretty good citizen.
Not too many people think of those less fortunate than themselves and speak up for the underdog, but he does.
No, not every deed in Williams’ long career has been entirely honourable, but he’s matured into a real leader whose words have cut-through and weight.
Of course we should have Maori and Pacific Island coaches on the All Blacks’ staff, but unfortunately it’s going to take more than Sonny Bill Williams’ best wishes to make that happen.
The men in contention for the All Blacks head coaching gig are assembling some crack squads:
Sign up to our mailing list here and we’ll keep you up to the minute with weekly updates from the world of rugby.