Northern | US

Scotland v England: Talking points as the Red Roses score 12 tries at Murrayfield

at Murrayfield Stadium, Edinburgh

EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND - APRIL 18: Ellie Kildunne of England dives to score her team's first try during the Women's Guinness Six Nations 2026 match between Scotland and England at Scottish Gas Murrayfield on April 18, 2026 in Edinburgh, Scotland. (Photo by Molly Darlington - RFU/The RFU Collection via Getty Images)
Comments
1 Comment

A ruthless 12-try England performance put any talk of the Red Roses’ injury issues behind them and left Scotland wondering what was next after a disappointing home performance.

ADVERTISEMENT

An attendance of 30,498 people smashed the previous Scottish record for a standalone women’s sporting event. But only England ensured that the game was a spectacle as the world champions registered their 84-7 win to claim a second bonus point win in a row at this year’s Guinness Women’s Six Nations.

It took just seven minutes for the Red Roses to open the scoring as Ellie Kildunne crossed the try line. By the first half’s end the Harlequins full-back had bagged another, as did Meg Jones, Kelsey Clifford and Emma Sing.

VIDEO

Rhona Lloyd’s effort on the stroke of half-time sent Scotland fans into the break with plenty of hope in their hearts. Hearts that were shattered as England saw Sarah Bern dot down twice, as well as Emma Sing, Amy Cokayne, Marlie Packer, Sadia Kabeya, Mia Venner and Haineala Lutui efforts in the second half.

Here are three talking points from the match…

Feaunati provides much-needed spark

There are a few England performances you could highlight from this game. Like how Abi Burton seamlessly stepped in at lock forward or Demelza Short’s strong debut in the back-row. But it is Maddie Feaunati that really personified a dominant England performance in Scotland’s capital city.

Put plainly, she bossed it from minute one to minute 80. It was the perfect complete performance from an England No.8, who stepped into the big shoes of Alex Matthews and filled them admirably. For so much of the contest the 23-year-old was England’s lynchpin. The perfect interchange between forwards and backs.

When you consider the lengthy England injury list Feaunati provided the perfect tonic as others performed equally as admirably.

ADVERTISEMENT

A quick look over the stats sheet you see that Feaunati, unsurprisingly, carried the ball more than anyone else in the England team [17]. She even made the second-most metres [97m] to Emma Sing [110m].

Upon receiving her Player of the Match award, Feaunati said: “It felt really good and it was good to get out there with the girls at Murrayfield, what an amazing occasion. I am super proud of the girls, everyone was outstanding. The starters set the tone, the bench came on and scored tries and executed their role really well.”

Scotland fail to fizzle at landmark fixture

The scene was set. Shortly before kick-off it was confirmed that over 30,000 tickets had been sold for the Scottish Gas Murrayfield clash. Edinburgh heaved with supporters donning rugby shirts, tartan and humming Flower of Scotland. Even the theatrics of pre-match entertainment took Scottish anticipation to greater heights. Then kick-off, and it all fell away.

There was no lack of desire. Rhona Lloyd’s try on the stroke of half-time was proof of that. But did not wipe away the wing’s two missed tackles as the Red Roses put pedal to the metal with an Ellie Kildunne brace and efforts from Megan Jones, Kelsey Clifford and Emma Sing put the result beyond doubt at the halfway point.

The intensity that Scotland head coach Sione Fukofuka wanted to see his team perform with did arrive until the 60-minute mark as the Scots landed two huge tackles. Even then it was a flurry and it was just a matter of time until Marlie Packer burst over the try line.

ADVERTISEMENT

Then the hosts fell apart. The Red Roses scored three more tries before the final whistle. It was a battering usually only reserved for Mars Bars. A worst loss to England since 2011 [89-0]. The second-most points a Scotland Women’s team has ever conceded.

The only silver lining? That new attendance record. But that is clutching at straws.

Back three reshuffle allows England to thrive

Ahead of the Women’s Six Nations, England boss John Mitchell had discussed his desire to include Emma Sing in his squads more. The only issue there was getting the “balance right”.

This weekend the Kiwi put the Gloucester Hartpury in from the start at her favoured full-back position and placed Ellie Kildunne on the wing. As Kildunne claimed two first-half tries, you could argue that the shift around worked.

Sing was able to capture the form that has made her Premiership Women’s Rugby’s top player for much of the past three years. Whether that was with her footwork or ability to find a soft shoulder and put her teammates into space, the 25-year-old was provided the opportunity to shine. Which she duly did.

Unencumbered by her usual post of full-back, Kildunne’s brief for the afternoon was to attack. The 26-year-old’s raw speed slingshotted her over the whitewash and constantly provided line breaks. And, while Jess Breach did not get add to her tally of tries, there was nothing inherently wrong with the 28-year-old’s performance. This could well be the England back three that starts at Ashton Gate Stadium in a week’s time.

ADVERTISEMENT
Play Video
LIVE

{{item.title}}

Trending on RugbyPass

Comments

1 Comment
B
BC1812 181 days ago

England’s attack was lessened by Kildunne on the wing. Sing’s lack of speed meant she was a pale imitation of what Kildunne would have managed as full back. The Red Roses need a back 3 that are all very quick and Sing does not fit that bill, much better to have another quick winger and there are a number to choose from.

Join free and tell us what you really think!

Sign up for free
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Long Reads

Comments on RugbyPass

L
LouisJ 50 minutes ago
Wallabies player ratings vs New Zealand | Bledisloe Cup II 2026

I agree with a lot of what you are saying 2Cents. The forwards are too stationary and I think they are playing too many phases, hitting the ball up with nearly no gain, this also causes fatigue because they are wrestling to try make some post contact metres. They need to hit the ball at pace, which Bell did well during the later stages of the game. The All Blacks also did well to niggle enough to keep Lonergen from getting the ball out quick but the wallabies allowed the AB’s to niggle because they weren’t clearing effectively and sometimes not at all. That’s where Tom Hooper and Tupou are missed. Communication in the midfield was lacking but it’s hard to blame 2 guys that have never really played together. I still maintain that Su needs to be left on the wing as I don’t believe his defence is up to scratch in the midfield. I think they might have been better off playing Daugunu and Henry in the midfield and Su on the wing. Hopefully Henry can have some better performances with Ikitau or Paisami inside. Having Carter, Paisami, Ikitau, Jake Gordon, Hooper and Tupou back, will make a big difference, it is just a fact. There is definitely a lack of depth in the back for Wallabies, it was positive to see Meredith step up and HMP looked good as well in the limited time he had. Jorgo had a pretty average game today but he doesn’t usually have more than one average game at a time, he made a few mistakes but he has been one of our best for a number of games since last year so I think he deserves to be forgiven. Harry Wilson was also not as ruthless as he was last week, I agree, but the All Blacks did well containing him a bit more today. Harry made a couple of mistakes today, kicking the ball away, forcing a couple of passes and also not going for 3 points when the Wallabies were a man down with Williams off with the yellow card. Jeremy Williams needs to work on his discipline, he gives away crucial penalties and yellow cards far too often, he is such an important player to have on the field. I think the Wallabies were better today and I think they will step up in the Nations Championship. Kiss is moving in the right direction with the boys. Most importantly I believe they need to get their mental game sorted, then the need to get their defence structured and organised. I think the run of 12, now 13 losses in a row against the AB’s have a massive psychological effect on the guys and they so badly want to win that they are pushing passes, making wrong decisions and making mistakes as a result. I believe they have the skills to be great.

36 Go to comments
L
LouisJ 1 hour ago
All Blacks player ratings vs Australia | Bledisloe Cup II 2026

I agree with a lot of what you are saying. I also think the ratings are atleast 1 point to high across the board. Loose forwards look solid and there is certainly depth in that department. Front row is not bulletproof, there isn’t that much depth and the wallabies stood up very well in the scrum. I don’t think there is that much depth at lock either, I think Barret and Holland is a solid combination. I don’t think Tavatavanawai will be able to handle the likes of the Springboks or the French, and even the English, Irish and Scotts will run circles around him. Tavatavanawai will have a hard time against guys like Minocello and Chocobares as well. Jordy and Quin is a massive loss and Billy Proctor is missed as backup, AB’s seem to lack in depth in the midfield. DMAC played very well against the wallabies because of their terrible defence and the massive amount of space they gave him, but he will be far less effective against defensive structures like the springboks and France even probably Ireland and Scotland. I hope the Kiwi supporters stop whinging about Beauden Barret now, he just showed once again that he is still a very dangerous player. One thing that has to be said, is that Roigard is pure class. They only thing I don’t like is his whingin to the ref and TV dives, he had a couple of whinges again today, I hope he can drop that from his game because otherwise he is pure class and the other backups are far behind, I don’t think the AB’s have that much genuine depth at 9. I reckon there were some positives form the Wallabies performance today, but they would have been far more dangerous if they had Carter Gordon, Ikitau, Paisami, Hooper and Tupou in their 23 and if they can have a more solid backup at 9, like Jake Gordon or maybe one of the others coming through the ranks, they will look much better against the All Blacks.

15 Go to comments
Close Panel
Close Panel

Edition & Time Zone

{{current.name}}
Set time zone automatically
{{selectedTimezoneTitle}} (auto)
Choose a different time zone
Close Panel

Editions

Close Panel

Change Time Zone

Close
ADVERTISEMENT
Copied to clipboard

Share Article close