1
It would be churlish to judge Scotland too harshly after another titanic chapter in Japanese rugby history.
ADVERTISEMENT
The red and whites were great value for their win.
Scotland made 12 changes to the team which beat Russia earlier this week. Fraser Brown, Darcy Graham and Tommy Seymour are the only players selected for the starting XV who started earlier this week.
Seven players returned to the starting XV having been left out of the 23 altogether in midweek: Allan Dell, Jonny Gray, Blade Thomson, Greig Laidlaw, Finn Russell, Sam Johnson and Stuart Hogg.
Here’s how we rated the Scottish players.
1. ALLAN DELL
Executed an important tackle that led to a turnover in the 3rd minute. The lightweight prop struggled badly at scrum time however. Was angry at Ben O’Keefe, who seemed to blame the loosehead for Scotland’s scrum woes.
5
2. FRASER BROWN
Brown switched from flanker back to hooker for Scotland’s final pool phase match. Tried to milk a card after getting smashed by Kazuki Himeno, which wasn’t a good look.
5
3. WILLEM NEL
Made 14 tackles in the first half alone. Worked so, so hard. Part of a Scotland scrum under the pump- although they improved in secondhalf. Deserved his try that ignited a Scottish fightback.
ADVERTISEMENT
6
The IRFU are not happy. #RWC2019 https://t.co/n7XpSu9K9l
— RugbyPass (@RugbyPass) October 13, 2019
4. GRANT GILCHRIST
Made a nuisance of himself all evening, but out-goosed by smaller and more efficient Japanese opponents.
5.5
5. JONNY GRAY
The Glasgow lock was everywhere, tackling all in front of him and getting through a mountain of work. Lucky to get away with an accidental head-on-head hit on Shota Horie. Threw the assist for Fagerson’s try.
7.5
6. MAGNUS BRADBURY
He and Gilchrist missed a telling tackle on Matsushima in the lead up to second Japanese try. Scotland needed his power on both sides of the ball, but it was only there in fits and starts.
ADVERTISEMENT
5
7. JAMIE RITCHIE
Scotland’s outstanding forward. Huge if questionable turnover in the 11th minute with Japan on the Scottish try line. Did everything he could and deserves the least amount of blame.
8.5
8. BLADE THOMSON
Fell off too many tackles. Looked anonymous for much of the game. A few athletic carries were the highlight of the rather minor role he played in proceedings.
4.5
Japan get the win in an incredible performance #JPNvSCO #RWC2019 pic.twitter.com/ZTlunoovxE
— RugbyPass (@RugbyPass) October 13, 2019
9. GREIG LAIDLAW (CAPT.)
Laidlaw being named captain for the fifth time at a Rugby World Cup equaled the Scotland record held by David Sole and Bryan Redpath. Spent 52 minutes on the back foot before left the field looking pretty pissed off.
6
10. FINN RUSSELL
An early block down of a kick didn’t faze him, brilliantly scampering through for a try in the 5th minute. Looked to play ball and didn’t lack for endeavour despite the magnitude of the mountain Scotland were climbing in the secondhalf.
6.5
11. DARCY GRAHAM
Bit in leaving Scotland exposed in the 18th minute, leading to Japan’s first try. A costly mistake. Looked defensively naive at times.
5
12. SAM JOHNSON
Part of a midfield that was completely harried and outplayed by their opposite numbers. Needed to stand-up but he just didn’t get the opportunity.
4
13. CHRIS HARRIS
The lone bright spark in the midfield. Made metres whenever he got on the ball and made a few decent breakaways.
6.5
14. TOMMY SEYMOUR
Tried to make things happen on the odd opportunity he got the ball. Had a quiet tournament by his own high standards.
5.5
15. STUART HOGG
Poor. Did not look himself with multiple missed tackles and seeming inability to play himself into the game.
4
16. STUART MCINALLY
Brought huge energy to the game. Question has to be asked: why didn’t he start?
7
17. GORDON REID
Scrums were noticeably better with Reid and Fagerson on.
7
18. ZANDER FAGERSON
Deserves huge credit for being there to receive the pass from Gray for his 55th minute try.
8
19. SCOTT CUMMINGS
Looked eager and willing when he came on and played a crucial part in Fagerson’s try.
7
20. RYAN WILSON
NA
21.GEORGE HORNE
Scotland improved markably when he came on. He gave them the impetus and speed they lacked for the first 52 minutes.
7
22. PETE HORNE
Did a decent job chasing the game. Challenging game to come into.
6
23. BLAIR KINGHORN
Put pressure on the Japanese in his short time on the pitch.
6
Comments on RugbyPass
Super Rugby desperately needs to lose at least 2, but up to 4 teams. Rebels quietly going bankrupt would have made that a bit easier. Teams like the Rebels and Force serve only to weaken Australian Rugby and Super Rugby more widely. In 13 years in the comp the Rebels are yet to win more games than they lose in a season, have never finished in the top half of the competition, and have come dead last a number of times. The Western Force, barring a brief stint of mediocrity under John Mitchell from 2007-2009 have been even worse. Sadly it’s hard to see a future for Moana Pasifika in Super Rugby. Likewise I think the writing is on the wall for the Highlanders, it’s hard to see how NZ rugby can continue to support 5 SR teams, and population distribution suggests one team in the south island would make the most sense.
41 Go to commentsNice that Connor Evans is happy to stay on here, that JD Schikerling is returning and Steven Kitshoff. Dobbo is careful to bring back just anybody but having a new financial lease of life, it has made the Stormers a more attractive club. On top of being good quality, having the financial backing helps a lot
1 Go to commentsEngland-qualified too, I believe.
1 Go to commentsThis might turn out to be emblematic of a real issue in Irish rugby. Ireland have one of the best -if not the best - senior sides in the world, and one of the best under 20s sides as well, but don’t seem to be giving graduating under20s players many opportunities to break through into URC starting lineups. There is a risk that a lot of the junior talent they are developing will either be wasted, or lost to other nations.
1 Go to commentsYou ask good questions, Nick. The group who have put together the proposal to play out of Tarneit and participate in the growing of the ground’s capacity are not a bunch of white knights who have been dragged in post-crisis; they were around whilst the Rebels accummulated $23m in debt. Why do we come up with ideas that might make the franchise affordable after it’s broke and not when it might have prevented the trainwreck this offseason was? As for Gordon/Kellaway v Lolesio/Wright, they are both good options. I think the former are better rugby players but the goal kicking of Noah may be decisive when Schmiddy makes his choices. I know Harry Jones has the hots for Edmed but I think it’s one of his few poor choices and he and Jorgensen aren’t close to the other pairs. By coincidence, the wife and I went into town over the weekend to watch Brian Cox and Patricia Clarkson in Long Day’s Journey into Night. Beautifully acted but it was 3.5 hours in the chair and very hard work. Like the Rebels, there were only small bursts of joy to go with a lot of bad news and a depressing story line. In the end, I was hoping it would end and I could give my sore butt a break. Again, familiar.
41 Go to commentsGood decision, very good player but not international quality. But so was Jamison Gibson Park …..
3 Go to commentsLoose forwards always look good going forward and winning. It’s the same loose forwards for the Crusaders and the Canes this year as last year. Too much of the shiny new things getting noticed here while older consistent ones getting bagged. It’s early days. Calm the farm.
6 Go to commentsThanks Nick, and on the money. We tend to be apathetic until something REALLY BAD happens, then we aren't! At least this applies to the Reb players and coach, if not the spectators. They seem to be getting very quick ball at times. Have they altered something, or is it just all of the skills coming together at the right time? It seems almost the opposite of the Reds, who started the season with quick ball, but haven't been showing that in the last 3 losing games. Is it attitude (McDermott hasn't looked “right” to me for 3 weeks), or something else?
41 Go to commentsGood summary. As said, Sevu Reece has been electrifying for the Crusaders. Great try and he has been everywhere. Amazing he is now equal with Caleb Ralph , club record of 52 tries for the Crusaders. That record beckons. Good to see Dallas McLeod getting regular starts at last. A big few weeks are ahead.
6 Go to commentsGood article/interview.As was said Christian Lio-Willie was barnstorming when he came on for the Crusaders. What happened at the end, self-explanatory.Captain fantastic Scott Barrett is due back soon as well, once they are back from Aussie. Great to see Ethan Blackadder back last week.
1 Go to commentsYou must have been watching one team, Andrew - and even then you missed the brightest star in the Chiefs pack - Naitoa Ah Kuoi, 2 turnovers, genuine line-out presence and grunt around the field, and the soft hands of a back.
6 Go to commentsHaha what a crock of sh!t these headlines are. Moorby’s best year was that first. Still doesn’t seem to have the same game about him as when he was fresh but has bounced back well this season to be playing consistent tight accurate footy
3 Go to commentsIt’s even dumber than Bernard Foley not kicking the penalty to touch in the Melbourne Bledisloe in 2022.
3 Go to commentsYes, they are traveling well but it’s early days. The Chiefs were in front with 20 to go while they snatched a last minute win v the Reds. Keep calm.
1 Go to commentsThe failure of the Irish system / rugby playing style to produce their own backs has them looking elsewhere for innovation and flair - not that Jordie has much flair. He’s a converted fullback. The Canes have plenty of other younger options.
10 Go to comments1.Watch Wallace Sititi be the wild card AB. A genuine full time no 8 2. Luke J like Sotutu has not delivered. 3. Chiefs have all the right cattle but badly miss the leadership of Webber. LJ is about as unconvincing as Sam Cane when under the pump. They had the winning of that game in the second half then fell apart.
6 Go to commentsYes the Rebels are showing signs of life because they are literally playing for their live -lihoods and thanks to their Australian attack coach. However they are still playing an essentially dull boring south african style for the rest of the time. And Geoff Parling must be the most useless lineout coach ever. Worse than Steve Hansen even. Interestingly we are starting to see more cheap shots and attempts to get away with cheating by Australian players, now they are being influenced by Joe Schmidt. It was exactly the same when Rennie started out as Wallaby coach and thru his tenure. Trying to teach Australians to play like kiwis doesn’t work, as the last 20 years has conclusively demonstrated. Especially when we are not as good at it as kiwis. Which of course is the whole idea …..
41 Go to commentsGreat signing, not sure where he’ll fit in though. As for him ‘playing alongside RG Snyman, that’s highly debatable given the likelyhood that the latter will spend most of the season on sick leave.
10 Go to commentsWowee!
10 Go to commentsEvery team that has played a game in Africa this Champions Cup season is already out of the competition - including the SA teams. Could be a concidence.
30 Go to comments